What Is a Plot Bunny?
Quick answer: What is a plot bunny? Writer slang for a story idea that hops in uninvited and multiplies, usually mid-project. What causes them and what to do with one.
A plot bunny is writer slang for a story idea that arrives uninvited, usually while you are working on something else, and refuses to leave. The name is a joke about rabbits: bunnies multiply, and so do these ideas, each one spawning subplots and characters until your current project starts to look grey by comparison. A plot bunny is not a plan. It is an infatuation with an idea you have not yet tested.
The term matters because it names a real hazard of the drafting life. The middle of any project is hard, and the brain, hunting for relief, offers you a shiny new story that feels effortless precisely because you have not written it yet. Knowing the pattern has a name helps you treat it as weather rather than destiny.
Where the term comes from
The phrase grew up in online writing communities in the late 1990s and early 2000s, and it spread widely through fan fiction forums and the National Novel Writing Month message boards, where thousands of drafters mid-slog compared notes on the new ideas tormenting them. Nobody owns the coinage, and you will see variants: bunnies breed, bunnies bite, writers speak of being ambushed by one in the shower.
There is an older cousin in publishing folklore, the anecdote sometimes attached to John Steinbeck, that ideas are like rabbits: get a couple and learn to handle them, and soon you have a dozen. Whatever its exact pedigree, the rabbit metaphor stuck because it captures both halves of the experience: ideas are fertile, and they are not housetrained.
Why plot bunnies strike mid-project
Plot bunnies almost never attack on day one of a draft. They attack in the middle, and the timing is the tell. By the midpoint, your current story has revealed its problems: the sagging second act, the character who will not come alive, the research you have been avoiding. A new idea has no problems yet, because problems only appear in execution. The bunny is not better than your project. It is merely unexamined.
Psychologists would call this a flavour of the shiny object problem; drafters call it the middle-of-the-book blues. Either way, the arithmetic is brutal: a writer who follows every bunny finishes nothing, and owns instead a warren of chapter ones. Most abandoned novels were not abandoned for good reasons. They were abandoned for younger ideas that were, six weeks later, abandoned in turn.
What to do when one shows up
Do not ignore it entirely; suppressed ideas nag louder. Do not follow it either. The working compromise most authors settle on has three steps:
When you should actually follow the bunny
Occasionally the new idea deserves the keys. The honest signals: it survives the hutch for a month and keeps growing specific scenes rather than vague glamour; it solves a problem your current project cannot, such as being the story you are actually equipped to write right now; or your current draft is finished in rough form and resting, in which case the bunny is not an interruption at all, it is simply next. What it should never be is a rescue from a hard chapter, because the hard chapter will be waiting in the new project too, six weeks along.
Short work gives you a middle path. A bunny that would derail a novel can be drained into a 1,500-word story in a weekend, tested for real, and either retired or promoted. Writers who keep a short-story habit lose fewer novels to rabbits, because the hutch has an exit.
What poets can take from this
- Give every new mid-project idea fifteen minutes on paper, then close the file and return to work.
- Keep one dedicated bunny file so your brain believes nothing gets lost.
- Adopt a finish rule: rough draft complete before any new project begins.
- Reread captured ideas quarterly; daylight kills most of them and proves the survivors.
- Drain small bunnies into short stories instead of letting them gnaw at your novel.
- Treat mid-draft infatuation as a symptom of a fixable problem in the current story, and go find the problem.
Try it yourself
Open your abandoned-ideas file and choose the oldest entry. Write a 500-word scene from it, today, as a short piece with a proper beginning and an ending, however rough. Decide afterwards, in one written sentence, whether it earned a bigger life or a respectful burial, and note what the verdict tells you about the ideas you tend to chase.
Questions
Is a plot bunny the same as a story idea?
A plot bunny is a story idea with bad timing and good marketing. The content may be identical; the term describes the way it arrives, uninvited and mid-project, and the way it multiplies if you feed it your drafting hours.
Why do my best ideas arrive while I'm working on something else?
Because drafting puts your story brain in gear, and a brain in gear generates ideas indiscriminately. The new ones look best because they have no flaws yet. Capture them briefly and keep going; the glow rarely survives a month.
How do I stop starting new projects and never finishing?
Make finishing the only door to starting. Keep a capture file for new ideas, set a visible finish line for the current draft, and shrink the project if you must, but cross a finish line before you begin again. Finishing is a trainable habit.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.