What Do Poetry Judges Look For?
Quick answer: What do poetry judges look for? Fresh language, genuine emotion, deliberate structure, and a poem that fulfils its own promise. A judge's checklist.
Poetry judges look for fresh, precise language, genuine emotion that is earned rather than announced, deliberate structure, and a poem that does something only a poem can do. Many contests formalise this into scoring criteria; Writory's judges, for example, score every entry on creativity, emotion, structure, language, and theme, and entrants see that breakdown.
What judges are not looking for surprises people: not big vocabulary, not obscure references, not suffering credentials, and not rhyme for its own sake. A plain poem that lands its one true moment beats an ornate poem about nothing, in essentially every competition, every time.
The first ten seconds
Judges reading hundreds of entries triage quickly, and the opening lines carry disproportionate weight. Cliches in the first stanza, misty eyes, broken hearts, souls soaring, signal the whole poem's register, and most judges will finish reading but stop hoping. A specific, surprising first image does the opposite: it promises the judge that the next thirty lines were chosen, not defaulted.
Titles matter more than entrants think. A title that merely repeats the theme ('Loss') wastes the poem's first move; a title that adds information or tension is already scoring.
What the criteria actually mean
Creativity means an angle the judge has not seen this month: not necessarily a wild form, but a fresh route into the subject. Emotion means the poem makes the reader feel something without instructing them to; showing the kettle boiling in an empty kitchen outscores writing 'I was devastated'. Structure means the shape is doing work, stanza breaks landing where the poem turns, line breaks placed with intent.
Language means precision and music at the level of the word: verbs pulling weight, no filler, sound patterns that reward reading aloud. Theme, where scored, means the poem engages the set subject genuinely rather than bolting it on in the final couplet, a move judges recognise instantly.
Common disqualifiers and quiet killers
Some entries lose before judging begins: over the line limit, identifying details where anonymity is required, or off theme entirely. Read the rules twice. Among poems that survive triage, the quiet killers are endings that explain the poem to the reader, abstractions stacked on abstractions, and inversions or archaic diction ('twas, o'er) used to force a rhyme.
One more honest note: judging has taste in it, and no scoring rubric removes that entirely. The same strong poem can place first in one contest and nowhere in another. That is a reason to enter more than once, not a reason to distrust the process.
What poets can take from this
- Spend disproportionate revision time on your first two lines and your title.
- Delete any line that tells the reader what to feel; keep the lines that cause the feeling.
- Read the rules twice and the theme brief three times before submitting.
- Replace every weak verb before you touch anything else in revision.
- End on an image, not an explanation.
- If a contest offers score feedback, use it to diagnose which criterion needs work next month.
Try it yourself
Write a poem about grief that never uses the words grief, loss, sad, heart, or soul. Let one household object carry the entire emotional load.
Questions
Do judges read every poem entered?
In reputable contests, yes, every entry gets read, typically by first readers who pass a longlist to the final judge. What is not guaranteed is a slow read for poems that stumble in the opening lines, which is why openings deserve your best work.
Do rhyming poems do worse in contests?
Not inherently. Judges reward rhyme handled with skill and penalise rhyme that forces word choices or inverted syntax. Free verse dominates winners' lists mostly because it dominates entries.
Does a sad poem score better than a funny one?
No. Judges see so much grief that a genuinely funny or joyful poem often stands out. Emotional range is scored on authenticity and craft, not on darkness.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.