New Formalism
Quick answer: New Formalism revived rhyme, metre and narrative in American poetry from the 1980s. Its history, arguments and how to learn from formal craft today.
New Formalism is the American movement, gathering force through the 1980s and 90s, that revived rhyme, metre and narrative at a time when free verse dominated magazines and writing programmes almost completely. Its poets argued that form is not a costume from the past but a living technology, and that abandoning it had cost poetry both music and general readers.
The movement arrived with a public argument attached. Dana Gioia's 1991 essay 'Can Poetry Matter?' claimed poetry had retreated into a subsidised academic subculture, and formal craft plus storytelling was offered as part of the way back. Whatever side you take, the debate clarified questions every poet still faces: who is the poem for, and what does form buy?
History and Key Figures
Scattered formalists never disappeared, Richard Wilbur and Anthony Hecht wrote metrically through every fashion, but the self-aware movement dates from the early 1980s, when younger poets began publishing manifestos and anthologies. Timothy Steele made the scholarly case in Missing Measures; Gioia became the public face; Molly Peacock, Rachel Hadas, Mark Jarman and Robert McDowell, whose journal The Reaper pushed narrative verse, filled out the ranks. Marilyn Hacker demonstrated that received forms could carry entirely contemporary lives.
The anthology Rebel Angels (1996) consolidated the group, and the annual West Chester conference became its schoolhouse, teaching metrics to a generation of writers.
What the New Formalists Actually Argue
Three claims recur. Metre is a means of memorability and music, not a political statement. Narrative reconnects poetry with readers who love stories. And form is generative: the search for a rhyme forces discoveries the free-verse poet never stumbles into. An invented couplet shows the last point: 'I meant to write forgiveness, rhymed on give, / and found the word I dodged for years was live.' The rhyme did the thinking.
Critics answered that the movement was nostalgic or politically conservative; its poets replied that villanelles have no party. The quarrel itself, notably civil by poetry standards, enriched craft discussion on both sides.
Learning From It, Whatever You Write
Spend a month drafting in strict iambic pentameter, not to publish but to install the pulse; afterwards your free verse will manage rhythm deliberately instead of accidentally. Try one narrative poem with a beginning, middle and end. Structure is among the criteria Writory judges score each month, and poets with formal training tend to control it visibly, even in unrhymed work. Form, like scales for a pianist, is practice that never shows and always tells.
What poets can take from this
- Drill metre privately: a sonnet a week for two months will change your ear permanently.
- Use rhyme as a discovery engine; accept only rhymes that surprise you into better meaning.
- Tell one complete story in verse, with characters and consequence, at least once a year.
- Read Wilbur or Hacker to see received forms carrying modern speech without strain.
- Never let the metre bully the sentence; the best formal lines sound inevitable, not upholstered.
Try it yourself
Write a poem of five rhymed quatrains telling the true story of a small domestic disaster, a burnt dinner, a lost key, a flooded bathroom, and let the strict form play against the chaos of the events.
Questions
What is New Formalism reacting against?
The near-total dominance of free verse in postwar American poetry, especially in universities and magazines by the 1970s. The movement argued this monoculture had cost poetry music, memorability and common readers, and offered metre and narrative as remedies.
Is formal poetry old-fashioned?
Only if written old-fashionedly. New Formalists set sonnets in supermarkets and wrote metrical poems about divorce, television and commuting. The claim is that form is a permanent resource, like melody in music, not a period style.
Who are the main New Formalist poets?
Dana Gioia, Timothy Steele, Molly Peacock, Rachel Hadas, Mark Jarman, Robert McDowell and R. S. Gwynn are usually listed, with elders like Richard Wilbur and Anthony Hecht as models and Marilyn Hacker as a fellow traveller.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.