Can You Make a Living Writing Short Stories?
Quick answer: Can you make a living writing short stories? Honestly, almost never on sales alone. Here are the real numbers, the exceptions and what short fiction does pay.
Honestly: almost nobody makes a full living from short story sales alone today. Even selling a story every month at professional rates, eight cents a word, twelve 5,000-word stories a year, grosses under 5,000 dollars. The writers who once lived on stories, in the magazine boom of the 1920s to 1950s, worked in an economy that television ended. What short fiction reliably provides now is supplementary income, reputation and a proving ground that feeds better-paying work.
That answer sounds like a door closing, but it is really a map being corrected. Short stories remain one of the highest-leverage things a fiction writer can make; they just pay mostly in currencies other than rent.
The arithmetic, faced squarely
Run the optimist's numbers. Suppose you write brilliantly and sell everything: a story a month, all at pro venues, averaging 450 dollars each. That is 5,400 dollars a year before tax, for a publication rate, twelve pro sales annually, that almost no living writer sustains. Add a good contest win and a few reprints and an exceptional year might reach 10,000. A typical successful year, four to six placements across tiers, sits under 2,000.
Compare the ancestors fairly. In 1925 the big American weeklies paid Fitzgerald what a schoolteacher earned in a year for one story, because magazines were the nation's prime entertainment and circulation ran to millions. Prolific pulp writers lived, sometimes barely, on volume at a cent a word. Those markets shrank as radio, television and eventually the internet claimed the audience. The craft survived; the salary did not.
The exceptions, and what they actually did
A few contemporary writers do earn serious money in short forms, and their methods are instructive. Some genre writers, prolific and fast, stack magazine sales, anthology invitations, reprints, audio rights and translation sales per story, so one piece earns five times. Some serialise fiction directly to readers through subscription newsletters and platforms, where a few thousand paying subscribers outearn any magazine. Some win major prizes; a single well-known international award can pay more than a decade of magazine sales.
Notice the pattern: none of them relies on first-sale magazine income alone. Each built either volume, direct audience or prestige compounding. Alice Munro, the patron saint of the form, is the honest limit case: a Nobel laureate who wrote almost nothing but stories, and whose living came substantially from book collections of those stories, advances, royalties and prizes, not from the magazine cheques where they first appeared.
What stories are actually for, economically
Treat short fiction as leverage rather than wage. Stories are how unknown writers get read by editors, agents and anthologists without needing anyone's permission: the slush pile is the most democratic door in publishing. A handful of strong magazine credits routinely opens agent conversations for a novel. Stories teach structure, compression and endings faster than novels do, one finished arc a month instead of one a year, and contests convert that practice into measurable progress; entrants in Writory's monthly Short Story Contest, for example, get a scored rubric back rather than silence, which is the kind of feedback loop salaried professions take for granted.
Stories also compound. Each published piece can be reprinted, anthologised, translated, collected, taught and optioned. Writers who keep their rights ledgers tidy find their backlist quietly outearning their front list within a decade. Slow money, real money.
A sane plan if you love the form
Keep the day job or the freelance base, and be unembarrassed about it; nearly every short story writer you admire teaches, edits, doctors, or writes other things. Set income expectations per story, not per life: aim for each piece to eventually earn a few hundred dollars across its first sale and afterlife, and let volume accumulate. Route your strongest work to pro markets and serious contests, and put reprints to work the moment exclusivity lapses.
If a living from fiction is the actual goal, let stories be the engine's starter motor: build the credits, then write the novel, the collection, the serial, the things with advances and royalties attached. And protect the part of you that writes stories for love. The form's economics are humble, but its practitioners keep choosing it anyway, for reasons the arithmetic never captures: it is the purest version of the job.
What poets can take from this
- Budget as if story income is a bonus, because for almost everyone it is.
- Make each story earn repeatedly: first sale, reprints, audio, anthologies, eventual collection.
- Use magazine credits as leverage toward agents, collections and longer work.
- Volume matters; a writer with thirty circulating stories has thirty chances a month.
- Keep the day job without shame; nearly every story writer you admire does.
Try it yourself
Write a story about a character whose beloved trade no longer pays, and who does it anyway. Keep it under 2,000 words, let the economics stay in the background, and make the final image show what the trade pays instead of money.
Questions
How many short stories would you need to sell to earn a salary?
At professional rates around eight cents a word, replacing even a modest 30,000-dollar salary would take sixty-plus pro sales a year, far beyond what any market ecosystem supports. That is why volume alone cannot do it and every working model adds books, audience or prizes.
Did writers ever make a living from short stories?
Yes, during the magazine era from roughly the 1920s to the 1950s, when weeklies paid sums worth a teacher's annual salary for a single story and pulps sustained fast writers at a cent a word. Television absorbed that audience and the economy never returned.
Is it easier to make money from novels or short stories?
Novels, by a wide margin, because advances, royalties, translation and screen rights attach to books. Stories earn less but cost less time, and they remain the standard route to the credits and skills that make a first novel sellable.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.