Poetry Prompt Jar Ideas
Quick answer: Poetry prompt jar ideas you can cut out today: 14 original slips, themed jar recipes, and a method for turning a random draw into a finished poem.
The prompt jar is the least glamorous tool in a poet's kitchen and one of the most reliable. A jam jar, thirty slips of paper, and a rule that you must write whatever you pull. Its power is ceremony: the twist of the lid, the paper unfolding, the small verdict in your palm. Unlike scrolling a website for the perfect prompt, a jar forbids browsing, and browsing is just procrastination wearing glasses.
The craft secret is in how you write the slips. A slip that says 'the sea' will sit damp and useless in your hand. A slip that says 'the sea, as described by someone who cannot swim, to someone who drowned' has a speaker, a listener and a wound. Load the jar with situations, not subjects.
The Prompts
Copy these fourteen slips into your own jar, then add sixteen more in the same spirit: every slip should contain either a scene, a constraint or a first line, never a bare noun.
- First line slip: 'The last time I lied, it was raining indoors.' Continue for at least twelve lines without explaining the indoor rain.
- Write from the point of view of the jar itself, full of everyone's unwritten poems, watching you hesitate.
- A slip with one word: 'unsalted'. Your poem must be about a marriage and use the word exactly once, in the final line.
- Describe the contents of a stranger's shopping basket, then reveal in the last two lines who is watching and why they are crying.
- Write a poem shaped as instructions for closing up a summer house, where every instruction is secretly about ending something else.
- The slip gives you a sound: two floors up, a chair scraping at 3 a.m. Write the history of that chair in ten lines.
- Constraint slip: every line must contain a number, and none of the numbers may be round. A poem of 7s, 43s and 11.30s about waiting for test results.
- Write the apology a scarecrow owes the crows, in the scarecrow's voice, without using the words field, straw or bird.
- A poem set entirely during the four seconds a phone takes to connect a call to your oldest friend.
- The slip names a smell: creosote, or school corridors, or a hot car in August. Follow the smell to one specific person and stay with them.
- Write a lost-property notice for something that cannot be returned: an accent, a nickname, the version of your mother before the diagnosis.
- Two-slip draw: pull an object slip (torch, ladle, hearing aid, bus ticket) and a verb slip (forgive, bury, translate, outlive). The object must do the verb.
- Write a poem in which someone teaches a child to whistle, and every stanza gets shorter, like breath running out.
- The slip is blank. Write the poem about pulling the blank slip, and what you were hoping the jar would say.
How to Use These
Build the jar in one sitting, thirty slips minimum, and make the rule absolute: whatever you draw, you write, today, for fifteen timed minutes. The jar dies the day you allow a second draw. Keep it where you write, and consider a weekly fixed appointment, Sunday morning with coffee, so the ritual carries you through the weeks when appetite does not. Some poets run two jars, one for situations and one for constraints, and pull one from each for harder sessions.
Refill as you spend. When a slip produces a draft worth keeping, drop the slip back in anyway; the same prompt six months later meets a different poet and gives a different poem. Once a month, pick your strongest jar draft and revise it properly across three or four sittings, tightening line breaks and cutting the first stanza, which in jar poems is nearly always warm-up. That revised piece is the one to send out, and a monthly deadline such as Writory's, open from the 1st to the 25th, pairs naturally with a monthly jar habit.
What poets can take from this
- Write slips when you are inspired so the jar can rescue you when you are not.
- Ban bare nouns from the jar; every slip needs a scene, a constraint or a voice.
- Fold slips identically so your hand cannot recognise favourites.
- Date each draft and its slip; patterns in what the jar keeps handing you are worth noticing.
- Make a second jar of your own abandoned lines and cross-pollinate the two.
Try it yourself
Make a ten-slip funeral jar for a fictional stranger: each slip holds one item found in their coat pockets. Draw three, and write the eulogy poem that only those three objects could tell.
Questions
How many slips should a poetry prompt jar have?
Thirty is a good floor, enough that you cannot remember what is inside, which keeps the draw genuinely blind. Add a few slips every month so the jar grows with you and never fully empties.
What makes a good prompt slip?
A situation rather than a topic: a speaker, a pressure, a limit. 'Grief' is a bad slip; 'return your dead brother's library book' is a good one because it gives the poem an action and lets the feeling arrive sideways.
Can I reuse a slip I have already written from?
Yes, and you should. A strong prompt is rereadable the way a strong poem is. Six months of living changes what you find in the same twelve words.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated September 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the October contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.