American Poetry: Whitman, Dickinson, and the Making of a Voice
Quick answer: American poetry from Whitman and Dickinson to the modernists, the Beats, and today's poets laureate: how the United States found its voice in verse.
American poetry spent its first two centuries sounding like an English cousin. Anne Bradstreet, the first published poet of the colonies, wrote accomplished verse in the manner of the old country in 1650, and even Longfellow's wildly popular narratives and Poe's musical dread stayed close to European models. Then, in 1855, a Brooklyn printer named Walt Whitman set the type for Leaves of Grass himself, and the country suddenly had a sound of its own.
The strange thing is that the American voice was invented twice in the same generation. While Whitman flung his long free verse lines outward, Emily Dickinson sat in Amherst compressing the universe into slant rhymed quatrains almost nobody read until after her death in 1886.
The poem
Hope is the thing with feathers
That perches in the soul,
And sings the tune without the words,
And never stops at all,
Emily Dickinson, 'Hope is the thing with feathers' (published 1891)
Two poles of the American voice
Whitman and Dickinson mark the two poles every American poet since has moved between. Whitman offered expansion: the catalogue, the democratic first person, the line stretched to the length of a breath and then some. Dickinson offered compression: the packed quatrain, the off rhyme that refuses to resolve, the abstraction pinned down by one homely image.
Neither fitted the polite magazine verse of their day, and that is the founding lesson of the tradition. The American canon was built by poets the establishment initially ignored.
Modernism and the midcentury schools
The early twentieth century scattered American genius in two directions. Eliot and Pound remade poetry from London and Paris, while at home Robert Frost hid modern darkness inside country metres, Wallace Stevens wrote philosophy in gorgeous sound, Marianne Moore built poems from quotation and precision, and William Carlos Williams insisted that poems be made from American speech and concrete things rather than imported abstractions.
After the war the tradition split into named schools: the confessional poets Lowell, Plath, and Sexton turning the self inside out; the Beats taking Whitman's long line onto the road; Black Mountain poets like Olson and Creeley theorising the line as breath; and the New York School of O'Hara and Ashbery treating the poem as charmed, quick witted talk.
The craft the tradition offers
American poetry's great export is permission. Whitman's example legitimised free verse built on breath and anaphora. Dickinson demonstrated that rhyme could be slant, approximate, and more haunting for it. Williams showed that plain speech and ordinary objects, a wheelbarrow, cold plums, could carry the full weight of a poem. A poet anywhere can practise all three: write one poem that sprawls, one that compresses, and one that trusts a single ordinary thing to mean enough.
The tradition today
The contemporary scene is broader than any earlier era. Joy Harjo became the first Native American poet laureate in 2019, Ada Limon followed in the role, and Louise Gluck won the Nobel Prize in 2020. Spoken word fills theatres, university programmes turn out thousands of trained poets a year, and online journals publish work from every state and idiom. The argument between expansion and compression, though, is still running, which suggests Whitman and Dickinson are both still winning.
What poets can take from this
- Write a Whitman style catalogue poem of at least fifteen items, then cut it to the seven that earn their place.
- Try slant rhyme on purpose: pair words like soul and all, and notice the unsettled music Dickinson perfected.
- Draft a poem in which no word would sound odd spoken across a kitchen table, following Williams.
- Let the length of your line match the length of a comfortable breath, then break the pattern once for effect.
- Read one poet from a school you distrust; American poetry grew by arguments, and so will your work.
Try it yourself
Write two versions of the same memory: one in long overflowing lines that include everything, one in eight short lines that keep only what hurts. Keep whichever surprises you.
Questions
Why are Whitman and Dickinson considered the founders of American poetry?
Because they broke from European models in opposite ways in the same era. Whitman invented an expansive free verse of democratic scope, while Dickinson perfected compressed, slant rhymed lyrics, and nearly all later American poetry works between those poles.
What defines American poetry as distinct from British poetry?
Historically, its embrace of free verse, plain spoken diction, and the individual voice over inherited form. From Whitman's long line to Williams's American speech, the tradition has favoured invention and directness over continuity with English metre.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.