Does a Main Character Need to Be Likable?
Quick answer: Does a main character need to be likable? No, but they must be interesting and understandable. What actually keeps readers turning pages, with examples.
No. A main character does not need to be likable, but they absolutely need to be interesting, understandable, and worth watching. Readers will follow a murderer, a liar or a monster of vanity for four hundred pages, provided the character wants something fiercely, acts on it, and shows them something true about people. What readers will not follow is a bore. Likability is optional equipment; fascination is the engine.
The distinction matters because 'make her more likable' is among the most common notes writers receive, and obeying it naively can sand a sharp character into a pleasant nobody. The better question is never 'how do I make them nicer' but 'why would anyone keep watching this person'.
What readers actually require
Break down the books that carry unlikable leads and you find the same three supports. First, comprehensibility: we may despise the character's choices, but we always understand why they make them. Second, momentum: the character pursues their desire actively, so scenes keep moving. Third, a contract of honesty: the book knows what its lead is and never tries to trick us into admiring them. When any one of the three fails, readers call the character unlikable; when all three hold, readers call the same character unforgettable.
Jane Austen reportedly set herself the challenge with Emma, a heroine she said no one but herself would much like. Emma is a snob and a meddler, and the novel thrives because Austen keeps her energetic, transparent in her self-deceptions, and surrounded by consequences. The reader's pleasure is watching the gap between Emma's self-image and the truth close, painfully, chapter by chapter.
The unlikable canon
Becky Sharp schemes through Vanity Fair with barely a scruple, and Thackeray subtitled the book a novel without a hero on purpose. Scrooge opens A Christmas Carol as a man the narrator calls a covetous old sinner, and we cannot look away. Raskolnikov kills two women; readers have stayed in his fevered head for a century and a half because Dostoevsky makes the inside of guilt more gripping than any chase.
Contemporary fiction leans on the same physics. Highsmith's Tom Ripley, the narrators of Gone Girl, the seething leads of Ottessa Moshfegh's novels: none is company you would choose, all are company readers pay for. What they share is voice and want. An unlikable character with a magnetic voice and a burning goal outperforms a likable one with neither, every time.
How to make an unlikable lead work in your draft
Give the reader one honest handhold in the first scene. It need not be a virtue; competence, wit, or naked honesty about themselves all work. Readers forgive a monster who is funny and self-aware far faster than a saint who is dull. Then keep the character active. Passive unpleasantness is the true killer; active unpleasantness at least generates plot.
Also, calibrate the surrounding cast. If everyone in the story adores your awful lead, readers smell a rigged jury. Let someone name the character's behaviour plainly, and let the character lose things because of it. For contest work this matters double: in a blind read, judges meet your lead without any goodwill toward you, so the handhold must be on the page by the end of the first paragraph or two. Writory's short story rubric scores emotion and creativity, not congeniality, and difficult leads score well when the writing earns them.
Mistakes and misconceptions
The first mistake is confusing unlikable with unmotivated. Rudeness is not a personality; a character who is merely sour, with no want driving the sourness, has nothing to offer a reader. The second is the secret redemption clause, where the author clearly adores the character and keeps excusing them; readers feel the thumb on the scale and revolt. Write the flaws as flaws, and trust the reader to supply whatever mercy is deserved.
The third mistake runs the other way: fixing an interesting, prickly character by committee until she is agreeable and inert. If beta readers say they did not like your lead, always ask the follow-up question: did you want to know what happened to her? Dislike plus curiosity is a healthy reading; dislike plus indifference is the fatal one. Treat the two answers completely differently.
What poets can take from this
- Swap the goal of likable for the goal of watchable.
- Plant one handhold on page one: wit, competence, or brutal self-honesty.
- Keep unlikable leads active; passivity is what readers actually abandon.
- Let the story acknowledge the character's flaws out loud at least once.
- When feedback says 'I did not like her', ask 'but did you keep reading?'
- Never fix an interesting character by making her agreeable; fix her by making her clearer.
Try it yourself
Write the opening 300 words of a story narrated by someone doing something indefensible, such as reading a sibling's diary or sabotaging a colleague. Your only job: make the reader unwilling to stop reading, using voice and motive rather than apology.
Questions
Will agents or judges reject a story because the protagonist is unlikable?
They reject stories where the protagonist is uninteresting, and sometimes say unlikable when they mean that. A vivid, driven, comprehensible lead who happens to be unpleasant is not a barrier; plenty of prize winners feature exactly that.
What is the difference between an unlikable protagonist and an anti-hero?
Overlap is large, but anti-hero usually implies a lead who lacks heroic qualities within a story that still has heroic stakes. An unlikable protagonist can exist in any genre, including quiet literary fiction where no heroism is on offer.
How do I know if my character is unlikable in the good way or the bad way?
Test for curiosity. If readers dislike the character but ask what happens next, you are fine. If they dislike the character and feel nothing at the cliffhanger, the problem is engagement, not niceness.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working poets. Updated July 2026.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the August contest and have your own poem read and scored.