How Do You Revise a Short Story?
Quick answer: How do you revise a short story? Rest the draft, reread it whole, fix structure before sentences, and work in passes. A practical revision order that works.
Revise a short story in this order: rest the draft until you can read it like a stranger, usually a week or more; reread it in one sitting without touching anything; fix the big things first, meaning what the story is about, whose it is, where it starts and how it ends; then rebuild scenes; then, last of all, polish sentences. Revision is triage. Fixing commas in a scene you later delete is the most common way writers waste their editing hours.
The order matters because early drafts are usually wrong at the level of structure, not language, and beautiful sentences will seduce you into keeping broken scenes. A short story is small enough to hold entirely in your head, which is its great revising advantage over a novel: you can genuinely re-see the whole thing, and re-seeing is what revision means.
First: rest it, then read it cold
Distance is not a luxury; it is the mechanism. Immediately after drafting, you read what you meant. After a week or three, you read what you wrote, and the gap between the two is where every revision lives. Put the draft away and work on something else. When you return, print it or change the font, read it in one sitting at reading speed, and keep your hands off the keyboard. Notes in the margin only: bored here, don't believe this, why is she suddenly kind.
Then write one sentence: this is a story about X. If you cannot, that is not a failure of the exercise, it is the diagnosis. Most limp drafts are limp because the writer has not yet decided what the story is about, and no amount of line polish can compensate. The first real act of revision is choosing.
The structural pass: story-level surgery
With the about-sentence in hand, interrogate the skeleton. Does the story start where something changes, or does it start two pages earlier, with weather and waking up? Short stories almost always begin too early; the classic fix is deleting the first page and finding the opening was hiding at the bottom of it. Is this the right point-of-view character, the one with the most to lose? Does the ending land on the story's true subject, or swerve into neatness?
Check the engine too: what does the main character want, what resists them, what changes by the last line. If nothing changes, you have a sketch. Be willing to cut whole characters and merge two scenes into one; at 2,000 words or fewer, every element must earn its place twice over. This is also where a rubric mindset helps, and it is no accident that contest scoring, including the five-part rubric Writory publishes for its Short Story Contest, weighs structure and emotional effect before prose polish.
The scene and line passes
Once the skeleton holds, revise scene by scene. Enter each scene late and leave early. Make sure every scene turns something: a decision, a discovery, a shift in power; a scene that only conveys information can usually become one line in a better scene. Check that dialogue is doing two jobs at once, advancing the story while revealing the speaker, and that your setting details are specific enough to be seen.
Only now do sentences get their turn. Read the whole story aloud, slowly; your ear will catch the repetitions, the limp verbs, the rhythm failures your eye forgives. Hunt filter constructions like 'she saw' and 'he felt', cut adverbs that prop weak verbs, and delete your favourite flourish if it points at the author rather than the story. A useful final constraint: cut ten percent. Nearly every draft carries that much fat, and the discipline forces real choices.
Common revision mistakes
The deadliest is polishing too early, spending three evenings on the prose of an opening you should have deleted. The second is revising forever, orbiting a story for years because finishing means being judged; set a pass limit, three or four, then send it somewhere real. The third is revising by committee, incorporating every note from every reader until the story has no author left. Look for convergence in feedback, not compliance.
Two quieter errors: revising on screen only, when paper and read-alouds catch different faults, and treating cutting as loss. Keep a graveyard file for everything you remove; nothing is wasted, and the knowledge that cuts are recoverable makes you braver. Bravery, in the end, is the revising virtue that matters most, because the difference between a draft and a story is usually one hard decision the writer finally stopped avoiding.
What poets can take from this
- Rest a story at least a week before revising; distance is the actual tool.
- Write 'this is a story about X' before changing a word, and revise towards it.
- Fix structure, then scenes, then sentences, never the reverse.
- Try deleting your first page; the real opening is often buried beneath it.
- Read the whole story aloud in the final pass and cut ten percent.
- Set a pass limit and then submit; endless revision is fear wearing overalls.
Try it yourself
Take a finished draft and perform surgery without anaesthetic: delete the first page entirely, then rewrite the opening in 150 words starting at the moment something changes. Compare the two openings honestly, and keep whichever one a stranger would keep.
Questions
How many drafts should a short story go through?
Three to five substantial passes is typical: one structural, one or two at scene level, one for lines, plus a proofread. More than that usually signals avoidance rather than craft. The number matters less than doing the passes in order.
How long should you wait before revising a story?
A week is the practical minimum; a month is better if a deadline allows. You need long enough to forget your intentions and read only the words. Working on a different piece in between speeds up the forgetting.
Should I revise before getting feedback?
Yes, at least one structural pass. Readers spending goodwill on problems you already knew about wastes them, and their best service is catching what you cannot see. Hand over the best version you can make alone.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.