Winter Dreams by F. Scott Fitzgerald
Quick answer: Winter Dreams by F. Scott Fitzgerald: full summary with the ending, Dexter Green and Judy Jones, themes of wealth and illusion, and how the story rehearses The Great Gatsby.
A fourteen-year-old caddy at the Sherry Island Golf Club in Minnesota quits on the spot rather than carry the bag of an imperious eleven-year-old girl, because he has just seen what he wants and cannot bear to be her servant. Winter Dreams appeared in Metropolitan Magazine in December 1922 and, revised, in All the Sad Young Men (1926).
Fitzgerald called it a first draft of the Gatsby idea: a self-made man, a careless rich girl, and the discovery that the dream outweighed the woman.
The story in brief, ending included
Dexter Green, a grocer's son, dreams in winter of beating the members at their own game. After Judy Jones treats him as furniture he quits, goes east to university, and builds a chain of laundries that wash rich men's golf stockings better than anyone. At twenty-three he is playing the course as a member when a ball strikes Mr T. A. Hedrick in the abdomen: Judy, grown and careless, hit it. At dinner that night he tells her he is nobody, that his career is a matter of futures, and that he is making more money than any man his age in the region.
For eighteen months Judy keeps him in a rotation of a dozen men. Worn out, he becomes engaged to Irene Scheerer; Judy returns for one evening, says she wishes he would marry her, and the engagement is gone in a night. Her renewed interest lasts a month. War, then New York, and at thirty-two a visitor named Devlin mentions that Judy Simms, wife of a drinking, straying man in Detroit, has faded. Dexter finds he cannot cry or care. "Long ago," he says, "there was something in me, but now that thing is gone." He grieves not Judy but his capacity to have wanted her.
The characters
Four people.
Themes: the dream that outlives its object
The exam readings are the American dream and its emptiness, class aspiration (Dexter's laundries against the members' inherited ease), and illusion against reality in Judy, desirable because she cannot be held. Winter is when Dexter dreams; summer is when the dreams are tested and fail.
The sharper point is where the loss lands. Dexter does not weep for Judy's marriage or her faded looks; he weeps because the news does not hurt. Fitzgerald puts the tragedy in the death of desire itself, which is bleaker than the Gatsby plot it rehearses.
The craft: six sections and fifteen years
Fitzgerald divides the story into six numbered parts and leaps years between them, trusting summary for the years and scene for the pivots. Section one already holds the whole pattern; the turn is the golf ball that brings Judy back as an adult.
The technique to steal is proportion. The eighteen months of Judy take a page; the single evening that breaks the engagement gets full dialogue. Writory's Structure judges notice exactly this, a passage's length matching its weight, and results pages dated each month show it rewarded.
For class and essays
Model answers, vocabulary, one misreading.
What writers can take from this
- For exams, read the title literally: dreams formed in winter, tested in summer.
- Cite the laundries as the story's exact picture of self-made money serving inherited money.
- Use the Irene Scheerer episode to argue about what Dexter's ambition costs others.
- Writers: cover years in summary and stop for scenes only where a life turns.
- Let the final blow be the absence of pain.
Try it yourself
Write a story in six short numbered sections spanning fifteen years, about someone who reshapes their life around a person met once in childhood. Give that person no malice, only inconsistency. End with news of them arriving second-hand, and let the grief be for the feeling that fails to arrive.
Questions
What is the theme of Winter Dreams?
The American dream of wealth and glitter, pursued through a person who embodies it, and the discovery that the dream dies before the dreamer does. Class, illusion and time are the standard readings.
Why does Dexter cry at the end of Winter Dreams?
Not because Judy has married badly and faded, but because the news does not hurt him. He realises the capacity to want, which made his youth, is gone for good.
How is Winter Dreams related to The Great Gatsby?
Fitzgerald called it a first draft of the Gatsby idea, a self-made man and a rich careless girl, and later lifted passages from the story into the novel.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working writers. Updated September 2026.
Enter a Writory story contest
Enter the Writory Short Story Contest and have your own story read and scored out of 100. Entries close 25 November. That first entry makes you a Writorian.