The Egg by Sherwood Anderson
Quick answer: The Egg by Sherwood Anderson, summary and analysis: the chicken farm, the restaurant scene with Joe Kane, the father's breakdown and the story's meaning explained.
A cheerful Ohio farmhand marries a schoolteacher, catches the American fever of ambition, and spends the next decade being defeated by chickens. Sherwood Anderson's narrator looks back on his parents' doomed poultry farm and the restaurant that followed it, and decides that his family's whole tragedy can be read in a single object: the egg.
The story appeared in 1920 and became the anchor of Anderson's 1921 collection The Triumph of the Egg. It is short, plain-spoken and devastating, told by a son who watched ambition hollow out his gentle father. Students meet it as a classic critique of the American dream; writers prize it as perhaps the best example in the language of letting one homely object carry an entire story's meaning.
The story in brief
The narrator's father is content until, at thirty-four, he marries an ambitious schoolteacher, and the couple resolves to rise in the world. They spend ten years on a chicken farm near Bidwell, Ohio, a decade the narrator describes with bitter comedy: chickens die of every disease known, hopes hatch and are crushed, and the family's one treasure becomes a shelf of deformed chicks, two-headed and four-legged grotesques, preserved in alcohol. Defeated, they move to Pickleville, a crossroads near the railway, and open a small restaurant. The mother believes the father should entertain the customers; cheerfulness becomes a business plan, and the father, a bald, worried man, sets out to become a public performer of jollity.
One night the young Joe Kane waits in the restaurant for a delayed train, and the father stakes everything on impressing him. He tells the story of Christopher Columbus, denouncing him as a cheat for breaking the egg to stand it on end, and swears he can stand an egg upright without breaking it. The trick fails over and over while Joe watches politely. Desperate, the father attempts a second feat, forcing a boiled egg into a bottle by heating it; the egg breaks, spattering him, just as Joe's train arrives and the audience leaves laughing. The father grabs another egg, roars, and charges upstairs to where his wife and son are sleeping. Meaning to destroy it, he instead lays it gently on the bedside table, kneels, and weeps. The narrator, now grown, still wonders why eggs must be, and concludes that the egg has triumphed over his family completely and finally.
The characters
Three people and one object, which is the correct way to count this cast.
Themes and meaning
The standard reading is the American dream as trap: ambition enters a happy household like an infection, and the story's structures of rising, the farm, the move, the restaurant, all descend. The grotesque preserved chicks are usually cited as symbols of deformed hope, treasures made of failure. The chicken-and-egg cycle gives Anderson his bleak cosmology, life producing death producing life, with profit nowhere in it.
The subtler point is about performance. The father's tragedy is not poverty but the demand that he convert his private sweetness into public entertainment. His collapse comes when showmanship fails in front of an audience of one. Anderson, writing just after Winesburg, Ohio, is extending his great subject: what happens to ordinary Americans when they are required to be remarkable.
The craft: one object, fully loaded
The technique worth studying is symbolic saturation. Anderson does not decorate the story with the egg; he builds every scene out of it: livelihood, grotesques, the Columbus rant, the bottle trick, the final gentle surrender. By the last page the object can mean fragility, ambition, fatherhood and futility simultaneously, because the plot, not the narrator's commentary, put those meanings there. When a symbol earns its weight through action, no explaining is needed.
Notice also the framing voice. The son narrates events he mostly did not witness, reconstructing his father's worst night with love and speculation, and that distance is what makes the humiliation bearable and the grief permanent. A first-person witness inside the restaurant would give us farce; the remembering son gives us elegy. Choosing the right distance from pain is half of storytelling, and it is the kind of judgement that separates high-scoring contest entries on emotional impact from merely sad ones.
What poets can take from this
- In exams, track the egg through all its forms: livestock, grotesque, prop, weapon and finally relic on the bedside table.
- Name the inversion in the title: the egg, not the family, achieves the triumph.
- Use the Columbus speech as evidence of the father's rage at a world that rewards cheats.
- As a writer, build your central symbol through plot events rather than through commentary.
- Try narrating a parent's defeat from a child's remembering distance and note how the tone changes.
- Let a character fail at something small in front of a tiny audience; intimacy multiplies humiliation.
Try it yourself
Choose one ordinary object from a family business, a loaf, a key, a receipt spike, and write a story in which it appears in five scenes, changing meaning each time, until a parent's whole life seems contained in it. Never state what it symbolises.
Questions
What does the egg symbolise in Sherwood Anderson's story?
The egg gathers meanings as the story moves: new life and hope on the farm, deformity in the jarred grotesques, the promise of success in the restaurant tricks, and finally futility when the father cannot master it. Anderson lets it stand for the whole cycle of American ambition, fragile, oval and closed.
Why does the father cry at the end of The Egg?
His attempt to entertain Joe Kane has failed grotesquely, and with it his effort to become the cheerful, rising man his family's ambitions require. Carrying the egg upstairs to destroy it, he finds he cannot even do that, and his tears acknowledge that the egg, and everything it stands for, has beaten him.
Is The Egg part of Winesburg, Ohio?
No. It appeared in Anderson's 1921 collection The Triumph of the Egg, though it shares the Winesburg territory of small-town Ohio and the same compassion for defeated, inarticulate people. Bidwell, near the family's farm, recurs elsewhere in Anderson's fiction.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.