Do Short Story Contests Pay?
Quick answer: Do short story contests pay? Many pay real prizes, from $100 to five figures, some pay in publication or feedback, and a few only take. How to tell which.
Many do, and some pay better per word than any magazine. Short story contest prizes range from token sums of 50 to 100 dollars at small community competitions, through the common 500-to-5,000-dollar band at established prizes, up to five-figure awards at the famous international ones. Beyond cash, contests pay in publication, judge feedback, certificates and career visibility. A minority pay nothing meaningful at all, and a fee-charging subset exists mainly to collect fees.
So the honest answer has two parts: yes, real money exists in contests, and the distribution is lumpy. Knowing which kind of contest you are looking at, before you pay to enter, is the entire skill.
The prize landscape, tier by tier
At the top sit the famous internationals: awards attached to major foundations, newspapers and universities, paying anywhere from several thousand to tens of thousands for a single story. One well-known transatlantic award pays its winner more than most novelists' advances. The middle band is the workhorse tier: established magazine contests and regional prizes paying a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, typically alongside publication. The wide base is small competitions, community, library, themed, paying modest sums or publication and a certificate.
Non-cash compensation deserves pricing too, and at the tiers most writers actually enter it often outweighs the cheque. Publication in a respected contest issue is a real credit that cover letters can cite for years. Judge feedback or scores, where offered, convert a losing entry into information no magazine rejection ever provides. Some prizes include mentorships, festival invitations or agency introductions, which have launched more careers than the money that accompanied them. Read the full prize package, not just the headline number.
The fee question, faced honestly
Most paying contests charge entry fees, commonly three to twenty-five dollars, and the fee is not inherently a scam; it funds prizes, judges and administration, exactly as race entries fund marathons. The test is proportion and transparency. A twenty-dollar fee for a 5,000-dollar prize with named judges and published past winners is a normal cultural economy. A twenty-dollar fee for a 100-dollar prize with anonymous judging and no visible history is a fundraising operation wearing a rosette.
Run the expected-value arithmetic without romance: fee, field size where published, prize pool, plus everything non-monetary you would actually receive. Feedback shifts the mathematics considerably; a fee that buys a judged score or critique pays you something even in defeat, while a silent no returns nothing. And cap the budget: a fixed annual contest allowance, spent on a shortlist of competitions you researched, outperforms scattershot entering both financially and emotionally.
What winners actually receive, beyond the transfer
Talk to writers who have won mid-tier contests and a pattern emerges: the money was spent in a month, the credit worked for years. Contest wins are unusually legible credentials, a named prize with a judge attached tells agents and editors that someone specific chose this story over a defined field, which a magazine acceptance, decided in private, never quite communicates. Anthology publication, local press, festival readings and the winner's next cover letter all compound it.
There is also the measurable-progress effect. Contests judge to deadlines against rubrics, so entering regularly gives your year a structure of finished stories that open-ended magazine submitting rarely enforces. Even placing, longlists and shortlists, is a public, citable signal. None of this requires winning the famous prizes; a consistent record at honest smaller contests builds the same staircase at smaller scale.
Reading a contest before you pay
Five checks, ten minutes. Past winners: published, findable, good? A contest proud of its history shows it. Judges: named humans with relevant standing? Rights: taken from winners only, for a limited period, not from every entrant? Fee-to-prize ratio: proportionate? Sponsor: an organisation with a life beyond running contests, a magazine, a foundation, a festival, or a website that exists only to run fee-charging competitions?
Failing marks on two or more checks means keep your story and your money. Passing marks mean the remaining question is fit: read a past winning story and judge whether your work belongs in that company and whether that company flatters your work. Contests pay best when chosen the way you would choose a magazine, for the readership and the standard, with the prize as the accelerant rather than the whole engine.
What poets can take from this
- Read the whole prize package: publication, feedback and introductions often outlast the cheque.
- Judge fees by proportion: fee, prize pool, named judges and visible past winners together.
- Prefer contests that return scores or critiques; those pay every entrant something.
- Set a fixed annual contest budget and spend it on researched competitions only.
- Check the rights clause before entering; winners-only, time-limited is the fair pattern.
Try it yourself
Find three real contests in your price range and read one winning story from each. Write a one-line verdict on whether your work belongs in that company. Then enter the one where the answer was almost, with a story finished to deadline. Almost is where growth lives.
Questions
What is the biggest prize for a short story?
The largest regular short fiction awards pay in the tens of thousands of dollars or pounds for a single story, usually run by major foundations, newspapers or universities. Fields at that level are enormous, but the prizes are real and awarded annually.
Are free short story contests worth entering?
Often, since the downside is only time: many reputable magazines, libraries and festivals run free competitions with cash or publication prizes. Apply the same checks as for paid contests, especially the rights clause, because free sometimes coexists with a grabby fine print.
Do contest wins help you get published elsewhere?
Yes, visibly. A named prize with a defined field and an identifiable judge is a legible credential in cover letters and agent queries, and editors treat contest-winning writers as pre-vetted. Even shortlists carry citable weight.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.