The Poetry Contest My Mother Entered Me In
She submitted my private poem without asking, and I won, furious.
My mother has apologized to me exactly three times in my life, and one of them came attached to a trophy.
To understand this story you need to know two things about her. The first is that she reads everything: cereal boxes, warranty cards, the fine print on parking tickets, other people's mail if it sits on the counter long enough. The second is that she believes privacy is a thing you earn by being boring, and that nothing interesting has ever happened behind a closed door that would not be improved by opening it.
I was twenty-six that spring, living in my childhood bedroom again after a layoff I described to relatives as a restructuring and to myself, at two in the morning, as the end of everything. I had a green notebook with a coffee ring on the cover like a pale moon. I kept it in the second drawer of my desk, underneath a folder of tax documents, because if there is one thing my mother respects, it is the boredom of taxes.
I was wrong about that too.
The poem was called Instructions for Loving a Difficult Woman, and it was about her.
I wrote it the night we fought about a lasagna. I had assembled it my way, and she rearranged the layers while I was setting the table, then denied rearranging them, then explained in the same breath why her arrangement was better. There is a very specific feeling that comes from being corrected by someone who insists she has not corrected you, and I carried that feeling upstairs and wrote it down.
All of it. Fifteen years of it.
The poem was not kind. There is a line in it that says she loves like an audit. There is another that says her apologies arrive with receipts stapled to them. I read it back the next morning and felt the particular shame of having told the truth too well, so I put it under the taxes and decided it would die there quietly, the way most honest things in our house did.
Six weeks later my phone rang while I was in line at the pharmacy.
“Hi, is this...” and the woman said my full name, including the middle name that appears only on documents and in my mother's angriest sentences. “I'm calling about the March results. Congratulations. Instructions for Loving a Difficult Woman took first place.”
I remember exactly what I said, because the pharmacist looked up.
“Took first place in what?”
In a monthly poetry contest, it turned out, the kind you enter online. The entry had my name on it. The contact email was my mother's, the one that is her first name followed by the year of her birth, which she gives out freely because she read somewhere that scammers target people who seem secretive.
The drive home from the pharmacy takes eleven minutes... I did it in eight.
She was at the kitchen table doing the crossword, glasses on the end of her nose, radio murmuring. She did not look up. I have thought about that since: she knew exactly why I was standing there breathing like a kettle, and she still filled in fourteen across.
“You went through my desk,” I said.
“I was filing the taxes.”
“The taxes were a decoy.”
“Then you should not have put poetry under them.”
“It was private.”
She put the pen down. “Nothing that good is allowed to stay private.”
“Ma. Did you read it? It says you love like an audit.”
“I know what it says. I typed it twice. The website crashed the first time.”
That stopped me.
I stood there doing the arithmetic of it: my mother at her ten-year-old laptop, hunting down each letter with two fingers, typing every cruel and accurate thing I had ever thought about her, watching the page crash, and then typing all of it again.
Forty minutes, maybe an hour, of her own indictment, entered voluntarily... twice.
“Why would you do that?” I asked, quieter now.
“Because it is true,” she said. “And because you were going to let it rot under the taxes, and I did not raise you to bury your best work under your worst paperwork.”
My mother read the worst thing I had ever written about her, decided it was good, and mailed it to strangers. I am still deciding whether that was a violation or the purest compliment of my life.
The prize was forty dollars and publication on the contest's website. She printed the page at the library, because our printer was out of the blue ink, which she pointed out was somehow also my fault, and she stuck it to the fridge with a Niagara Falls magnet, directly over the takeout menus, at eye level, where guests could not miss it.
At Easter, my aunt Carol read it aloud to the whole table. I sat there with the face of a man passing a kidney stone while my mother watched everyone's expressions, and when Carol reached the audit line, my mother raised her glass and said, “That one is about me,” with more pride than I have ever heard her use about anything, including me.
Here is the part I did not expect.
Winning did not feel like winning.
It felt like being seen through a window I had thought was a wall. For weeks I circled the whole thing... furious in the shower, composing speeches about boundaries that I never delivered.
And then, slowly, another feeling crept in underneath the fury, the way water gets under paint. She had read the meanest thing I was capable of, and her response was not to defend herself. Her response was to fight for the poem.
I started writing about family on purpose after that, instead of only in ambushes at two in the morning. Some of those poems are kind. Most are complicated. One of them, eventually, was about forgiveness, and I want to be clear that I did not leave it lying around by accident. I left it on the kitchen counter, next to the crossword, where she could find it without having to work for it.
She never mentioned it... the next morning it was back on my desk with a comma added. The comma was correct.
Her apology, the third of my lifetime, came in June, in the car, at a red light, delivered to the windshield rather than to me. “I am sorry I went through your desk,” she said. “I am not sorry for the rest of it.” The light turned green. That was the whole apology, and I have received longer ones that meant far less.
Last month I wrote to the contest and asked them to send me the entry exactly as she had submitted it. I think I wanted evidence, some sign that she had softened a line in her own defense, edited herself kinder while my back was turned.
She had not.
Every audit, every stapled receipt, intact, down to the punctuation. The only thing she added was the author bio, forty words I never wrote, in which I am apparently “a writer with a good job history,” which is both untrue and extremely her.
It ends with a sentence I have now read more times than I have read the poem itself.
“He has been writing since he was seven,” it says. “He gets it from his mother.”
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.