When Should You Abandon a Story?
Quick answer: When should you abandon a story? Quit when the problem is the conception, not the execution, and when you no longer care about the question at its heart.
Abandon a story when the problem is its conception rather than its execution, and when you no longer care about the question at its centre. A story that is merely hard is worth finishing; a story that has gone dead in your hands, where every fix produces a different story, is telling you something. The practical test: put it away for six weeks, reread it cold, and notice whether you feel dread or curiosity. Curiosity means revise. Dread, on a story whose premise no longer interests you, means let it go.
The distinction matters because both quitting too early and quitting too late are expensive. Serial abandoners never learn the skills that only endings teach, while grim completists spend years on manuscripts that were unworkable from page ten.
Stuck Is Not the Same as Dead
Nearly every story gets stuck, usually around the middle, and stuckness alone is a terrible reason to quit. Stuck stories have a live premise and a broken mechanism: a plot knot, a viewpoint chosen wrongly, a missing character. Those are repairable, and the repair is often the moment a writer levels up. Dead stories are different. The premise itself no longer generates scenes you want to write, and when you imagine the finished version, you feel nothing.
A useful diagnostic is to ask what drew you to the idea originally and whether that thing still exists in the draft. If the spark got revised out three drafts ago, you may be maintaining a building whose tenant already left. If the spark is still there but buried, dig; that is revision, not resurrection.
Writers Who Walked Away, and Came Back
Abandonment is rarely as final as it feels. Stephen King started a novel about a town sealed under an invisible barrier in the 1970s, gave up on it twice because the engineering of the story defeated him, and finished it more than thirty years later as Under the Dome. He has also described nearly abandoning The Stand in its swampy middle before a structural idea rescued it.
Harper Lee's early material took radical reshaping before it became To Kill a Mockingbird, and the draft published decades later as Go Set a Watchman shows how much she left behind. The lesson is not that everything abandoned returns. It is that a drawer is not a grave: shelved work keeps its salvage value, and the skills you built writing it transfer entirely to the next project.
How to Quit Well
If you decide to stop, stop like a professional. First, write yourself a one-page memo: what the story was trying to do, where it went wrong, what you would attempt differently. Future you will thank you. Second, strip it for parts. Characters, settings, images and even whole scenes can migrate into new work; many published short stories began life as the one good chapter of a doomed novel.
Third, archive rather than delete, and date the folder. Then, and this is the step people skip, start something new within a week. The danger after abandonment is not the lost manuscript; it is the vacuum. A short piece is ideal for restarting momentum, and a deadline helps: a monthly contest window such as Writory's gives the next story a shape and a ship date before doubt can settle in.
Tell your first readers too, if the story had any. A sentence closing the file with witnesses makes the decision real, stops the guilty reopening cycle, and frees the attention the half-dead project was quietly taxing every week.
Bad Reasons to Abandon a Story
Do not quit because the draft is bad. All drafts are bad; that is what drafts are for, and the gap between your draft and the books you love is a revision gap, not a talent verdict. Do not quit because a similar book just came out, since premises overlap constantly and execution is what distinguishes them. Do not quit at the first structural problem, because solving those is the actual job.
And be honest about pattern. If you have abandoned your last five stories at roughly the same point, the problem is not five separate bad ideas. It is a skill or habit issue at that mile marker, and the only way through is to finish one anyway, ugly if necessary, to learn what the far side looks like.
What poets can take from this
- Apply the six-week drawer test before any abandonment decision; never quit inside a bad writing day.
- Ask whether your original spark still exists anywhere in the draft.
- If you quit, write a one-page post-mortem memo before closing the folder.
- Archive abandoned drafts with dates; shelved is not deleted.
- If you always quit at the same point, finish the next story regardless, as an exercise.
- Start a new, smaller piece within a week of any abandonment.
Try it yourself
Open your most recently abandoned draft and pull out exactly one character, one image and one line of dialogue. Write a completely new 800-word story that uses all three, set somewhere the original story never went.
Questions
Is it normal to abandon a novel halfway through?
Very. The middle is where initial excitement runs out and structural debts come due, so most abandonments cluster there. Before quitting, try skipping ahead to write the ending you imagine; knowing the destination often revives the route.
Can an abandoned story be fixed later?
Often, yes. Time reveals structure that closeness hides, which is why writers like Stephen King returned to shelved manuscripts decades on and finished them. Keep everything, write a note about what went wrong, and revisit after a year.
Do professional writers abandon projects?
Constantly, and usually more than beginners, because they start more. Most published novelists describe at least one practice novel in a drawer, and short story writers routinely shelve a piece per month. The skill is quitting deliberately rather than drifting away.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.