Pastoral
Quick answer: The pastoral tradition in poetry: shepherds, idealised countryside and the pastoral elegy, from Theocritus to Lycidas, with advice for writing your own.
Pastoral is the oldest running joke in poetry that is also completely serious: sophisticated city poets writing about shepherds who speak beautifully, love hopelessly and never seem to do much herding. The tradition begins with Theocritus, a Greek poet of the third century BC writing in urban Alexandria about the Sicilian countryside of his youth. Virgil inherited it, Renaissance Europe made it a craze, and its afterlives run through Romantic landscape poetry into modern ecopoetry.
Strictly speaking, pastoral is a mode rather than a fixed form: no set line count, rhyme scheme or metre defines it. What defines it is a stance, the countryside viewed through longing, usually by someone who has left it or is about to lose it.
A short history of an idealised field
After Theocritus and Virgil fixed the conventions, pastoral slept through much of the Middle Ages and woke spectacularly in the Renaissance. Spenser announced himself with the pastoral Shepheardes Calender (1579); Marlowe's 'The Passionate Shepherd to His Love' made the seduction-by-scenery poem famous, and Walter Raleigh's 'The Nymph's Reply' punctured it, inaugurating the anti-pastoral counter-tradition. The mode also produced a durable subgenre, the pastoral elegy, in which a dead friend becomes a dead shepherd mourned by nature itself: Milton's 'Lycidas' (1637) and Shelley's 'Adonais' (1821) are the towering English examples. Later poets kept quarrelling with the mode; George Crabbe's 'The Village' answered its prettiness with rural poverty, and much contemporary nature writing continues the argument.
The working conventions
Because pastoral is a mode, its rules are furniture rather than architecture. The recurring pieces:
Writing pastoral now
Do not fake sheep. Modern pastoral works when you translate the stance honestly: the allotment, the childhood village swallowed by a bypass, the national park visited on annual leave. Choose your lovely place and render it with specific flora, weather and labour, then let the longing show its seams, since the best pastoral always knows it is idealising. Decide where you stand on the mode's central lie, that country life is simple, and let the poem argue with itself. A singing contest can become two friends topping each other's memories; an elegy can mourn a landscape rather than a person.
Strengths and the sentimental trap
Pastoral suits homesickness, environmental grief, elegy and any poem about the gap between the life you live and the life you picture. Its conventions are so old that readers feel them even unnamed.
The beginner's failure is postcard writing: generic hills, unspecified flowers, a word like 'idyllic' doing the work detail should do. The cure is agricultural accuracy. Name the crop, the breed, the machine, the smell. Pastoral survives its own idealism only when the mud is real.
What poets can take from this
- Translate the shepherd honestly: allotments, caravans, family farms.
- Name species, crops and weather precisely; no generic meadows.
- Let the poem admit it is idealising; self-awareness is built into the mode.
- Try the two-voice structure: one speaker praising, one correcting.
- For a pastoral elegy, follow the old arc from grief to consolation.
Try it yourself
Write a pastoral in which you praise a green place you loved as a child, then let one intrusive modern detail, a pylon, a ring road, a phone, complicate the picture without destroying it.
Questions
What is a pastoral poem?
A poem presenting rural life, traditionally shepherds' lives, in an idealised way, usually written by and for city dwellers. It is a mode with recurring conventions rather than a fixed form with set rules.
What is a pastoral elegy?
An elegy that mourns the dead using pastoral conventions: the deceased appears as a shepherd, nature joins the grieving, and the poem ends in consolation. Milton's 'Lycidas' is the classic English example.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.