The Well's Water: Akbar and Birbal Story with Moral
Quick answer: The Well's Water retold in full: a farmer buys a well and is told he did not buy the water in it. Birbal's judgement, the moral about bargains, and classroom questions.
A farmer pays good money for his neighbour's well, comes to draw water the next morning, and is told the sale covered the well alone and the water still belongs to the seller. The case goes to Birbal. It is the most quoted of the Birbal judgements, and the ruling is a single sentence.
The story
The farmer had three fields and no water, and his neighbour had a deep stone well he barely used. They haggled for a month in the shade of a neem tree, and at last the farmer counted out a purse of silver and the neighbour, smiling, accepted it. "The well is yours," he said, and they shook hands before witnesses.
At dawn the farmer came with his bullocks and his leather bucket and found the neighbour sitting on the well's rim. "You may draw water," said the neighbour, "when you have paid for it. You bought the well. Show me the word water anywhere in our bargain." The farmer looked at him. "The well has water in it. What else is a well for?" "Holding my water," said the neighbour, "which I did not sell. You are welcome to the stones."
The farmer went to the local kotwal, who scratched his head, and then to Agra, where petitioners waited in the outer court for days. Birbal, hearing the case, sent for both men and had them stand before Akbar. The neighbour repeated his claim, carefully, with a lawyer's confidence. He had, he said, sold a well and only a well.
Birbal listened with his head on one side. "Quite right," he said, and the neighbour began to smile. "You sold the well and kept the water. Then the water is yours and the well is his. Since your water is sitting in his well, you will pay him rent for the storage, from the day of the sale, at the rate charged for a warehouse in the bazaar. Or you may remove your water by sunset tomorrow, every drop, and take it home." The neighbour's smile went out like a lamp. He asked for a moment to reconsider his position. By evening the farmer's bullocks were drinking, and the emperor, the story says, was still laughing.
The wit, and what it exposes
The moral usually attached is that a cheat's own cleverness can be turned against him. What Birbal really exposes is the difference between the letter of a bargain and its sense. He does not rule that the neighbour is wrong; he rules that the neighbour is exactly right, and follows the neighbour's logic one step further than the neighbour wanted to go. The trick of the judgement is that it never contradicts the trickster.
Where it comes from, and why it lasts
The historical Birbal, Mahesh Das, was a poet and one of Akbar's closest companions; the judgement tales are later folk attributions, and versions of this one are told about other clever judges across India as well.
It lasts because the ruling is reversible in the mind: the reader can hear the neighbour's argument, then hear it turned, and both directions make sense. A good riddle works the same way.
For young readers and classrooms
Seven and up. A gift for talking about fairness and fine print.
Write your own
The engine is a loophole closed by extending it. Give a character a legalistic trick that works, then give another character the patience to agree with it completely and follow it to its absurd conclusion. Never let the judge say "no." The satisfaction is in "yes, and."
What writers can take from this
- For exams, explain both the trick and the counter-trick in plain words.
- Note that Birbal begins by agreeing; the agreement is the weapon.
- Writers, make the cheat clever enough that a lesser judge would be stuck.
- Give the ruling a deadline (sunset tomorrow); concreteness makes it funny.
- End on the winner's ordinary reward, bullocks drinking, not on Birbal.
Try it yourself
Write a story about a dispute in which one party is technically correct and obviously unfair. Let the person who settles it agree with every word the cheat says.
Questions
What is the moral of The Well's Water?
A clever cheat can be undone by his own logic. The neighbour claims he sold only the well, so Birbal rules that he must pay rent for storing his water in another man's well or remove it.
How does Birbal solve the well and water case?
He accepts the neighbour's claim that the water is still his, and then orders him to either pay storage rent to the well's new owner or take all the water out by the next day.
By the Writory editorial team, reviewed by working writers. Updated September 2026.
Enter a Writory story contest
Enter the Writory Short Story Contest and have your own story read and scored out of 100. Entries close 25 November. That first entry makes you a Writorian.