The Storyteller by Saki
Quick answer: The Storyteller by Saki: full summary with the ending, the bachelor's tale of horribly good Bertha, themes of moral tales versus honest fiction, and the craft.
A hot railway carriage, three restless children, an aunt whose answers all begin with don't, and a stranger in the corner who finally cannot bear it: The Storyteller, from Beasts and Super-Beasts (1914), is Saki's declaration of war on improving literature for the young, staged as a storytelling contest with an audience of three.
It is one of the most joyful things he wrote, a story about stories that actually demonstrates its argument, and schools assign it partly in self-mockery, since the aunt it demolishes is a standing risk of the profession. Writers get something rarer: a working comparison of a bad story and a good one built from identical parts.
The story in brief, ending included
An aunt travels with a small boy and two small girls in a hot railway carriage; a bachelor shares it, unluckily for him. The children ask relentless questions, the aunt answers with feeble prohibitions, and when she attempts a story it is exactly what her conversation promised: a good little girl, saved from a mad bull by rescuers who admired her goodness. The children savage it with one question, would they not have saved her anyway, and the aunt's defence collapses. Stung by the bachelor's remark that she seems an unsuccessful storyteller, she challenges him to do better. He does.
His story concerns Bertha, a girl who was not merely good but horribly good, decorated with three medals, for obedience, punctuality and good conduct, which clinked as she walked. As a reward for supreme virtue she is granted the unique honour of walking in the Prince's park, where no children go, and where there are no flowers, because the pigs have eaten them; the Prince keeps pigs. Into the park comes an enormous wolf, hunting. Bertha hides in a myrtle bush and might have survived, except that she trembles so hard with terror that her medals for goodness clink against one another, and the wolf finds her and devours her, leaving only her shoes, scraps of clothing, and the three medals. The children pronounce it the most beautiful story they have ever heard. The aunt is outraged: a most improper story to tell young children, undermining years of careful teaching. The bachelor, gathering his things, has the last word as he leaves the carriage: at any rate, he kept them quiet for ten minutes, which was more than she could do, and, he reflects, the unhappy woman will be assailed in public by those children for the next six months with demands for an improper story. That is the ending: the wolf wins, the children win, and improving literature is left dead in the myrtle bushes.
The characters
Every figure is a position in an argument about fiction, and still breathes.
Themes: what children know that moralists forget
The surface theme is didactic fiction versus honest fiction. The aunt's tale claims virtue is rewarded; the children detect the lie instantly, since rescuers save screaming children regardless of conduct marks. The bachelor's tale succeeds not because it is cynical but because it is consistent: in his story, goodness has weight, texture and consequence, medals that clink, and the world remains genuinely dangerous. Children reward the second kind of story because it respects what they already know about reality.
The sharper point for essays: the bachelor's story is a precise parody that keeps every element of the aunt's genre, exceptional virtue, official reward, dramatic peril, and changes only the causality, so that the reward mechanism itself, the medals, delivers the punishment. Bertha dies of being decorated. That single engineering change converts propaganda into irony, and the fact that Saki's frame story shows the audience preferring it is his real thesis: the appetite for true consequences is native, and the appetite for morals is installed, badly, by aunts.
The craft: a story that demonstrates its argument
The structure is a frame with a controlled experiment inside: same carriage, same audience, two stories, one variable changed. Any essay on The Storyteller can be organised as that comparison, and any writer can steal the deeper trick, which is dramatising your aesthetic argument instead of stating it. Saki never explains why the aunt's story fails; he lets a child's single question do it, then lets the rival story win on stage in front of us. Show the theory losing, show the practice winning.
Study also the bachelor's technique inside his tale: the interrupting questions from the children are absorbed rather than resisted, each answer, the pigs ate the flowers, the Prince kept pigs, adding another absurd, solid plank to the world. Improvised detail delivered with total confidence is what makes an invented world stand. And the ending of Bertha's tale lands on inventory, shoes, rags and three medals, the same procedural coolness Saki uses everywhere: a list, not a lament. The five criteria a contest judge weighs, story, character, emotion, language and theme, are all visible in miniature inside a tale told to stop children fidgeting, which is perhaps the joke Saki would have enjoyed most.
Lines that carry it
Two phrases have entered the language of everyone who teaches this story. Horribly good, the bachelor's description of Bertha, does with two words what whole essays on didactic fiction attempt, fusing virtue and repulsion into a single audible wince. And the children's verdict, that it was the most beautiful story they had ever heard, is Saki resting his case with the only jury he trusts. When a story's own audience appears inside it and votes, quotation becomes unnecessary; the text has already graded itself.
What poets can take from this
- For exams, structure answers as the two-story comparison; the frame is a controlled experiment about fiction.
- Quote horribly good and explain how the oxymoron carries the entire critique of enforced virtue.
- Use the medals as your symbol answer: rewards for goodness become the instrument of destruction.
- Writers: absorb your audience's objections into the tale as the bachelor does; confident detail builds worlds.
- Note the ending's inventory, shoes and medals, as Saki's signature procedural coolness at the point of horror.
- In essays, point out that the children, not the narrator, deliver the verdict on both stories; judgement is dramatised.
Try it yourself
Write a story in which a character forced to entertain a hostile or restless audience improvises a tale, and let the audience's interruptions shape it in real time. The inner tale must parody a genre your teller despises, keeping its parts but reversing its causality, and the frame must end on the audience's verdict.
Questions
What is the message of The Storyteller by Saki?
That children prefer honest stories with real consequences over moralising ones, because didactic tales lie about how the world works. The bachelor's improper story succeeds precisely where the aunt's improving story fails.
Why is Bertha called horribly good?
The oxymoron is the story's critique in two words: her goodness is so extreme, so certified and medal-plated, that it becomes repulsive and finally fatal, since the clinking medals lead the wolf to her hiding place.
What happens at the end of The Storyteller?
The children adore the bachelor's tale, the aunt condemns it as improper, and the bachelor leaves observing that the children will now demand improper stories from her in public for months. The wolf eats Bertha; the argument eats the aunt.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.