Whimsical Poetry Prompts
Quick answer: Whimsical poetry prompts for serious play: 14 original ideas where umbrellas migrate and Tuesdays resign, with craft notes on keeping whimsy airborne.
Whimsy is play taken seriously. It is not the same as comedy, which wants a laugh, or nonsense, which wants escape; whimsy proposes a small impossible premise, the moon is on loan from a library, Tuesday has handed in its notice, and then honours that premise with complete logical rigour. Lewis Carroll's worlds run on strict internal rules. Edward Lear's owl and pussycat conduct their courtship with proper ceremony. The impossible thing happens once; everything after it follows sensibly, and that sense is what makes the whimsy glow rather than whiff.
The mood has a secret seriousness, too. The best whimsical poems use their lightness to carry something true, loneliness in a poem about a sock's emigration, tenderness in the biography of a spoon, and the truth lands softly because the reader's guard was down. These prompts hand you the impossible premise. Your job is the rigour, and the smuggling.
The Prompts
Accept each premise completely. The poem should never wink, apologise, or explain that it knows better.
- The umbrellas of the city migrate south every October. Write the departure: the assembly on rooftops, the older umbrellas showing the young the thermals, the one that stays behind, and why.
- Tuesday has resigned. Write the letter it leaves for the other six days, including its reasons, its forwarding address, and its advice to Wednesday, who must now go first.
- Write the parish newsletter of a village where one small impossible thing is normal: the postbox grants one wish per decade, say, and the flower rota is unaffected. Report both with equal calm.
- A child's lost tooth is processed through the tooth fairy's actual bureaucracy. Write the paperwork: intake form, condition report, valuation notes, and the one handwritten comment in the margin.
- The moon is a library book, long overdue. Write the final notice sent to Earth, the accumulated fine, and Earth's letter requesting an extension on compassionate grounds.
- Write the biography of a spoon that has served one family for ninety years, in five chapters: christening porridge, wartime jam, the drawer years, the picnic it nearly didn't return from, now.
- All the town's odd socks have been found: they run a small seaside guesthouse together. Write the brochure, or the review left by the first human guest to track one down.
- Write instructions for the care and feeding of a house's resident echo, which has grown shy since the family got quieter. Include what it eats, where it sleeps, and how to coax it back.
- The number 47 bus has begun making one unscheduled stop, at a stop that is not there, where somebody always gets on. Write the regulars' unspoken agreement never to mention it, and the day a tourist asks.
- Write the annual general meeting of a garden's snails, convened to discuss the new gravel. Minutes must be taken at snail pace: the meeting covers three agenda items and lasts the whole summer.
- A lighthouse falls in love with a distant wind turbine. Write the courtship conducted entirely in their available vocabulary: sweeps of light, rotations, the occasional synchronised pause that neither will admit was deliberate.
- Write the lost property announcement for things that cannot be handed in: a whistled tune from 1974, the smell of a grandmother's coat, the exact blue of a bicycle. The office is open Thursdays.
- The ghosts in the old theatre are unionised. Write their negotiations with the new management: haunting hours, cold-spot allocations, the dispute over who gets the balcony, resolved by an audition.
- Write a poem in which a child's drawing of a house, sun in the corner, chimney smoke in a spiral, four flowers, turns out to be architecturally binding. The builders comply. The planning office sighs and stamps it.
How to Use These
Begin by legislating. Before drafting, write down the three rules of your impossible premise, umbrellas migrate in October, never singly, and only when unobserved, because whimsy without rules collapses into randomness, and randomness is far less interesting than it thinks. Then draft in a plain, matter-of-fact voice for twenty minutes, treating every marvel as administrative fact. The deadpan is not optional: whimsy floats on the gap between an extraordinary premise and an ordinary tone, and the flatter your delivery, the higher it flies.
In revision, look for the smuggled cargo. Somewhere in your draft a true feeling will have crept in under the whimsy, the stay-behind umbrella's reason, the spoon's drawer years, and your job is to find it and let it surface exactly once, briefly, before the play resumes. That single visible seam of feeling is what separates memorable whimsy from decoration. Trim any line where the poem congratulates itself on its own charm, and test the logic end to end: readers forgive an impossible premise instantly, and an inconsistent one never.
What poets can take from this
- One impossible premise per poem, with rules; rigour is what keeps whimsy aloft.
- Deliver marvels in a flat administrative tone; the gap between matter and manner is the magic.
- Smuggle one true feeling in under the play, and let it show only once.
- Concrete nouns ground the impossible: give the migrating umbrella a broken rib and a favourite thermal.
- Never wink; the poem must believe itself completely.
Try it yourself
Somewhere in every house is a door that leads to a room that is only there sometimes. Write the household's calm domestic protocol for it: who checks, on which days, what is stored in there when it exists, and the family's one rule about never mentioning it to visitors.
Questions
What is the difference between whimsical and nonsense poetry?
Nonsense delights in unmeaning, invented words and logic for its own sake, while whimsy proposes one impossible premise and then follows it with complete internal logic. Carroll wrote both, but the owl and the pussycat getting properly married is whimsy: absurd premise, orderly world.
Is whimsical poetry only for children?
No. Children's verse uses whimsy, but the mode runs through plenty of adult poetry, where an impossible conceit carries real feeling. The lightness is a delivery mechanism; what it delivers, loneliness, wonder, grief, can be as grown-up as anything in an elegy.
How do I keep a whimsical poem from becoming twee?
Tweeness comes from self-congratulation, the poem nudging you to find it delightful. The cures are a deadpan tone, strict internal rules, one grain of genuine feeling, and at least one detail with grit in it: the migrating umbrella has a broken rib, the guesthouse smells faintly of damp wool.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated September 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the October contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.