Success Is Counted Sweetest by Emily Dickinson
Quick answer: Success Is Counted Sweetest by Emily Dickinson, explained line by line: the theme of desire and defeat, its common metre, imagery, and lessons for poets.
Success Is Counted Sweetest is one of the very few poems Emily Dickinson saw published in her lifetime, appearing anonymously in the 1878 anthology A Masque of Poets, where some readers guessed Emerson had written it. She had composed it around 1859, in her late twenties, and it already carries her signature move: a calm, aphoristic opening that turns out to conceal a battlefield.
The poem's argument is a paradox stated with the confidence of arithmetic. Only those who fail can truly measure success. The winners hold the prize; the losers alone understand what it weighs.
What the poem says
The first stanza is pure aphorism: success seems sweetest to those who never succeed. To comprehend a nectar, Dickinson adds, requires 'sorest need'. The thirsty know sweetness in a way the satisfied cannot.
The second stanza moves to a battlefield. Not one soldier of the victorious army, the 'purple Host' who took the flag today, can define victory as clearly as the defeated man can. The third stanza finds him: dying, forbidden the triumph, while the distant strains of the winners' celebration break on his ear, agonised and clear. The whole poem funnels from general maxim to one soldier's final minutes, and the abstraction 'success' ends as a sound heard by a man who will never hold it.
How it works
Formally this is Dickinson doing her quiet subversion of hymn metre: three quatrains, mostly iambic trimeter, second and fourth lines rhyming, the shape of church song carrying a distinctly unconsoling message. The compression is extreme. 'Comprehend a nectar' compacts a whole theory of knowledge through deprivation into three words.
The structure is a telescope. Stanza one states the law, stanza two applies it to armies, stanza three zooms to a single ear on a single dying man. Her word choices sharpen as the camera closes in: the victors get one splendid blur of a phrase, while the loser gets 'defeated', 'dying', 'forbidden', each one exact. Manuscript dashes are usually modernised to commas in print, as here.
Why it lasts
Written on the eve of the American Civil War, the poem gained terrible relevance within two years, but its staying power is not historical. It survives because the paradox is true across every field of human wanting: the reader who never won the prize, the writer collecting rejections, the athlete who came fourth. Dickinson gives loss a form of expertise, a strange dignity, and readers in every generation have needed that.
It also displays her genius for scale, proving that a twelve-line poem in a borrowed hymn shape can carry an idea philosophers write chapters about.
What today's poet can steal
Steal the telescope structure: open with a general claim, test it on a group, then land on one individual whose experience proves it. The final image should be sensory, not conceptual; Dickinson ends on sound, not on a moral. Also steal her habit of giving the argument to the loser. Poems about winners tend toward speech-making, while poems about the defeated tend toward truth. If you enter contests, this poem is worth rereading after a near miss; it is the best consolation in the language, and it doubles as a reminder that wanting the win sharpens the work.
What poets can take from this
- Open with an aphorism, then spend the rest of the poem making it cost something.
- Move from the general to one person; end inside a single body or sense.
- Try hymn metre (alternating four and three beats) when you want quiet authority.
- Give your sharpest, plainest words to the defeated figure, not the victor.
- End on a sensory image rather than a stated moral.
Try it yourself
Write a three-stanza poem that argues only the person who lost something can define it, moving from a general claim to a crowd to one individual, and ending on a sound.
Questions
What is the theme of Success Is Counted Sweetest?
The theme is that success is understood most deeply by those who fail to achieve it. Deprivation sharpens perception: the thirsty comprehend nectar, and the dying soldier understands victory better than the winners celebrating nearby.
What metre is Success Is Counted Sweetest written in?
It is written in Dickinson's characteristic hymn-derived form: three quatrains of mostly iambic trimeter with a four-beat opening movement, rhyming on the second and fourth lines of each stanza.
Was Success Is Counted Sweetest published in Dickinson's lifetime?
Yes, unusually for Dickinson. It appeared anonymously in the 1878 anthology A Masque of Poets, one of only a handful of her poems printed while she lived.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.