Arthur Conan Doyle: Short Stories, Style and What to Learn
1859 to 1930
Quick answer: Arthur Conan Doyle craft file: the deduction scene, the client's tale, negative evidence, "Silver Blaze" and "The Speckled Band", and what the Holmes stories teach.
Quick facts
- Born: 1859, Edinburgh
- Died: 1930, Crowborough, Sussex, aged 71
- Wrote in: English
- Known for: "A Scandal in Bohemia", "The Adventure of the Speckled Band", "Silver Blaze"
- Signature move: The deduction scene, where a small object is read aloud
- Start with: "The Red-Headed League" (1891)
Doyle wrote fifty-six Holmes stories over forty years and resented most of them; he wanted to be known for historical novels. The stories won anyway, because he had solved a structural problem no one else had: how to make a reader enjoy being told what they should have noticed. Each story is a small engine with the same parts, and the parts are worth taking out and labelling.
What he actually does on the page
He opens with a reading. In "The Blue Carbuncle" (1892) Holmes examines a battered hat and tells Watson its owner is intellectual, formerly prosperous, now poor, out of training, middle-aged, recently haircut, and no longer loved by his wife. Each conclusion is then tied to a physical fact: the hat's size, the dust, the tallow stains. The scene has nothing to do with the plot yet and everything to do with the contract: the reader is being taught to look.
He gives the client a long, uninterrupted story. Jabez Wilson in "The Red-Headed League" (1891) tells of a job copying the encyclopaedia for four pounds a week, offered only to red-headed men, and its sudden closure. Helen Stoner in "The Speckled Band" (1892) describes a whistle at night, a metallic clang, a bell-pull that does not work and a ventilator that goes nowhere. Doyle plants every clue inside the client's own account, in plain view, and trusts the reader to miss it.
He builds the solution on what did not happen. In "Silver Blaze" (1892) the racehorse has vanished and its trainer is dead; Holmes solves it by noticing that the stable dog did not bark, so the night visitor was someone the dog knew. Negative evidence, the absent bark, the unused bell-pull, is Doyle's favourite kind, because it is fair: the reader had every chance.
The signature move
The deduction scene is dissected best in "The Speckled Band", where Doyle runs it twice. The first time, Holmes reads Helen Stoner as she arrives: she came by dog-cart and train, from the splash of mud on her left sleeve and the return ticket in her glove. The second time, he reads the room at Stoke Moran: a bed clamped to the floor, a bell-rope that is a dummy, a ventilator opening into the next room, a saucer of milk and a dog-lash tied in a loop. Neither reading states a conclusion; each lays out facts. The reader who assembles them arrives at the snake a page before Holmes says it, and that moment of arriving first is the pleasure the whole form is built to deliver. A writer learns from this that a mystery is fair only when the reader can win.
Stories to read first
Eight stories, six of them Holmes.
What to steal for your own stories
Exercises drawn from the stories.
What not to copy
The formula shows. Read ten Holmes stories in a row and the client, the reading, the trip, the reveal and the lecture become a rhythm you can set your watch by, and the later stories coast on it. Some villains are drawn with the racial and national prejudices of the 1890s, and Watson's admiration can be cloying. The prose is serviceable rather than fine. Take the fair-play contract and the negative clue; vary the machinery.
Life at a glance
- 1859: Born in Edinburgh
- 1881: Qualifies in medicine at Edinburgh, where Dr Joseph Bell's diagnostic method becomes the model for Holmes
- 1887: A Study in Scarlet in Beeton's Christmas Annual
- 1891: "A Scandal in Bohemia" opens the Strand Magazine series in July
- 1893: "The Final Problem" sends Holmes over the Reichenbach Falls
- 1902: The Hound of the Baskervilles; knighted
- 1903: "The Adventure of the Empty House" brings Holmes back
- 1930: Dies at his home in Sussex
What writers can take from this
- Teach the reader to look before you ask them to solve.
- Hide the clues in a witness's own words.
- Prefer the absent fact to the present one.
- Let the detective lose occasionally; it keeps the wins honest.
- Give every solution a physical object the reader could have picked up.
Try it yourself
Someone comes to a friend who is good at noticing things and describes, in one uninterrupted speech of about 400 words, a strange thing that has been happening at their workplace. Then write the friend's solution in under 400 more. The answer must turn on something the speaker mentioned that did not happen. The reader must be able to get there first.
Questions
What is Arthur Conan Doyle's best short story?
Doyle himself ranked "The Adventure of the Speckled Band" (1892) first in a 1927 list. Readers most often name "The Red-Headed League" (1891) and "A Scandal in Bohemia" (1891) beside it.
How did Conan Doyle influence the short story?
He took Poe's detective and made him a series character with a fixed method, a narrator and a recurring cast, and in doing so invented the modern detective short story and most of its conventions. Agatha Christie and every fair-play mystery since work inside his rules.
Is Conan Doyle hard to read?
No. The stories are written in plain Victorian prose, run to about 8,000 words each, and are built to be read in a sitting. Nearly all of them are in the public domain.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working writers. Updated September 2026.
Enter a Writory story contest
Enter the Writory Short Story Contest and have your own story read and scored out of 100. Entries close 25 November. That first entry makes you a Writorian.