Crisis
Quick answer: What the crisis means in fiction: the decisive choice before the climax, how it works in real stories, common traps, and how to build one into a short story.
A crisis is the moment in a story when the protagonist must finally make the decision that everything before has been forcing and everything after will pay for. In other words, it is the fork in the road: the scene where choice can no longer be postponed and every cheaper option has burned away.
The term belongs to dramatic structure, the stage of craft where you plan or revise the shape of a whole story rather than a single sentence. Novelists, playwrights and short story writers all rely on it, though editors lean on the word hardest when a manuscript has action in abundance and no real decision at its centre.
Sydney Carton makes up his mind
In A Tale of Two Cities, Dickens spends an entire novel establishing Sydney Carton as a man convinced his life has been wasted. The crisis arrives when Charles Darnay sits condemned in a Paris cell and Carton realises that he alone, because of the resemblance between them, can take the other man's place at the guillotine. Notice what Dickens does with the moment. The decision happens quietly, well before the famous ending, and every scene afterwards simply carries it out. The reader feels the click of inevitability the instant the choice is made, which is precisely the sensation a crisis exists to produce.
The climax of the novel, the execution itself, contains almost no suspense about what will happen. All of that suspense was spent at the crisis. The division of labour is worth studying: the crisis carries the question of who this person truly is, and the climax carries the consequences of the answer.
Why the decision matters more than the action
A crisis converts plot into character. Chases, storms and betrayals can happen to anyone; a decision can only be made by this particular person, with this history and this exact set of fears. When you force a protagonist to choose between two things they cannot both keep, the reader learns more in a single beat than a chapter of description could teach. Judges reading for Storytelling and Structure in Writory's monthly Short Story Contest tend to reward exactly this beat, because it is where shape and feeling meet.
The risk sits in the dilemma itself. If one option is obviously right, there is no crisis, only delay dressed up as drama. And a story that manufactures an agonising choice every few pages exhausts its reader; the device draws power from scarcity. One true crisis per story is usually plenty.
Engineering a crisis in a short story
Start by naming the two incompatible things your protagonist wants, or the two evils they must pick between. Then spend the story closing escape hatches, so that by the final fifth no clever reader could suggest a third way out. Place the crisis late, roughly four fifths of the way through a short piece, and write it as a scene rather than a summary: the reader wants to watch the choosing, not hear about it afterwards.
The trap to avoid is letting circumstance decide. If the cavalry arrives, the rival conveniently confesses, or the burning bridge collapses before the character steps onto it, you have stolen the moment your whole story existed to deliver. Whatever the character picks must cost something visible, and the character must be the one who picks it.
Crisis, climax, turning point: keeping the terms straight
The climax is the action that answers the story's central question; the crisis is the decision that makes that action inevitable. A turning point is any scene that reverses the direction of the story, and a healthy plot has several, but the crisis is the last and largest of them. The dark night of the soul, a phrase from popular structure guides, names the stretch of despair that often sits just before the crisis, when the protagonist believes no good choice exists.
Be aware that usage is not settled everywhere. Some older handbooks use crisis for the climax itself, and theatre criticism sometimes treats the two as one unit. Working editors keep them separate because they fail differently in drafts: a weak climax is usually a staging problem, while a weak crisis is a character problem.
What poets can take from this
- If your protagonist can win without giving anything up, you have a victory scene, not a crisis.
- Write the crisis in real time; a summarised decision robs the reader of the story's best moment.
- Cut any escape route an attentive reader could spot, or the dilemma collapses into a puzzle.
- Let the choice expose something the character has hidden from themselves all story.
- In a 2,000 word story, aim to land the crisis within a page or two of the end.
Try it yourself
A volunteer firefighter reaches a burning house and hears two voices inside: one belongs to the neighbour who ruined her family, the other to that neighbour's young son, and the staircase will let her reach only one room. Write the scene of the choosing, keeping the decision on the page and the rescue itself off it.
Questions
Is the crisis the same as the climax?
No, though the two sit close together. The crisis is the protagonist's decisive choice; the climax is the action that follows from it. Some teachers merge the terms, but editors keep them apart because each fails in a different way during revision.
Where should the crisis fall in a short story?
Late. In most short fiction the crisis lands in the final fifth, close enough to the end that the story can pay for the decision and stop. Placing it earlier tends to leave a long, deflating aftermath.
Can a story have more than one crisis?
Longer works often give each act a smaller dilemma, but one decision should still tower over the rest. If three choices feel equally decisive, readers will struggle to say what the story was about.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.