Writing a Villanelle? Be Obsessed First
The villanelle's nineteen lines and two refrains reward one emotional state above all others: obsession. A contest judge shows how to build the form backwards, refrains first, and when to break it.
The best villanelle I ever scored was about a phone number. The poet's mother had died, the landline had been disconnected, and the refrain was the number itself, seven digits returning again and again like a hand reaching for a phone that no longer rings. By the final stanza those digits had stopped being information and become incantation. I have judged thousands of poems and I can still type that number from memory. That is what writing a villanelle can do when the poet understands the secret of the form, and what it never does when they do not. The secret is this: the villanelle is not a rhyme scheme. It is a diagnosis.
The Form Is a Machine for Obsession
Here is the mechanism, quickly. Nineteen lines, five tercets and a closing quatrain, two rhymes only, and two refrain lines that take turns ending the stanzas until they finally collide as the last two lines of the poem. Line one comes back four times. Line three comes back four times. You cannot get away from them. Neither can the reader.
Now ask what human experience actually works like that. Not mild interest. Not a pleasant afternoon. Grief works like that. Insomnia works like that. Regret, addiction, jealousy, prayer: anything the mind circles at 3 a.m. and cannot put down. The form's structure of return is the structure of a thought you cannot stop thinking, which is why the famous villanelles of the last century are about dying fathers, lost lovers, and losing things in general. The poets did not choose the form and then hunt for a subject. The subject was already circling, and the form gave the circling a shape.
Contrast that with the villanelles I see written as assignments. The rhymes arrive on schedule, the refrains return on cue, and nothing is at stake. Reading one is like watching someone pace a room they could leave at any time. The pacing only becomes drama when the door is locked.
So my first piece of advice about writing a villanelle is disqualifying rather than instructive: if you are not obsessed with something, do not write one. Write it the month your mind has a splinter in it. The form will feel like relief instead of homework.
Writing a Villanelle Backwards: Refrains First
Most poets fail at this form because they draft it in reading order, line one to line nineteen, and discover at line fifteen that their refrains have nothing left to give. The refrains are the load-bearing walls. You build them first.
Each refrain must pass three tests before you write anything else. It must be a complete grammatical unit that can end a sentence. It must be plain enough to survive four repetitions without embarrassment, which rules out your most ornate line. And it must be ambiguous enough to change meaning as its context changes, because a refrain that means exactly the same thing all four times is a chorus, not a poem. Our glossary entry on the refrain goes deeper into that last test, and it is the one that separates working villanelles from exercises.
A quick check I use: write your candidate refrain at the top of a page, then write four different sentences that could sit directly before it. If the line means the same thing after all four setups, discard it. If it flickers, if it reads as tender after one setup and bitter after another, you have found a refrain with four lives in it, and the villanelle needs every one of them.
What Robinson Knew About Plainness
Edwin Arlington Robinson published a villanelle called The House on the Hill in 1897, and its opening tercet is a masterclass in refrain selection:
They are all gone away,
The House is shut and still,
There is nothing more to say.
Look at how ordinary those refrain lines are. They are all gone away: seven plain words a child could speak. There is nothing more to say: another seven. No metaphor, no decoration. And that plainness is exactly why the poem devastates, because each return lands like the same fact refusing to become less true. By the end, there is nothing more to say has said everything, and has also become a small lie, since the poem kept talking anyway, the way mourners do. Robinson understood that a refrain is a stone worn smooth: it must be handled nineteen lines' worth of times, so it cannot have sharp ornament on it.
The Two Refrains Must Fight
Here is a worked pair of refrains I drafted to demonstrate the principle. Suppose the obsession is a daughter who stopped calling home:
Refrain A: I leave the porch light on for you.
Refrain B: You know the way; you always knew.
Notice the relationship. A is an action in the present, faithful, a little pathetic, wholly within the speaker's control. B is an accusation dressed as reassurance, aimed at the absent person, wholly outside the speaker's control. One is hope; the other is blame. Every stanza between them becomes an argument the speaker is having with herself, and when the two lines finally sit together at the poem's end, hope and blame in one breath, the collision does the emotional work automatically. If your two refrains agree with each other, your villanelle has no engine. They should be a couple mid-quarrel, forced to share the last room of the house.
A villanelle does not repeat itself. It keeps failing to escape itself.
A Six-Step Build You Can Run Tonight
- Name the splinter. Write one sentence describing the thought you cannot stop thinking. If you have to search for one, save the form for a worse month.
- Draft ten candidate refrains. Plain words, complete units, each able to end a sentence. Cross out anything clever.
- Pick the two that disagree. One line the speaker controls, one line the speaker does not. Check they share a rhyme sound with plenty of available partners: day, say, away, stay, gray beats orange every time.
- List your rhyme bank before drafting. Write fifteen words for each of your two rhyme sounds in the margin. This is the step everyone skips and the reason most villanelles die in stanza four with three rhymes left to find.
- Draft the quatrain first. Write the ending where both refrains collide. Now every earlier stanza has a destination.
- Fill the middle tercets as escape attempts. Each stanza should try a new angle on the obsession, memory, blame, bargaining, and fail back into the refrain. The failure is the poem.
When to Loosen the Bolts
Strict repetition is the tradition, but the modern masters bend it. Elizabeth Bishop famously varied her refrains, letting the repeated line mutate a few words at a time, and the mutations enacted the speaker's unraveling better than perfect repetition could have. I score loosened villanelles regularly and I hold them to one standard: the variation must mean something. Changing the refrain because you could not make the original fit is a patch. Changing it because the speaker can no longer say the original sentence honestly is craft. If you want to see the strict skeleton before you start bending it, the full pattern is laid out on our villanelle form page, and the grief theme collection shows how often this form and that subject find each other.
The Door That Keeps Reappearing
The phone number poem did win its month, and the scorecard tells you why: near-perfect marks for structure and emotion, because in a true villanelle those two criteria become the same criterion. The form is the feeling. When we return five-part score breakdowns to every poet at the end of each contest cycle, villanelles are the poems where the structure score most reliably predicts everything else, and if you finish one this month, the 25th is the deadline to send it in and see how the machine you built actually runs.
One warning to end on. The villanelle will not make you obsessed, and it punishes pretenders: fake circling reads as filler by stanza three, and judges feel it before they can name it. But if something already has its hooks in you, if there is a sentence your mind keeps saying at red lights, you are holding the raw material of the most architecturally satisfying form in English. Build the two walls first. Let them argue. Then live inside the argument for nineteen lines and see what the collision at the bottom of the poem finally admits.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.