Setting
Quick answer: Setting is the where and when of a story, and in good fiction it argues with the characters. Examples from Hardy and Dickens, plus how to choose a setting that works.
Where does your story happen, and why there rather than anywhere else? Setting is the where and when of a narrative: the physical place, the historical moment, the season, the weather, the social world and the objects among which the characters move. In other words, it is everything the story would lose if you lifted the same people and events into a different room, town or century.
Setting is a concern for every kind of fiction, from a two-page domestic story to a nine-volume epic, and it operates at every stage of craft: a planning decision first, a scene-writing resource second, and a revision question last, when you ask whether the place is pulling its weight. Weak stories treat setting as a backdrop. Strong ones treat it as a pressure.
The term at work: Egdon Heath before anyone speaks
Thomas Hardy opens The Return of the Native (1878) not with a person but with a place. The first chapter is given entirely to Egdon Heath at dusk: a vast, dark, unenclosed moor that Hardy describes as a face on which time makes little impression. Only after the heath has been established does a human figure appear on it, and every character who follows is measured by their relation to the place, those who belong to it, those who long to escape it, and those it destroys.
Hardy is doing openly what most fiction does quietly: making the setting an actor. The heath shapes the plot, times the meetings, kills, shelters and outlasts. Dickens performs the same move with the fog that opens Bleak House (1853), which drifts from the river into the Court of Chancery until weather becomes a verdict on an institution. In both cases the setting is not where the meaning happens; it is part of the meaning.
What setting does for a story
First, it constrains, and constraint is plot fuel. A blizzard, a border, a small town where everyone knows everyone: each closes exits and forces characters into decisions. Second, it characterises. Show a reader a person's kitchen and you have told them more than a paragraph of description of the person. Third, it carries mood and theme without commentary, the way Hardy's heath carries indifference and Dickens's fog carries obfuscation.
The risks run the other way. A setting described for its own sake becomes travelogue, and pace dies while the narrator admires scenery. A setting chosen by default, the anonymous city, the unexamined suburb, wastes one of the few free sources of meaning fiction has. And research can show: writers back from a trip or a rabbit hole tend to include everything they learned, which is inventory, not place.
How to choose and write a setting
Choose a setting that argues with your protagonist. A woman who craves quiet, placed in a house beside a level crossing; a man ashamed of his origins, sent home. When place and person want different things, scenes generate themselves. Then render the place through the character's senses and errands rather than in blocks: three exact details deployed while something happens beat a page of standing description. Give the setting a clock as well as a map, since time of day, season and era are all setting.
The trap to avoid is front-loading. Resist opening with a full survey of the location before anyone wants anything. Establish a few anchoring details, start the trouble, and release the rest of the place as the story moves through it. In judged contests this matters doubly; Writory's Short Story Contest scores theme and resonance, and a setting that quietly carries the theme earns marks no scenery paragraph can.
Neighbours and opposites
Setting is often confused with worldbuilding, but worldbuilding is the invention of the whole container, including history and rules the story never shows, while setting is the specific where and when this story occupies. Atmosphere is the emotional colouring a setting gives off, an effect of setting rather than a synonym. Milieu, a term you will meet in older criticism, means the social environment specifically: class, manners, institutions.
There is no true opposite of setting, because even a story told entirely in dialogue happens somewhere in the reader's mind. But there is settingless writing, the placeless default that could occur anywhere, and its blandness is the strongest argument for treating place as a decision rather than an accident.
What poets can take from this
- Pick a setting that makes your protagonist's problem harder, not just a pretty one.
- Render place in motion, through errands and obstacles, not in standing description.
- Use three exact details rather than ten approximate ones.
- Remember that era, season and hour are setting, not only geography.
- In revision, ask what the story would lose if relocated; if the answer is nothing, choose again.
Try it yourself
Write the same two-character argument twice: once in a cramped car in traffic, once in an open field at dusk. Change nothing about what they want, only where they are. Notice which lines survive both settings and which the place itself rewrote.
Questions
What is the difference between setting and worldbuilding?
Setting is the specific where and when of your story, the rooms and weather the reader actually visits. Worldbuilding is the larger act of inventing the whole world those rooms sit inside, including rules and history that never reach the page. Every story has a setting; not every story needs invented worldbuilding.
How much setting description does a short story need?
Less than most drafts contain, but placed earlier. Readers need to be grounded within the first page, a place, a time, a body in space, yet a few precise details will do it. Spread the rest through the action instead of banking it in an opening block.
Can setting be a character?
Not literally, since it makes no choices, but it can act on the plot the way an antagonist does, closing exits, applying pressure and outlasting everyone. Hardy's Egdon Heath and the sea in many voyage stories work exactly this way, and the phrase survives because the effect feels like personhood.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.