What Winning a School Writing Contest Taught Me
Years before judging poems for a living, I won a school contest with a poem about my grandfather's boots. Six lessons from that week still shape how I write and score today.
The poem that won my school writing contest was about my grandfather's boots, and I nearly did not enter it. I was fourteen. I had written something grander for the occasion, a piece about war and history with words I had to look up to use, and at the last minute my English teacher read both and tapped the boots poem with one finger. Enter this one, she said. It came first, and the grand one would not have placed, and understanding why took me another decade and a judging table of my own. A school writing contest looks like a small thing: a form, a deadline, a certificate in assembly. Mine turned out to be the hinge my whole writing life swung on, and not for the reasons anyone tells you.
The Certificate Is Not the Prize
Let me get the obvious out of the way. The certificate faded. The small prize money went to a bookshop within the week. Nobody in my adult life has ever asked about it. If a school writing contest were only its trophies, it would not be worth an essay.
The actual prizes were invisible and permanent: a deadline that forced a finish, a stranger's judgment I could not argue with, and one piece of evidence that words I made could move a person I had never met. Every serious writer I know can point to an early moment like that. It is rarely a publication. It is almost always a contest, a teacher, or a stage, some first collision between private writing and public consequence.
What a School Writing Contest Really Tests
Here is what I did not understand at fourteen and understand thoroughly now, having sat on the other side of the table: a contest does not test how good a writer you are. It tests five narrower, more learnable things.
- Can you finish? Most students who intend to enter never submit. The deadline eliminates more people than the judging does.
- Can you choose your best work rather than your most impressive work? My teacher's finger on the boots poem was this exact test, taken for me.
- Can you follow instructions? Word limits, themes, formatting. Judges disqualify or downgrade over these constantly, and it is the least poetic, most decisive skill in the room.
- Can you move a stranger with no context? Your friends know your grandfather died. The judge only knows what the page says.
- Can you survive the result? Winning tests this too, in ways nobody warns you about.
Every one of those five is trainable, and most of them are trainable in a single school term. The students who win repeatedly are almost never the most naturally gifted writers in the building. They are the ones who submit every time, who finish, who read the rules, and who learned early to trust the boots over the war. Notice that raw talent appears nowhere on that list. This is the most encouraging fact I know about contests, and almost no student believes it until they judge one.
Lesson One: The Small True Thing Beats the Big Borrowed Thing
My war poem had everything a fourteen-year-old thinks judges want: importance, vocabulary, sweep. The boots poem had my grandfather's actual boots by the door, still holding the shape of his feet a year after he died. One image was borrowed from books. One was mine alone, and could not have been written by any other student in that school.
As a judge now, I watch this exact contest play out in every stack I score. The entries divide cleanly into poems reaching up toward Big Subjects and poems reaching down into a specific life, and the second kind wins so reliably that I can often sort the shortlist by that criterion alone. If you take one line from this piece into your next entry, take this one.
Judges do not reward the biggest subject. They reward the only witness.
Lesson Two: Winning Teaches You Less Than the Week After
Here is the part of the story nobody frames. The week after I won, two things happened. A boy in my class said the contest was rigged because his story was better, and I discovered I could not write anything for a month because everything I started had to be as good as the boots poem now.
Both were more educational than the win. The first taught me that public writing attracts public opinion, and that this is the price of admission, not a malfunction. The second taught me that a win can become a weight if you let one lucky poem set your permanent standard. The cure, I eventually learned, is volume: write the next thing badly on purpose, then the next, until the muscle loosens again. Winners who never learn this quietly stop writing, and I have watched it happen to genuinely gifted students. Losing stings for a week. Winning wrongly handled can cost you a year.
Lesson Three: The Revision Happened Out Loud
The boots poem got good in a single evening, and I can tell you the exact mechanism: my teacher made me read it to her aloud, twice. The first time, I stumbled on the same three lines she had already marked. Nothing exposes a dead line like your own mouth. Here is the kind of repair that session produced, reconstructed honestly.
Before:
His boots remain there by the door,
reminding us of days of yore.
After:
His boots still hold the shape of him.
Nobody moves them. Nobody says why.
The before version rhymed, and I was proud of the rhyme, and the rhyme was the whole problem: it forced days of yore, a phrase no grieving family has ever spoken. Cutting the rhyme freed the true detail underneath. If rhyme keeps steering your poems into words you would never say, read our glossary entry on slant rhyme, which is the compromise that saved half my later poems, and study how free verse handles endings at the free verse page before your next entry.
Your Next Contest: A Six-Point Checklist
Everything above compresses into a sequence you can run this term.
- Write three candidates, not one. You cannot choose your best work if there is only one work. Three short pieces beat one long labored piece.
- Pick the entry with the most specific detail, not the biggest theme. Ask which piece contains a detail nobody else in your school could have written. Enter that one.
- Read the rules twice and obey them exactly. Word count, theme, deadline, format. Treat the rules as round one of the judging, because they are.
- Read your entry aloud to one adult who will be honest. Mark every stumble. The stumbles are the revision list.
- Submit two days early. The deadline-night crowd submits typos. The early crowd submits proofread work. This alone moves you up the stack.
- Decide in advance what a loss means. Write it down before results: a loss means one judge, one month, one poem. Students with that sentence waiting recover in days. Students without it sometimes never enter again.
The Hinge Is Available Every Month
I got one contest a year at school, which meant one deadline, one verdict, one chance to learn the lessons above. You are luckier. The contest structure that changed my writing life now runs on a monthly cycle, open internationally, which means the finish-choose-submit-survive loop can happen twelve times a year instead of once.
The feedback is better than mine was, too. My certificate came with no explanation at all; I never learned what the judge actually saw in the boots. Writory's monthly contest scores every entrant, not only the winners, across creativity, emotion, structure, language, and theme, so even a losing month hands you a map for the next one. Entries run from the 1st to the 25th, and if you have a poem with one detail only you could have witnessed, enter it and see your score. Reading a few pieces from past winners first is the fastest way to calibrate what specific and true look like at full strength.
Somewhere in your notebook is your version of the boots by the door, and it is probably the piece you think is too small to enter. It is not too small. It is the only entry in the stack that could not have come from anyone else, and I am telling you, from the far side of the judging table, that this is precisely the thing we are looking for.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.