Lovecraft Died Poor and Unknown
Quick answer: H.P. Lovecraft died poor and almost unknown in 1937. Two friends invented a publishing house to save his work, and a strange literary afterlife began.
In the early months of 1937, in Providence, Rhode Island, a 46-year-old writer was dying of intestinal cancer and taking notes on the process. H.P. Lovecraft, methodical to the end, kept a record of his own symptoms for the interest of medicine until he could no longer hold a pencil. He died on 15 March 1937 in a Providence hospital. His estate was negligible; he had been living carefully on the last of a shrunken family inheritance and the thin, irregular payments of the pulp magazines. No publisher had ever brought out a proper collection of his work. By any professional measure then available, his career had failed.
Within a century, that failed career had produced one of the most influential bodies of horror fiction ever written, a mythology so pervasive that people who have never read a word of him can identify Cthulhu on a coffee mug. The gap between the deathbed and the coffee mug was bridged by two loyal friends and a publishing house invented for the purpose, and the whole story, including its genuinely ugly parts, is one of the strangest object lessons in literature about how work outlives its market.
The gentleman of Providence
Lovecraft's professional life was small and precarious almost by design. He wrote for the pulps, above all Weird Tales from 1923 onward, which paid modest per-word rates, often late, and rejected some of what is now considered his best work; 'At the Mountains of Madness' was turned down by the magazine that was supposedly his home. He supplemented this with ghostwriting and revision jobs for other writers, including, famously, a story published under Harry Houdini's name in 1924.
He was hopeless at the business side and knew it. He rarely submitted work aggressively, took rejections badly, and priced his revision labour absurdly low. In his last years, back in Providence after an unhappy spell in New York, his poverty was real: he lived frugally in rented rooms with his aunt, and his letters record meals planned around tins and day-old bread. The widely repeated picture of Lovecraft economising on food to the point of malnutrition in his final years comes from his own correspondence and from friends' accounts, and while details vary in the retelling, the essential poverty is beyond doubt.
One bad book in a lifetime
The single book publication of his lifetime is a black comedy in itself. In 1936 a tiny operation called Visionary Publishing brought out 'The Shadow over Innsmouth', the only real book Lovecraft ever held. The edition was riddled with printing errors that mortified its exacting author, and it sold a couple of hundred copies at most. That was the sum of his book career: one botched small-press volume in a print run that failed to sell out.
Yet inside the pulp ghetto, something unusual had been growing: a network. Lovecraft was one of the great letter writers of his century, corresponding on a scale reliably estimated in the tens of thousands of letters, generously encouraging younger writers, sharing his invented mythology, and inviting others to build stories inside it. Robert Bloch, who later wrote 'Psycho', was one of his protégés. The network earned him almost nothing while he lived. It turned out to be the most valuable thing he built.
Two friends invent a publishing house
After his death, two of those correspondents, August Derleth and Donald Wandrei, tried to sell a collected Lovecraft to the established New York houses. The houses declined. So in 1939, with more loyalty than capital, they founded a publishing company themselves for the express purpose of putting their dead friend between hard covers. They called it Arkham House, after the fictional New England town of his stories, and issued 'The Outsider and Others' in 1939 in an edition of just over a thousand copies. It took years to sell out.
That slow, unglamorous rescue is the turn in this story, and it deserves to be stated plainly: Lovecraft's afterlife did not begin with a critic's rediscovery or a lucky reprint. It began because two writers refused to let the work disappear, and were willing to found a company, learn publishing, and lose money for years to prevent it. From Arkham House the stories crept outward: paperback reprints in the 1960s and 70s, translation and championing abroad, then academic attention, and eventually full canonisation, including a Library of America volume in 2005. The pulp writer who could not sell a thousand hardcovers now sits in uniform classic editions in every bookshop on earth.
The uncomfortable part
An honest page cannot leave it out: Lovecraft held racist views, expressed plainly in his letters and visible in some of his fiction, and they were pronounced even by the standards of his own time. This is not a modern reinterpretation; it is documented in his own hand. As his canonisation advanced, the reckoning followed, and in 2015 the World Fantasy Award retired the bust of Lovecraft it had used as its trophy since 1975.
Readers and writers now hold both facts at once: the fiction's enormous influence and the prejudice threaded through its maker. For a working writer the point is not to resolve that tension here, but to see clearly that posthumous fame did not sanitise him. What survives of a writer is everything, the letters included. Write as if your correspondence will be read in a hundred years, because if the work lasts, it will be.
What a working writer can take from it
The first lesson is about generosity as a long game. The mythology Lovecraft gave away freely, encouraging other writers to borrow his gods and towns, is precisely what made his world too widely loved to die with him. Hoarded, it would have been buried with its author. Shared, it acquired hundreds of caretakers. Writers who help other writers, blurb, encourage, correspond, collaborate, are building the network that may one day carry their own work further than they can.
The second lesson is colder. Lovecraft's obscurity was partly the market's blindness, but partly his own retreat: he submitted timidly, absorbed rejection as verdict, and let 'At the Mountains of Madness' sit unsold for years after one refusal. The work survived despite these habits, thanks to friends most writers will not have. Do not budget for a Derleth. Send the work out yourself, repeatedly, while you are alive to sign the acceptance letter; a monthly contest with a guaranteed reading, like Writory's, exists precisely so that no manuscript has to wait for posthumous rescue.
Where to start reading
Start with 'The Colour Out of Space', which Lovecraft himself favoured and which shows his method at its purest: dread built from measurement, testimony, and a farmer's failing well rather than from monsters described. Then 'The Call of Cthulhu' for the architecture of nested documents, and 'At the Mountains of Madness' for the slow Antarctic accumulation that magazine editors found unsaleable and readers now find hypnotic. As a craft study, watch how he withholds: the horror is almost always in the report of a thing, never quite the thing. Poets can learn from that restraint, and should feel free to discard the adjectives he never learned to ration.
What poets can take from this
- Share your invented worlds; generosity builds the network that preserves work.
- Never treat one rejection as a verdict; Lovecraft shelved a masterpiece over a single no.
- Keep your correspondence worthy of survival, because if the work lasts, the letters surface too.
- Learn the business side even if you despise it; timid submission cost Lovecraft dearly.
- Study 'The Colour Out of Space' for horror built from evidence rather than description.
- Put work into circulation now instead of trusting the future to rescue it.
Try it yourself
Write a poem or short piece structured as a report: a well tested, a field measured, a house inspected, in which something is wrong with the findings and the writer of the report never once names what it is.
Questions
Was H.P. Lovecraft famous during his lifetime?
No. He was known only inside the small world of pulp magazines, chiefly Weird Tales, and the one book published in his lifetime was a tiny, error-filled 1936 edition that sold a few hundred copies. Mainstream recognition came decades after his death in 1937.
How did Lovecraft's work survive after he died?
Two friends and correspondents, August Derleth and Donald Wandrei, failed to interest established publishers, so in 1939 they founded their own house, Arkham House, to publish his collected stories. From that rescue his work spread through paperbacks, translations, and eventually classic editions.
Was Lovecraft racist?
Yes, and it is well documented in his own letters and visible in parts of his fiction. The issue has been central to modern reassessments of him, and in 2015 the World Fantasy Award stopped using his likeness for its trophy. His influence and his prejudice are both part of the record.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated September 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.