Odour of Chrysanthemums by D. H. Lawrence
Quick answer: Odour of Chrysanthemums summary and analysis: Elizabeth Bates, the pit accident, the washing of the body and Lawrence's theme of the unknowable other explained.
Dusk in a colliery village: a woman waits with her two children for a husband who has not come home from the pit, rehearsing the anger she will feel when he is carried in drunk. He is carried in, but not drunk. What follows, a mother and a wife washing a dead man's body by candlelight, becomes one of the most unsparing scenes in English fiction.
Lawrence published the story in the English Review in 1911, revising it heavily for The Prussian Officer collection in 1914, and it draws directly on the Nottinghamshire mining world of his childhood. Readers come for the tragedy; what they find is stranger and colder, a story about discovering, over a corpse, that you never knew the person you married.
The story in brief
Elizabeth Bates, proud and handsome, keeps house by the railway line near Brinsley pit with her small son John and daughter Annie; she is pregnant with a third child. Her husband Walter has not come home, and she assumes the usual: he has slipped past to the public house to drink his wages. The evening is built from small domestic movements, tea kept waiting, chrysanthemums in her apron band, the children put to bed, while her irritation hardens into bitter certainty about the man she married. She goes out to ask after him; the neighbour Rigley walks her home with reassurances neither believes.
Then Walter's old mother arrives, weeping over news Elizabeth has not yet heard: there has been an accident. Men bring the body on a stretcher, knocking over a vase of chrysanthemums as they carry it in. Walter was suffocated when a fall of coal penned him in; the body is whole, warm-looking, unmarked. The two women wash and lay him out, the mother crooning over her boy, and Elizabeth, touching the dead man, is overwhelmed not by grief but by recognition: this body is a stranger's. They had met in the dark and fought in the dark, never truly seeing each other; her husband existed apart from her all along, and death has only made the separation visible. She covers him, tidies the room, and submits, with fear and shame, to life, her new master.
The characters
Lawrence needs only a handful of people, arranged around an absence.
Themes and meaning
The examination staples are the harshness of mining life, the failed marriage, and the symbolism of the chrysanthemums, which Elizabeth links aloud to her wedding, her childbirths and the first time Walter was carried home drunk; when the stretcher-bearers smash the vase, the flowers' whole ironic history arrives with the corpse. Death and the rituals of laying out give the story its second movement, and the pregnant body beside the dead one closes the circle of the village's biology.
But the theme Lawrence actually presses is the isolation of the human soul. Elizabeth's epiphany is not that she loved Walter after all, nor that she is free; it is that each of them was finally unknowable to the other, and that her angry certainty about him was a fiction she lived in. Few stories have the nerve to make a widow's great discovery an accusation against herself.
The craft: withholding the event
Notice what Lawrence does with the accident: nothing. The fall of coal happens off the page, before the story's present, and is reported in a dozen words. All the narrative weight goes to waiting and to aftermath, the two states fiction renders better than catastrophe itself. Writers should steal the proportion: when the terrible thing is conventional, spend your scenes on the approach and the reckoning, and let the event pass in summary.
The story also demonstrates symbol handled with a working hand. The chrysanthemums are not planted once but used: tucked in an apron, smelled by a child, catalogued bitterly by Elizabeth, and finally knocked to the floor by the stretcher. Each appearance is a plot action first and a symbol second, which is why the device never feels literary. That, plus the tonal discipline of the washing scene, pure procedure carrying unbearable feeling, is why this early story already reads like a master's.
What poets can take from this
- Track every appearance of the chrysanthemums and note that each is an action before it is a symbol.
- Name the true theme as the soul's isolation, using Elizabeth's own realisation over the body as evidence.
- Contrast the two mourners: the mother grieves a son she knew, Elizabeth confronts a husband she did not.
- As a writer, keep the catastrophe off-stage and give its space to waiting and aftermath.
- Let household procedure, making tea, washing a body, carry your biggest emotions.
- End on submission to what continues, not on resolution.
Try it yourself
Write a story in which a character spends the first half constructing an angry, confident account of someone who is absent, and the second half confronting evidence that the account was wrong. The absent person must never speak in the story.
Questions
What do the chrysanthemums symbolise in the story?
Elizabeth ties them to every stage of her marriage: her wedding, her children's births, and Walter first carried home drunk, so they stand for a life of soured promise. When the men bringing in the body knock the vase over, the broken flowers complete the pattern, beauty and bitterness arriving together.
How does Walter Bates die?
He is suffocated underground when a fall of coal pens him in at the pit; his body is recovered unmarked. Lawrence keeps the accident off the page entirely, reporting it in a few words so the story can concentrate on the waiting before and the reckoning after.
What does Elizabeth realise at the end?
Washing the body, she understands that she and Walter were strangers who met and fought in the dark: her confident bitterness described a man she had invented. The realisation is Lawrence's theme of the utter separateness of souls, and she ends the story ashamed, submitting to life as her new master.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.