The Composition Teacher Who Underlined One Line
She wrote 'more of this' in red, and I've chased it since.
Mrs. Dunne returned our essays face down, which everyone understood was a mercy.
It was eighth grade composition, third period, the room that smelled like pencil shavings and the radiator's slow cooking of somebody's forgotten orange. The assignment had been two pages on 'A Person Who Shaped You,' and I had done what I always did: I manufactured two pages. Topic sentence, three supporting details, a conclusion that restated the introduction wearing a different hat. I wrote the way you fill out a form at the dentist. I was thirteen and already fluent in saying nothing at length.
Except for one line. It got in by accident, the way true things do, late on a Sunday night when I was too tired to keep guarding the door. I was writing about my grandfather, dead two years by then, and in between the dutiful sentences about how he taught me to fish and always worked hard, I wrote this: 'His radio in the garage still gets the station, but now nobody stands there getting it with him.'
I remember reading it back and feeling embarrassed, the specific hot embarrassment of having been caught by my own paper. I almost crossed it out... the eraser was in my hand. But it was 11:40 on a school night, and rewriting the paragraph felt harder than being briefly honest, so I let it stand and went to bed.
The essay came back with a B... Fine. Expected. B was my natural habitat. But there, in the margin beside that one accidental sentence, was a single red underline, steady as a pulse, and two words in Mrs. Dunne's upright hand: 'More of this.'
Not 'good.' Not a checkmark. Not the smiley face she gave Danielle Kwan for perfect margins. An instruction. A door left open with the porch light on.
I have been walking toward that porch light for thirty years.
You have to understand what school writing was before that moment. It was a compliance exercise. Adults asked for words, you supplied words, they weighed the words and stamped them. No one had ever suggested that the point of a sentence might be that it was true, or that a teacher grading her ninety-fourth essay of the weekend might sit up at her kitchen table because a thirteen-year-old accidentally told her about an empty garage.
I started smuggling one honest line into everything. That was the game I invented, though I would not have called it a game, or admitted to playing it. A book report on 'The Outsiders' with one sentence about how my brother slammed doors the year my parents stopped talking at dinner. A five-paragraph essay on recycling with a line about the neighbor who saved glass bottles for a wife who no longer remembered why. I would bury it mid-paragraph like contraband and wait.
She found it every time.
Every single time, the red underline. Sometimes the two words again.
Once, just: 'There you are.'
Nobody becomes a writer because someone corrects them. You become a writer because someone catches you being one and refuses to let you deny it.
Here is the part I got wrong for decades. I assumed I was one of her projects. Teachers have them, the kids they decide to save, and I figured I had been selected, flattered myself that she had seen a spark. The truth was better and it took a funeral to learn it.
Mrs. Dunne died the winter I turned forty-three. I saw the notice in my hometown paper's website, taught thirty-eight years, survived by a sister in Galway, service at St. Brendan's, and I drove four hours in bad weather without entirely deciding to. The church was full. That surprised no one. What surprised me was the table at the reception, where her sister had set out a box of things from the house, and in the box were folders. Dozens of them. Manila, soft at the corners, each with a student's name.
Mine was there.
Inside were photocopies. She had photocopied our essays before handing them back, or at least the pages that mattered, and on my pages every red underline had a small penciled note beside it in her private shorthand. Beside the radio sentence, in pencil so faint I had to tilt it toward the window... 'First true thing. Keep him.'
Keep him. Not keep at it. Keep him.
She was tracking my grandfather through four years of assignments the way a birder tracks a rare thing that might not come back.
Her sister watched me holding the folder and said, 'She did that for everyone she believed. Not everyone she taught. Everyone she believed.' Then she told me the other thing, the thing I still hand carefully to people when they tell me encouragement is cheap: Mrs. Dunne had written her whole life. Two novels, unpublished. Poems, unpublished. A drawer of rejection slips going back to before I was born. She never stopped submitting and she never once got the letter she wanted, and she spent thirty-eight years making sure other people's first true sentences did not die of loneliness in a margin.
I drove home in the dark thinking about arithmetic. Two words, 'more of this,' maybe half a second of red ink. Against that: every paragraph I have written since, the notebooks, the small publications, the mornings I got up early because a sentence was waiting. There is no economy on earth with a better exchange rate than a teacher's honest margin note, and we keep acting like the currency is a mystery.
It is not a mystery. It is attention.
She read a bored kid's filler essay closely enough to find the one line with a heartbeat, and then she did the bravest thing a reader can do.
She asked for more.
These days I teach a little myself, evening workshops, beginners mostly, people who apologize before they read aloud. I stole her entire method because it was sitting right there. I do not open with what is broken. I find the line, the one line that arrived from somewhere real, and I underline it and say: more of this. Then I point them somewhere they can keep going, a place to actually learn the craft instead of guessing at it alone, because encouragement without a road is just weather.
Last spring one of them, a retired nurse who writes about her night shifts, sent her first poem to a monthly poetry contest. She did not win... She printed the confirmation email anyway and taped it inside a cupboard, and when she told the class, her face was the porch light. Later she wrote her way into the hard material, the patients she still counts at 3 a.m., and I watched a woman in her sixties discover that hope is not the opposite of grief but its stubborn cousin, the one that keeps the radio on.
I never told Mrs. Dunne any of this while she could hear it. That is the tax on being thirteen, and then thirty... and then busy. So I do the only thing that resembles repayment. I keep a red pen in my bag. Not for corrections. I have a separate boring pen for corrections.
The red one has one job, and I hope I do it with half her aim: find the sentence with the heartbeat, underline it once, and write the only writing advice that has ever changed a life.
More of this.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.