The Adventure of the Empty House by Arthur Conan Doyle
Quick answer: The Adventure of the Empty House by Arthur Conan Doyle: full summary and ending, how Holmes survived Reichenbach, the wax bust trap for Moran, themes and craft.
An elderly, deformed book collector follows Dr Watson home from a murder scene, offers to fill a gap on his shelf, and straightens up into a man three years dead. The Adventure of the Empty House, published in the Strand in 1903, is the resurrection: the story with which Conan Doyle, after a decade of public pressure and one safely retrospective novel, brought Sherlock Holmes back from the Reichenbach Falls alive.
Doyle had two problems to solve at once: explain the survival without cheapening The Final Problem, and give the returned Holmes a case worthy of the occasion. His answer binds them together, since the mystery of the moment, the murder of the Honourable Ronald Adair, turns out to be the last live wire of Moriarty's ruined machine. Below: the complete plot with the ending, the characters, the themes, and the craft of the comeback.
The story in brief, ending included
London, 1894. Ronald Adair, a blameless young aristocrat fond of whist, is found shot dead in his second floor sitting room, the door locked from inside, no weapon present, no one heard on the stair, and an expanding revolver bullet in his brain; the window looks onto a drop no climber could use quietly. Watson, still mourning his friend and lately his wife, haunts the inquest crowd, where he collides with a snappish old book dealer. Minutes later the dealer appears in his study, offers him British Birds and The Holy War, and while Watson glances at the shelf, removes his disguise. Watson faints for the only time in his life. Holmes's explanation follows: he never went over the falls. Using baritsu, the Japanese wrestling, he slipped Moriarty's grip and watched the professor drop alone; then, seeing in an instant what a presumed death was worth, he climbed the cliff above the path, was nearly brained by rocks dropped by Moriarty's lieutenant, who had watched the whole duel, and fled. Three years followed as a dead man: Tibet under the name Sigerson, Persia, Mecca, Khartoum, a laboratory in the south of France, while only his brother Mycroft knew, keeping the Baker Street rooms paid. He has returned now because the Adair murder tells him his most dangerous surviving enemy is active, and that enemy is the man from the clifftop: Colonel Sebastian Moran, once of the Indian Army, the best heavy game shot of the Eastern Empire, Moriarty's chief of staff.
The trap is the story's set piece. In the darkened window of 221B stands a wax bust of Holmes, sculpted in Grenoble, turned periodically by Mrs Hudson from her knees; Holmes and Watson watch not from the rooms but from the empty house across Baker Street, the hunter's blind aimed at his own silhouette. Past midnight Moran creeps into that same empty house, assembles a special air rifle built for Moriarty by the blind German mechanic Von Herder, and puts a soft revolver bullet through the wax head from the window beside them. Holmes is on him instantly; Watson and the police complete the arrest. The air gun explains Adair: Moran had shot him through the open window with the silent weapon, almost certainly because Adair, his whist partner, had caught him cheating at cards and threatened exposure. Inspector Lestrade takes the prisoner, Holmes suggests the charge, and 221B reopens for business, the bullet hole in the bust's brow serving as the canon's driest joke about celebrity. Watson ends where the readers of 1903 were: back in the old chair, the world restored.
The characters and what they want
Holmes wants his city back, but only once it is safe to claim; his three year silence, even to Watson, is defended on operational grounds and has been argued over by readers ever since. Watson wants his friend alive and forgives the cruelty of the method in a paragraph, which tells us more about Watson than about the method. Colonel Moran wants the death he was cheated of at Reichenbach, and Doyle builds him as the dark twin of the imperial hero: tiger hunter, decorated soldier, card cheat, assassin. Ronald Adair, the victim, wanted only to keep a cheat from ruining both their names, and died of his own decency.
Themes and meaning
The themes: resurrection and its price, since the return is bought with three years of deception of the person most loyal to him; the hunter hunted, made literal when Moran, the big game shot, stalks a decoy while being stalked; and the long tail of evil, Moriarty's organisation persisting past its head, an idea any modern crime story recognises. The empire theme flickers at the edges: Moran is what the imperial adventure produces when its virtues curdle.
The sharper observation is that the story is built on doubles and effigies. A wax Holmes draws the bullet meant for the real one; an empty house faces the full one; Moran repeats Moriarty in miniature; even Holmes's return doubles his death, another performance staged with props and an audience. Doyle, restoring a character the public treated as real, fills the story with images of simulation, the fake that absorbs the attack so the original can live. Whether that is confession or joke, it is the resurrection story the situation deserved.
The craft: paying the debts of a comeback
A resurrection owes the reader three payments, and the story schedules them precisely. The explanation must be prompt and plausible enough: Holmes delivers it in one scene, with baritsu, the climbed cliff and the dropped rocks knitting the new account into the old story's exact gaps. The emotion must be honoured: Watson's faint, and his quiet record of grief, price the three years properly before any plot resumes. And the occasion must matter: the returned hero's first case is aimed at the last of Moriarty's men, so the comeback completes the story that caused the absence instead of merely following it. Sequence matters as much as content; reverse it and the reunion becomes an interruption.
The technique worth stealing is the decoy built from the hero's own legend. Moran can be trapped because Holmes's silhouette in a window is irresistible, to the assassin and to the reading public alike; the character's fame is converted into apparatus. When you bring anything back, a character, a setting, a running feud, look for the trap that only works because of what the audience already knows. Doyle also demonstrates economy with the locked room: the air gun answers it in a sentence once Moran exists, proof that a mystery's machinery can be small if its people are large.
What poets can take from this
- For exams, know the survival account: baritsu at the ledge, Moriarty falling alone, the climb, and the three year wandering as Sigerson.
- Explain how the Adair murder and the return interlock: the air gun that killed Adair is the proof Moran is active.
- Use the wax bust trap as the set piece: the hunter of tigers taken with a tethered decoy of the detective himself.
- Writers: pay a comeback's three debts in order, explanation, emotion, occasion, before resuming business as usual.
- Convert a character's fame into plot machinery; the legend itself can bait the trap.
- Keep locked room solutions economical; one established weapon can retire the whole puzzle.
Try it yourself
Write the story of someone returning after years of being believed dead, told from the point of view of the person who mourned them hardest. The returner needs the mourner's help that same night, and the reunion must be complicated by the job at hand.
Questions
How did Sherlock Holmes survive the Reichenbach Falls?
He never fell. Using baritsu, a Japanese wrestling method, he broke Moriarty's grip and the professor went over alone. Holmes then climbed the cliff above the path to fake his death, survived rocks dropped by the watching Colonel Moran, and spent three years abroad, partly in Tibet as the explorer Sigerson.
Who killed Ronald Adair and why?
Colonel Sebastian Moran shot him through the open window with a silent air rifle built by Von Herder. Adair, his card partner, had discovered Moran cheating at whist and threatened to expose him unless he quit the clubs, so Moran silenced him to protect the income he lived on.
What is the trap in The Adventure of the Empty House?
Holmes places a wax bust of himself in the lit window of 221B, moved regularly by Mrs Hudson, while he and Watson wait in the empty house across the street. Moran shoots the decoy from that very house and is seized by Holmes the moment the rifle fires.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.