Do Rhyming Poems Win Contests Anymore? A Judge Answers
Rhyme did not stop winning contests; bad rhyme did. A judge explains which rhyming poems still take prizes, why most fail, and gives five tests every rhyme should pass before you submit.
Out of the last three hundred poems I scored, ninety-four rhymed. Of those ninety-four, five made my shortlist and one won. Those numbers sound like an execution notice for rhyme, until you notice the other half of the ledger: the single rhyming winner beat two hundred free verse poems to do it. So when poets ask me whether rhyming poems win contests anymore, my honest answer is yes, absolutely, and also: probably not yours, not yet. The difference between the five that made my list and the eighty-nine that did not has nothing to do with fashion and everything to do with a single, fixable failure that shows up by line two.
Let me lay out what I actually see on the scoresheets, because this debate is usually argued by people who have never had to rank a stack of entries by Friday.
How Rhyme Got Its Bad Reputation
Judges do not walk in biased against rhyme. We walk in biased against what rhyme usually drags behind it. Three offenses account for nearly every rhyming rejection I write:
- Inverted syntax. Nobody says the garden gate I did behold. The sentence has been broken on the wheel to force a rhyme to the end of the line, and every reader hears the bones crack.
- The predictable pair. Love and above. Heart and apart. Fire and desire. When I can guess your rhyme word before I reach it, the line pays me nothing for reading it.
- Rhyme-driven meaning. The poem says something not because the poet believes it but because it rhymed. You can feel the poem swerve, the way a car swerves for an exit the driver almost missed.
Notice that none of these is a crime of rhyming. They are crimes of letting the rhyme drive the bus. Free verse has its own equivalent failures, they are just quieter: the line break that means nothing, the prose paragraph wearing a poem's clothes. But a botched rhyme announces itself like a dropped tray, which is why weak rhyming poems die faster in a contest pile than weak free verse does.
The Rhyming Poems Contests Actually Reward
Here is the pattern in the ones that survive. The winning rhymers in my experience share three habits.
First, the sentence wins every argument with the rhyme. Read the poem aloud and you hear a person speaking naturally; the rhymes seem almost accidental, discovered rather than installed. That is enormous craft disguised as ease.
Second, they reach past the obvious pair. Slant rhyme, half rhyme, consonance: soul and all, room and worm, given and heaven. Emily Dickinson built a whole cosmology on rhymes that lean instead of click. Her most famous quatrain runs:
Hope is the thing with feathers,
That perches in the soul,
And sings the tune without the words,
And never stops at all.
Soul and all is not a perfect rhyme, and that slight off-ness is exactly what keeps the stanza from sounding like a music box. If slant rhyme is new territory for you, the glossary entry on slant rhyme is a fifteen-minute education that will change how you hear your own endings.
Third, the form is load-bearing. In the strongest formal entries, the rhyme scheme does emotional work: a villanelle's returning lines enact obsession, a sonnet's final couplet lands like a verdict. The form is not a costume the poem wears. It is the skeleton the poem cannot stand without.
A Couplet Fixed in Front of You
Theory is cheap, so let me do the repair live. Here is a couplet of the kind I see forty times a month, written by me in the style of the pile:
I wandered through the garden fair
and saw my one true love stood there.
Every failure we listed is present. Fair is padding that exists to rhyme with there. Stood there is syntax bent backward. Garden, love, wandering: three stock props and no evidence a specific human ever lived this. Now the same gesture, rebuilt so the sentence leads and the rhyme leans:
I walked the garden out of season,
looking for you, or any reason.
Season and reason still chime, but the second line arrives as a thought, not a delivery. Out of season does actual work: the garden is dead, the visit is wrong-timed, the speaker knows it. And the swerve at the end, or any reason, admits something true about grief that the first version was too busy rhyming to notice. That is the whole game in two lines: the rhyme survived, the furniture-moving did not.
Five Tests Your Rhymes Must Pass Tonight
Before you submit a rhyming poem anywhere, run each rhyme through this sequence. It takes ten minutes and it is the ten minutes most entrants skip.
- The spoken test. Read the poem aloud to an empty room. Anywhere your voice trips or your word order sounds like a legal document, the rhyme has bent the sentence. Rewrite the sentence first, then find the rhyme again.
- The cover test. Cover each rhyme word and ask a friend to guess it. If they guess right more than twice in the whole poem, your rhymes are on rails. Reach for the slant option, or rebuild the line so the expected word cannot fit.
- The subtraction test. Rewrite one stanza as plain prose. If the prose says exactly what the stanza says, the rhyme was decoration. A rhyme should create meaning you cannot get without it: an irony, a click of inevitability, a joke.
- The freight test. Rhyme spotlights line endings, so audit yours. If your end words are the, there, so, and it, you have hung lanterns on your emptiest luggage. End lines on nouns and verbs that could carry the poem alone.
- The belief test. Find every claim the poem makes and ask whether you would still assert it in prose. Anything you only said because it rhymed gets cut, no appeals.
What the Scoresheet Sees
A structural note from the judging side, because scoring rubrics quietly favor skilled formal poets. Writory's judges, for instance, score every entry on five criteria: creativity, emotion, structure, language, and theme, and every entrant sees that breakdown when results land on the 30th. A rhyming poem executed with real control tends to bank the structure score almost automatically, which is an edge free verse has to earn some other way. The same rubric punishes forced rhyme twice, though: once under language, where the inversions live, and once under emotion, where the reader stopped believing you. Rhyme raises the ceiling and lowers the floor. That is the honest trade.
A poem I scored last winter made the trade look easy. It was a rhymed poem about a father's dementia, and the poet let the rhyme scheme itself decay: crisp couplets in the first stanza, slant pairs in the second, and by the final stanza the rhymes had dissolved entirely, the form forgetting itself the way the father did. I gave it the highest structure score I awarded that month. Nobody who read it talked about whether rhyme is old-fashioned. The technique was the meaning.
Should You Rhyme Your Next Contest Entry?
Here is my actual advice, stripped of diplomacy. If rhyme is how your ear naturally works, rhyme, and rehearse the five tests until they are reflex. If you are rhyming because you believe contests expect poems to rhyme, stop: no serious contest does, and the belief will cost you entries. And if you have never written formal verse at all, try one poem in form this month anyway, because even a failed sonnet teaches you more about line control than a dozen safe free verse drafts. Browse any archive of past winners and you will find both camps standing on the podium, usually in the same year.
Rhyme should feel like fate arriving, not furniture being pushed through a doorway.
Fate is the standard. When a rhyme lands as the only word that could possibly end that line, and also the word nobody saw coming, judges do not score it as old-fashioned. We score it as inevitable, and inevitability wins contests in every era. When your next rhyming poem passes all five tests, send it into the pile. I promise you the judges are not counting rhymes. We are listening for the bus driver, and hoping, every single time, that it is you behind the wheel and not the rhyme.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.