Anthology in Fiction
Quick answer: An anthology is a book collecting stories by many different authors, chosen by an editor around a theme, genre or year. Learn how anthologies work for writers.
An anthology is a book that gathers stories by many different authors, selected and arranged by an editor, usually around a theme, a genre, a place or a period. In other words, it is a curated group exhibition in book form. The word descends from the Greek for a gathering of flowers, and the editor's job has not changed much since: pick, arrange, and make the whole read as more than the sum of its parts.
For working writers, anthologies matter at two moments: when an open call invites submissions on a theme, and when an editor comes asking to reprint a story you have already published. Both are ordinary, respectable routes to readers, and each has its own etiquette and economics.
The shapes anthologies take
The annual best-of is the most visible shape: The Best American Short Stories has appeared every year since 1915, with a guest editor choosing from stories published in magazines during the year, and equivalent series exist for many genres and countries. Then there are themed originals, built from newly commissioned or openly solicited work. Harlan Ellison's Dangerous Visions in 1967 is the famous example, an original anthology that deliberately gathered stories too provocative for the magazines of its day and reshaped science fiction in the process.
Reprint anthologies collect previously published work around a subject; tribute anthologies orbit a single writer's influence; charity anthologies raise funds for a cause. The label on the spine matters less than one distinction: original anthologies buy first rights to new stories, while reprint anthologies license stories that have already appeared elsewhere.
How stories get in
Three doors exist. Invitation: established writers are simply asked, which is why famous names cluster in commercial anthologies. Open calls: the editor announces a theme, a word count range, a pay rate and a deadline, and reads whatever arrives; market listing sites and small press newsletters announce these constantly. Selection: for best-of series, editors trawl the year's magazines, so the way in is publishing strong stories in visible venues.
Open calls reward precision. Read the call twice, hit the theme squarely rather than tangentially, respect the word count, and submit before the deadline rather than at it, since some editors fill slots as they read. Payment varies from royalty shares to flat fees to professional per-word rates; reputable calls state terms up front.
Why anthologies are good for writers
An anthology puts your story on a shelf beside writers whose readers have never heard of you, which is the cheapest audience-borrowing available in publishing. Themed calls also generate work: a prompt with a deadline and a paying destination concentrates the mind wonderfully, the same mechanism that makes a monthly contest theme productive for writers who enter Writory regularly. And anthology editors remember contributors who were professional; invitations grow from open-call relationships.
The risks are mild but worth naming. Weak anthologies from careless presses can bury a good story; royalty-share deals on low-selling books pay almost nothing; and exclusivity clauses, if carelessly signed, can lock up a story for years. Read contracts, check the press's previous books, and keep your rights reverting on a definite date.
Reading anthologies like a working writer
Anthologies are market intelligence bound in covers. A best-of series shows you, in one sitting, what the year's most visible editors considered the strongest work and which magazines they drew it from; the acknowledgements page alone is a curated submission list. Themed anthologies teach a different lesson: read one straight through and notice how twenty writers attacked the same brief without colliding, which is a masterclass in finding the unexpected angle.
Study the sequencing too. Editors open with a story that sets the book's register and close with one that lingers, and the logic of those choices is the same logic that should govern how you order your own strongest and weakest material in any submission that allows several pieces.
Neighbours and opposites
An anthology differs from a literary magazine in permanence and rhythm: the magazine is an ongoing periodical, the anthology a one-off book. It differs from a single-author collection, which gathers one writer's stories rather than many writers'. And it differs from a chapbook, which is a small single-author pamphlet. When a story appears first in a magazine and later in an anthology, the second appearance is a reprint, which is why understanding first rights protects you at both ends.
What poets can take from this
- Match open-call submissions to the stated theme exactly, not approximately.
- Check a press's previous anthologies before submitting; production quality varies wildly.
- Prefer contracts with clear payment terms and a definite rights reversion date.
- Keep a list of your published stories with their rights status, ready for reprint requests.
- Treat anthology deadlines as writing engines: a theme plus a date produces stories.
Try it yourself
Find a real open anthology call, or invent one with a theme, word limit and deadline. Write the story you would submit, then write two sentences explaining to the imaginary editor why it belongs in that book and not just any book.
Questions
What is the difference between an anthology and a collection?
An anthology gathers stories by many authors under one editor; a collection gathers stories by a single author. Both are books of short fiction, but they signal different things about whose work is on display.
Do anthologies pay contributors?
Many do, through flat fees, per-word rates or royalty shares, while some small and charity projects pay in copies only. Reputable calls state terms up front, and royalty shares on small print runs usually amount to very little.
Can a story appear in more than one anthology?
Yes, as long as your contracts allow it. After first publication, a story can be reprinted repeatedly provided each agreement is non-exclusive or its exclusivity period has ended. Track your rights carefully.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.