Birbal and the Brinjal: Akbar and Birbal Story with Moral
Quick answer: Birbal and the Brinjal retold in full: Birbal praises the vegetable one week, condemns it the next, and explains why. The story, its sting about flattery, and classroom notes.
At dinner the emperor declares the brinjal the finest of all vegetables and Birbal outdoes him in praise. A few days later Akbar calls it the worst thing on the table, and Birbal agrees with that too. The tale ends on one sentence, and the sentence is the most honest thing ever said about serving a king.
The story
The dish that evening was brinjal roasted on coals and mashed with onion and mustard oil, and Akbar, who was hungry, ate two helpings. "There is no vegetable like it," he announced. "Look at the colour of the skin. Look how it takes every spice you give it. The brinjal is the king of the garden."
"Your Majesty says too little," said Birbal at once. "It is the only vegetable that wears a crown. Look at the little green cap on its head. Even the plant knows what it is." The courtiers murmured agreement. The emperor was pleased. More brinjal was ordered for the following week.
By the following week, though, the emperor had eaten brinjal five times and the sixth plate came to the table as the cooks were losing their nerve. Akbar pushed it away. "Tasteless," he said. "A sponge with skin on. It has no flavour of its own, it soaks up oil like a rag, and it sits on the stomach all night. Whoever called this the king of the garden was a fool." He looked at Birbal.
"Your Majesty is right," said Birbal without a pause. "It is a fraud of a vegetable. Purple outside and nothing inside, like a courtier. No wonder it wears a crown; it has nothing else." Akbar put down his spoon. "Birbal. Last week you praised it to the sky." "I did, Jahanpanah." "And now you condemn it." "I do." "Well? Which is it?" Birbal bowed. "I am Your Majesty's servant," he said, "not the brinjal's." And the emperor, who had been ready to be angry, found that he was laughing instead, and the brinjal, whose opinion no one asked, was taken away.
The wit, and what it exposes
The moral usually given is a light one: the wise courtier agrees with the king. The tale is far sharper than that. Birbal is not confessing to flattery; he is exposing it. Every man at the table nodded at both verdicts, and only Birbal says aloud what all of them were doing. The joke lands on Akbar too. He has been told, to his face, that his opinions about brinjals are received as commands, and that his court has learned to have no opinions of its own. He laughs because the alternative is to think about it.
Where it comes from, and why it lasts
The real Birbal, Mahesh Das, was known as a poet and companion rather than a jester, and this exchange is a folk tale; the same story is told of Tenali Raman in the south and of other court wits elsewhere.
It lasts because the punchline is only seven words and works on two levels at once, as a servant's excuse and as a satire on everyone who did not say it.
For young readers and classrooms
Seven and up. Excellent for talking about honesty and agreement.
Write your own
The engine is a contradiction admitted so openly that it becomes a critique of the room. Give a powerful character two opposite opinions on something trivial, let everyone agree with both, and give one character a single honest sentence about why. The sentence should be funny to the powerful character and uncomfortable to everyone else.
What writers can take from this
- For exams, explain the double meaning of "I am your servant, not the brinjal's."
- Note that the courtiers are the real target, not Birbal.
- Writers, keep the subject trivial; the smaller the vegetable, the larger the point.
- Let the powerful character laugh; it shows he has half understood.
- Mirror the two praise speeches so the reversal is audible.
Try it yourself
Write a scene in which a leader changes their mind about something small and the whole room changes with them. One character explains, in a single sentence, exactly what just happened.
Questions
What is the moral of Birbal and the Brinjal?
A courtier's loyalty is to the king, not to the subject under discussion; and by saying so openly, Birbal exposes how everyone at court simply echoes the emperor.
What did Birbal say about the brinjal?
When Akbar asked why he had praised the vegetable one week and condemned it the next, Birbal replied that he was the emperor's servant, not the brinjal's.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working writers. Updated September 2026.
Enter a Writory story contest
Enter the Writory Short Story Contest and have your own story read and scored out of 100. Entries close 25 November. That first entry makes you a Writorian.