What Is Blind Judging in Writing Contests?
Quick answer: Blind judging in writing contests means entries are read without names attached. How anonymity works, why it protects newcomers and how not to break it.
Blind judging means contest entries are read and scored without the judges knowing who wrote them: names, bios and identifying details are stripped before manuscripts reach readers, and identity is reconnected only after decisions are final. The practice exists to make the field fair, a newcomer's story competes on identical terms with an established writer's, and to protect judges from bias they could not help, friendly, hostile or starstruck.
For entrants the concept carries one practical command and one large comfort. The command: keep your name out of the file, completely. The comfort: in a blind contest, nobody needs to know you to choose you.
How the anonymity machinery works
Well-run contests separate identity from manuscript at intake: your details live in the entry form or a cover sheet, the story file carries only a title, and an administrator, never a judge, holds the key matching numbers to names. Judges receive numbered manuscripts, score them, and submit rankings; only then does the administrator reconnect identities for the announcement. Some contests double-blind the middle rounds too, so committee members argue about entry 214 rather than about anyone's friend.
Your side of the machinery is hygiene. No name in the manuscript body, header or title page. No identifying anecdotes framed as fiction the judges could google. And the one everyone forgets: file metadata, since documents quietly store an author name in their properties, and a contest administrator who must scrub it for you may be required to disqualify instead. Check document properties before export; the rule is usually stated, and always enforced somewhere.
Why contests bother, and what the evidence says
Anonymised evaluation has a famous proof from another art: when major orchestras moved auditions behind screens, the hiring of women rose sharply, because the screen removed a bias the judges did not believe they had. Literary judging inherits the same physics. Names carry gravity, reputation, familiarity, demography, and blind reading is the screen that lets the sentences alone argue. Editors who read slush both ways confirm the difference: known names get patience, unknown names get pages, and blindness rations patience equally.
For contests specifically, blindness also defends the prize's meaning. A win chosen blind is a verdict on the story, citable without asterisks, and fields stay large partly because entrants trust the game. It is why the practice clusters at the reputable end: anonymity costs administration, and operations that invest in it are usually the same ones publishing rubrics and past winners. Writory's Short Story Contest, for one, judges every entry blind against its published criteria, so a first-time entrant and a many-time winner meet the same reading.
Writing for readers who cannot know you
Blind judging changes what your first page must do. No bio softens the reader; no previous credit buys a second chance. The story must establish authority by itself, immediately, through control of prose and consequence, which is bracing once you accept it: the blind field is the one arena where nothing you lack, connections, credits, a name, counts against you. Everything the judges can love is already in your file or it is nowhere.
Practically, this argues for spending your effort where anonymous reading concentrates: the opening page that survives triage, the ending that wins arguments in committee, the distinct material only you could bring, since voice is the one signature anonymity cannot strip. It also argues for entering blind contests early in a writing life, precisely when your cover letter is thinnest. The screen that hides your empty bio hides everyone else's full one.
How entrants break the blind, usually by accident
The common breaches: a name in the running header copied from a magazine-format template; a title page pasted from a submission to a non-blind market; metadata carrying the author field; a story posted publicly before entering, so a curious judge's search lights up; and self-identification inside the text, my previous novel, the prize I won in 2023, framed as the narrator's but transparently the writer's. Contests handle breaches differently, silent scrubbing at kind ones, disqualification at strict ones, and rules rarely promise kindness.
The deliberate version, hinting at identity to a judge you know, is treated as cheating everywhere and remembered longer than the contest. If you have a relationship with a judge, many contests ask you to sit that year out, and the honourable read the room without being asked. The blind is the fairest machine our trade has built for strangers' work. Entering it cleanly is both self-interest and citizenship: the anonymity protecting everyone else is the same screen giving your pages their equal, unencumbered hearing.
What poets can take from this
- Keep your name out of the body, header, title page and file name of a blind entry.
- Check document properties before export; metadata carries an author field most writers forget.
- Never enter a blind contest with a story already posted publicly under your name.
- Keep two templates: a named manuscript for magazines, an anonymised twin for contests.
- Enter blind contests early in your career; the screen that hides your thin bio hides everyone's.
Try it yourself
Write a 1,500-word story you believe could win on its first page alone, then strip it for blind entry: no name anywhere, clean metadata, numbered file. Ask a friend to confirm nothing in the text identifies you. Enter it in a blind-judged contest this month.
Questions
Do judges ever find out who wrote an entry before deciding?
In well-run contests, no; an administrator holds the identity key and reconnects names only after rankings are final. Judges may privately guess at familiar styles, but honest processes give them no way to confirm it while scoring.
What happens if I accidentally leave my name in a contest entry?
Outcomes range by contest: some administrators scrub the file and proceed, others disqualify, and the rules usually reserve the right to. Email the organisers immediately if you catch the error; a prompt correction before judging often saves the entry.
Are magazine submissions also judged blind?
Some literary journals read blind, and their guidelines say so, but most magazines see your name and cover letter. That is why contest anonymity needs its own manuscript template rather than the standard named format magazines expect.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.