Magical Realism
Quick answer: Magical realism blends impossible events into realist fiction and reports them deadpan. Its history, how Garcia Marquez does it, and how it differs from fantasy.
A young woman rises into the sky while folding laundry, and the neighbours' chief concern is the loss of the sheets. Magical realism is fiction in which impossible events occur inside an otherwise realist world and are narrated in the same calm, factual register as breakfast. In other words, the magic is real, nobody is amazed, and the story refuses to treat wonder and reality as separate categories.
The mode is most associated with Latin American fiction of the twentieth century, though its practitioners now write everywhere. For a working writer it is less a genre shelf than a set of narrative rules about tone, explanation and consequence, and the rules are strict enough that small violations, a gasp, an explanation, tip the story into fantasy or whimsy.
The term at work: the ascension of Remedios the Beauty
The laundry scene above is from Gabriel Garcia Marquez's One Hundred Years of Solitude (1967). Remedios the Beauty ascends bodily into heaven one afternoon, and the narration gives the event the same unhurried, chronicle-like attention it gives civil wars and banana harvests; the family's lasting grievance is the linen that went up with her. Elsewhere in the novel an insomnia plague makes a whole town forget the names of things, so people label the cow and the clock, and the narration never once marks any of it as strange.
The deadpan is the device. Because the narrator declines to be surprised, the reader's disbelief has nowhere to lodge, and the impossible events start to function the way history functions: absurd, unarguable, consequential. Garcia Marquez said he learned the method from his grandmother, who told the most outrageous stories with a brick face, and from the practical observation that Latin American history already outran realism's capacities.
Why writers choose the mode
Magical realism literalises what realism can only assert. Grief weighs on a house, so the house fills with falling flowers; a woman is too beautiful for the world, so the world loses her upward. The impossible event is usually a metaphor made flesh, which lets a story carry political and emotional freight that direct statement would flatten. The mode has been especially powerful for writers from colonised and violent histories, Garcia Marquez, Salman Rushdie, Toni Morrison, Ben Okri, precisely because official realism never told their communities' truth.
The risks are two. Whimsy: magic with no metaphorical spine, sprinkled for charm, which reads as decoration. And incoherence: magic that solves plot problems on demand, which teaches the reader that nothing in the story has weight. The mode's paradoxical discipline is that the impossible must obey rules the story never states.
How to write it in a short story
Choose one impossible thing, not seven, and let it be the literalisation of the story's emotional truth: the lie that sits in the kitchen and grows, the grief that floods the ground floor. Establish the realist world with hard specific detail first, since the magic borrows all its credibility from the rent, the weather and the bus timetable around it. Then narrate the impossible in exactly the register you used for the rent. Give the event ordinary consequences, paperwork, gossip, a smell, because consequence is what makes it real rather than dreamt.
The trap is explanation. The moment anyone investigates the magic, doubts it or traces its mechanism, you have changed genres; magical realism dies under inquiry. The characters may grumble about the flood of grief, but nobody may ask how it works. Judged against a rubric like Writory's, where originality and voice carries a fifth of the mark, a well-run deadpan is a distinctive voice by definition.
Neighbours and opposites
Fantasy is the neighbour most often confused with it, but fantasy builds worlds where magic is acknowledged as magic and usually systematised; magical realism inserts the impossible into this world and refuses to categorise it. Surrealism is a second cousin that abandons realist logic altogether, following dream association rather than consequence. Fabulism and the modern fairy tale sit between, franker about their unreality. The term itself began outside literature: the critic Franz Roh coined it in 1925 for a school of German painting, and Latin American criticism later remade it.
The opposite is strict realism, and the relationship is intimate: magical realism is realism's grammar with one impossible noun, which is why it fails whenever the surrounding realism is thin.
What poets can take from this
- Allow one impossible element per story and make it a metaphor made literal.
- Narrate the magic in the same register as the rent and the weather.
- Give impossible events mundane consequences: gossip, paperwork, laundry.
- Never let any character investigate or explain the magic.
- Build the realist detail first; the magic borrows its credibility.
Try it yourself
A week after a betrayal, something impossible and physical appears in the family home, growing slightly whenever the betrayal is mentioned. Write the story in a flat domestic register, never explain the object, and end on an ordinary chore performed around it.
Questions
What is the difference between magical realism and fantasy?
Fantasy frames magic as magic, often with rules, costs and wonder, and frequently in an invented world. Magical realism places impossible events in the real world and narrates them as unremarkable fact, with no system, no explanation and no astonishment.
Who invented the term magical realism?
The German critic Franz Roh coined it in 1925 to describe a movement in painting. Critics of Latin American literature adopted and transformed it decades later, and the fiction of Garcia Marquez, among others, fixed its current meaning.
Can magical realism be set outside Latin America?
Yes, and much of it is: Toni Morrison in the United States, Salman Rushdie in India and Britain, Ben Okri in Nigeria. What defines the mode is the deadpan treatment of the impossible, not geography, though its Latin American history still shapes how critics read it.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.