How Do You Title a Short Story?

Quick answer How do you title a short story? Pull a resonant image or phrase from the story itself, keep it short and concrete, and let it mean more after the last line.

Title a short story by pulling something resonant from inside it: a charged image, a spoken phrase, a place, an object that carries the story's weight. Keep it short and concrete, one to five words is the sweet spot, and prefer a title that means one thing on the cover and something more after the last line. Draft ten candidates, say them aloud, and choose the one a reader could remember while recommending the story to a friend.

Titles matter more for short fiction than almost anywhere else. In a magazine's table of contents or a contest longlist, the title is the story's entire advertisement, and it is also the first note of the reading experience itself: a good one starts the story before the first sentence does. Writers who slap on a working title and never return are leaving craft on the table.

What good story titles actually do

Study the titles that stuck and a pattern emerges: they are concrete, and they are double. Shirley Jackson's The Lottery names an ordinary event and lets the story poison the word. Joyce's The Dead sounds like a subject and turns out to be a verdict. Hemingway's Hills Like White Elephants gives you an image that quietly holds the entire unspoken argument of the story. O'Connor's A Good Man Is Hard to Find plants a cliche and detonates it. O. Henry's The Gift of the Magi promises wisdom and delivers irony wrapped around tenderness.

None of these summarise. A title is not a synopsis; it is a lens. The reliable test is the reread test: the best titles mean more the second time the reader sees them, because the story has recharged the words. If your title means exactly the same before and after reading, it is labelling the story rather than working for it.

Six places to find your title

When nothing arrives on its own, hunt systematically. The story almost always contains its own name:

The central object: the thing hands keep returning to. If a pawned watch runs through the story, the title may be wearing it.
A line of dialogue, trimmed: characters often say the title without knowing it, usually near the turn.
The governing image: the frozen canal, the unfinished wall, the dress in the wardrobe.
A place or time that owns the story: names like Araby prove an address can carry dread and longing at once.
The story's key action, made noun: The Swim, The Inheritance, The Apology.
A phrase that turns ironic: a title the ending quietly rewrites, the way Magi's 'gift' doubles back.

A working method for choosing

Wait until the story is drafted; titles chosen first tend to steer stories into their own shadow. Then list ten candidates fast, without judging, drawing from the six sources above. Read each aloud, since titles live in the mouth and ear as much as on the page. Cull anything generic enough to sit on a hundred other stories: Reflections, The Journey, Lost and Found have no fingerprints.

Test the survivors three ways. Say each before an imaginary stranger and ask whether it raises a question worth answering. Check it against the ending for the double meaning. And check it is honest about tone: a comic title on a grief story is a broken promise, and readers punish broken promises. Remember, too, that in blind-judged contests the title does extra work as the one label a judge sees before the first sentence; entrants to Writory's Short Story Contest often find retitling is the last real revision the story gets.

Common titling mistakes

The most frequent is the theme title: naming the abstraction the story is about, Regret, Betrayal, Family, which flattens a living story into a category. Its cousin is the spoiler title, which hands over the twist; if the whole story turns on the brother being alive, do not call it The Living Brother. Vague poetic fog fails in the opposite direction, promising atmosphere and delivering confusion.

Length errors cut both ways: one flat word can be too little, and a fourteen-word title is usually a darling in disguise, though the long title done well, like O'Connor's, earns its space by being a voice rather than a summary. Finally, never keep a working title out of loyalty alone. Working titles are scaffolding, and scaffolding is not the building. Retitle after the final revision, when you finally know what the story turned out to be about.

What writers can take from this

Title after drafting, from material already inside the story.
Prefer concrete nouns and spoken phrases to abstractions and themes.
Apply the reread test: the title should mean more after the final line.
List ten candidates and say them aloud before choosing one.
Avoid titles that could sit on a hundred other stories.
Match the title's tone to the story's; a mismatched title is a broken promise.

Try it yourself

Take a finished story and generate ten titles using a forced menu: two from objects, two from dialogue, two from images, two from places, one action-as-noun, one ironic phrase. Read all ten aloud, pick the winner, and write two sentences defending it against the runner-up.

Questions

Can two stories have the same title?

Yes; titles are not protected by copyright, and literature is full of repeats. Practically, though, a title shared with a famous work invites comparison and search confusion, so check before committing and prefer wording you can own.

Should a short story title be capitalised like a book title?

Use title case in most contexts: capitalise the first and last words and everything except short articles, conjunctions and prepositions. Individual magazines have house styles, so match the venue's guidelines when submitting.

How long should a short story title be?

One to five words serves most stories; long titles work when they carry voice or irony rather than summary. The real limits are memorability and honesty: a stranger should be able to repeat it, and it should not promise a story you did not write.

Keep Exploring

Related writing from the Writory blog

This entry on How Do You Title a Short Story?. This entry is the work of the Writory editorial team for the story collection.

Current story contest: Enter the Writory Short Story Contest. Every story receives a score out of 100 and a certificate; entries close 30 November.

Enter a Writory story contest

Enter the The First Writory Story Contest contest and have a story of your own read and scored. Entries close 30 November.