Not Writing for Months? A Judge Defends Dry Spells
A poetry judge argues that months without writing are usually a fallow season, not a failure, explains what the silence is doing for your poems, and maps five steps back to the page.
The strongest poem I scored last year came from a woman who had gone eleven months without a single draft. She confessed it in her entry note, half apology, the way people admit to a lapsed gym membership. Her poem was about pruning an apple tree in February: cutting living wood so the tree could afford its own fruit. If not writing for months has you doing guilt math at two in the morning, I want to make the case that the silence is usually not the emergency you think it is. Sometimes it is the pruning, and the fruit is already deciding where to grow.
The Guilt Math Every Poet Does
Here is the arithmetic that runs in a silent poet's head. Real writers write every day. I have written nothing since spring. Therefore I am not a real writer. The logic feels airtight in the dark, and it is wrong at every step. I have judged thousands of contest entries, and I can tell you plainly: daily writers do not dominate the winners' list. Not even close. The winners' list is full of seasonal writers, binge writers, grief-interrupted writers, new parents who wrote four poems that year and made all four count.
The daily practice myth comes from novelists, who need momentum the way long-haul trucks need fuel. A poem is not a long haul. A poem is a struck match. Nobody asks whether the match was practicing every day before it lit.
What Not Writing for Months Actually Does to a Poet
Farmers have a word for a field deliberately left unplanted: fallow. Not abandoned, not barren. Resting on purpose, while the soil rebuilds what constant harvest strips out. I have come to believe most dry spells are fallow seasons, and the evidence is in the poems that end them. They are almost never timid. They arrive with unusual density, as if the unwritten months had been compressing material the whole time.
There is a reason for that. While you were not writing, you were still metabolizing. The argument with your sister, the hospital corridor, the bookstore you hid in for a whole rainy afternoon: all of it was settling into the deep storage a poem draws from. Rilke, who went years between his great bursts, treated those silences as gestation and defended them fiercely; anyone who reads his letters can watch a master refuse to panic. The panic, not the pause, is what damages poets.
A dry spell is not the absence of writing. It is writing done with the pen down.
Composting: What to Do Instead of Forcing Drafts
A fallow field is not ignored. It is tended differently. During my own longest silence, eight months after my mother died, I could not write a line, but I could read, and I read the way some people drink. I stood in the poetry aisle of a secondhand bookstore most Saturdays, pulling collections I would never have chosen in a productive season. That reading turned out to be composting: everything went in green and came out, months later, as soil. The first poem I finished afterwards borrowed its spine from a Polish poet I had never heard of before that bookstore, a woman whose collected works cost me three dollars and repaid me a whole season of work. You cannot plan that kind of debt. You can only be in the aisle when it happens.
Tend your fallow season with inputs, not outputs:
- Read outside your taste. Productive seasons narrow us to poets who resemble our current project. Dry spells are for the strange shelf, the translations, the forms you claim not to like.
- Keep a scrap file, not a notebook. One line overheard on a bus. A phrase from a seed catalogue. No pressure to develop anything. You are gathering, not building.
- Memorize one poem. Carrying someone else's rhythms in your body rebuilds the ear faster than any exercise I know.
- Walk without headphones once a week. Boredom is the mother tongue of imagery, and we have almost engineered it out of our lives.
The Poem That Came Back First
When my own silence broke, the first draft was terrible, and I want to show you exactly how terrible, because the ugliness of the first poem back stops more comebacks than the silence itself. My draft opened: It has been so long since I have written and I do not know if I remember how. A poem about not writing poems: the most common first-poem-back in the world, and judges see hundreds of them.
Three drafts later, the poem had stopped staring at itself and looked out the window instead: The pen works. I checked it on the back of a receipt, / a small blue storm over the price of bread. Same subject, but now it has a receipt, a price, a small blue storm. The way back is never through announcing your return. It is through the first concrete thing your eye lands on. If your comeback draft is about the dry spell itself, keep the energy and swap the subject.
The Fallow Field Protocol: Five Steps Back to the Page
When the season turns, and it will, do not vault back to your old standards. Reenter on a gradient.
- Write one sentence of description a day for a week. Not a poem. A sentence, about something you can currently see. This is stretching, not sprinting.
- In week two, break the best three sentences into lines. Play with where they snap. You are reminding your hands how enjambment feels, the way a cyclist relearns balance in one wobbly minute.
- Write one deliberately bad poem. Full permission, twelve lines, no revising. The perfectionism that helped cause the silence dies in this step or not at all.
- Revise one old draft before writing anything new. Revision is lower stakes than creation and rebuilds judgment first, which is the muscle that atrophies least.
- Finish one small poem and let one other human see it. A friend, a workshop, a contest. The circuit is not complete until the work leaves the house.
Most poets I coach are writing steadily again within six weeks of step one. Not because the protocol is magic, but because it replaces the impossible demand, be who you were, with a possible one: do the next small thing.
When the Dry Spell Is Telling You Something Else
I owe you one caution, because I have seen the other kind. Sometimes months of silence are not fallow. If the silence extends past writing into everything, if the books have gone quiet too, if nothing you used to love has flavor, that pattern can be depression wearing a writer's block costume, and it deserves a doctor, not a protocol. A fallow field still hums with life underneath: worms turning, roots trading minerals, the whole quiet economy of recovery. If you press your ear to your days and hear nothing at all, no hum, no appetite, no color, please treat that as information about your health, not your talent, and take it to someone qualified to help.
For everyone else, the grief seasons and the new-baby seasons and the two-jobs seasons: the field is doing what fields do. Some of the best work in our archive of past winners came from poets who mentioned, almost sheepishly, that this was their first poem in a year. The judges never guessed. The poems had the density of stored seasons.
The Field Is Not Empty
Here is what I wish someone had told me during my own eight quiet months. The question is not how long has it been. The question is what is accumulating. A poet who lives attentively through a wordless year and then writes four poems has had a better year than one who produced two hundred drafts about having nothing to say.
So stop counting the days since your last poem. Start tending the field: read strangely, gather scraps, walk unplugged, and when the first shoot appears, follow the five steps and be gentle with the ugly first draft. When something small and true finally stands up out of the soil, send it into the world while it is still warm. Our contest runs every month, entries open from the 1st to the 25th, and every entrant gets a full score breakdown across five criteria, which makes it a kind way to test the ground after a long winter. The field was never empty. It was getting ready.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.