Do You Need an MFA to Be a Writer?
Quick answer: Do you need an MFA to be a writer? No. What the degree buys is time, community and teaching credentials; publication has never required one.
No. No agent, editor or magazine requires an MFA, and the majority of published novelists do not have one. What the degree genuinely buys is two or three funded years to write, a community of serious peers, faculty feedback, and the credential needed to teach writing at university level. If those are what you want, an MFA can be excellent value, especially fully funded. If what you want is simply to be published, the degree is one optional route among several cheaper ones.
Getting this straight matters because the MFA question stalls a surprising number of writers, some waiting years for an acceptance letter as permission to begin. Publishing runs on manuscripts, not transcripts, and the reading and writing hours the degree structures can be structured without it.
What an MFA Actually Provides
Strip away the mystique and the degree delivers four concrete things. Time: a funded programme pays you, modestly, to treat writing as your job, which for many people is the only period of their life that will be true. Community: a cohort who take the work seriously, some of whom become lifelong first readers. Feedback: regular workshop critique plus faculty attention on a thesis manuscript. Credential: the terminal degree that university teaching posts require.
Notice what is missing from the list. Publication is not provided, and programmes are honest about this; plenty of graduates never publish a book, and agents request pages, not diplomas. Connections are real but overrated, since an introduction gets you a faster read, not a yes. The manuscript still has to do everything.
The Ledger, Both Columns
The case studies cut both ways. Flannery O'Connor was shaped by Iowa; Kazuo Ishiguro came through East Anglia; George Saunders took an engineering degree into oil-field work, then an MFA at Syracuse, where he now teaches. Against them stand Gillian Flynn, trained in journalism; Andy Weir, a programmer who serialised The Martian on his website; Cormac McCarthy, Hilary Mantel, Zadie Smith publishing her first novel while still an undergraduate reading English.
The money column matters most. A fully funded MFA, with tuition waived and a stipend paid, is defensible almost regardless of outcome. An unfunded one can cost the price of a house deposit for a credential the market does not require. The standard advice inside the field is blunt: go funded or do not go.
Building the MFA Without Enrolling
Everything the degree provides except the teaching credential can be assembled independently:
Questions to Ask Any Programme
If you do apply, interrogate programmes the way you would any large purchase, because that is what an unfunded one is. The brochure will not volunteer the answers; current students and recent graduates will.
How to Decide
Ask what problem you are hiring the degree to solve. If the answer is time and cohort, and you can get funding, apply. If the answer is I want to teach undergraduates, the credential is genuinely necessary, so apply. If the answer is validation, save your money; imposter feelings survive graduation intact, as any MFA workshop will confirm.
And if the answer is I want my fiction to improve, be honest about the mechanism. Improvement comes from the loop of drafting, feedback and revision, wherever that loop runs. Two years of disciplined self-study with real deadlines beats two distracted years in a programme, and costs nothing but the discipline.
What poets can take from this
- Never pay full price for an MFA; funded programmes exist and the market treats the degrees identically.
- Apply for time and community, not for publication odds.
- If teaching at university is the goal, the credential is required; otherwise it is optional.
- Build the free version first for one year; you may find it is all you needed.
- Judge any programme by its funding and its graduates' books, not its brochure.
Try it yourself
Write a story that takes place entirely during the fifteen-minute break in a writing workshop, in the corridor outside the room. The draft being critiqued belongs to the one student who has not come out for the break.
Questions
Do agents and publishers care about an MFA?
Only as a mild signal that you take the work seriously; it might earn a slightly faster read. No agent signs a weak manuscript because of a degree, and none rejects a strong one for lacking it.
What can you do with an MFA besides write?
The main career use is teaching creative writing at college level, where the terminal degree is a standard requirement. Graduates also move into editing, publishing and arts administration, though none of those strictly require it.
Are online MFA programmes worth it?
Low-residency and online programmes suit working adults and can offer strong faculty, but funding is rarer, so the cost question bites harder. Apply the same rule: weigh the debt against time, community and credential, not against dreams of publication.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.