She Sat Through Fifty Open Mics Before Reading One Poem
The night she finally stood up, the regulars gave her a standing start.
The sign-up sheet at the Blue Door has twelve slots, and for fifty straight Tuesdays, not one of them said Margaret. I know it was fifty because I counted.
Not out of kindness, I should admit. I started counting around week nine the way you count a dripping tap, and by week twenty the counting had turned into something closer to devotion.
She always took the same chair: third row, aisle side, closest to the exit and the radiator. She ordered one peppermint tea and let it go cold. She clapped for everyone, even the guy who did forty minutes of rhyming couplets about his ex-landlord, and when the host, Devi, lit the stub of a red candle on the stool beside the mic, Margaret leaned forward like the flame owed her money.
That candle is the whole religion of the place. No spotlight, no stage, just a wobbly stool, a microphone with a dent in it, and one small fire in a dark room. Devi lights it before the first reader and blows it out after the last. Whatever you say while it burns belongs to the room and stays there.
Week after week, Margaret watched it burn and said nothing.
We invented stories about her, of course. Poets are shameless that way. Tomas decided she was a retired judge gathering evidence. Priya said she was somebody's mother, come to check on a kid who never showed. I had my own theory, which embarrasses me now: I decided she was afraid. I even rehearsed the little speech I would give her someday about courage, about how the mic is only terrifying for the first eleven seconds.
I never gave it... Thank God I never gave it.
Once, in week thirty-something, I tried. I carried my coffee over and sat down beside her at the break.
"You should read," I said. "Everyone starts somewhere."
She looked at me for a long moment. She had eyes the color of weak tea and a scarf she wore in all seasons.
"I'm not ready," she said. "Nearly... Not yet."
"It gets easier."
"That," she said, "is not my problem." And she smiled like a woman with a locked drawer.
I went back to my seat feeling I had knocked on a door that was never locked to begin with.
The fifty-first Tuesday was ugly outside, the kind of February night when the rain cannot decide what it wants to be. Attendance was thin. Devi read out the list, and at the bottom, slot twelve, she paused, and something moved across her face.
"Closing us out tonight," she said. "Margaret."
The room did not gasp. It did something better. Every regular turned, all at once, the way a field of sunflowers turns, and before she had even stood up, before she touched the mic or cleared her throat... the applause started.
Sal behind the bar shut off the milk steamer. Somebody whistled. Half the room was on its feet for a woman who had not yet said one word. Fifty Tuesdays of silence, and she got a standing start.
She waited at the mic while it died down. She did not unfold a paper. She had no phone, no notebook. My stomach dropped on her behalf, that lonely walk without pages, and then she began, and I understood everything at once, and nothing has sat quite the same in me since.
The poem was about us.
Not "us" as a warm idea. Us, precisely. Line by line. The boy in week four who read a poem to his father's voicemail and hung up before the beep. Tomas's habit of gripping the mic stand like a subway pole in a curve. The night the power failed and Priya finished her poem in the dark, inside the candle's little country, and nobody breathed.
My poem about my grandmother's hands, week nineteen, and she quoted my own line back to the room, softer than I had ever said it, like she had carried it home in her coat pocket and worried it smooth.
Fifty Tuesdays... She had not been gathering courage.
She had been gathering us.
We thought she was too afraid to speak. She had been busy writing every one of us down.
The poem ran maybe three minutes. In it, nobody was mocked and nobody was spared. The rhyming-couplets guy got two lines so gentle and so accurate that he laughed and then covered his mouth. She called the candle a hive door, and the fire the one bee that stays. She ended on an empty chair, third row, aisle side, and what it might mean to leave it for good. Then she said thank you and stepped back, and Devi forgot, for a full ten seconds, to blow the candle out.
Afterward we crowded her like gulls. Where had it come from... who was she... why now. She drank her cold peppermint tea and gave us almost nothing, which felt correct. The one thing she did explain, she explained to Devi, and Devi told me later at the bar.
Margaret's husband had been a talker. Forty-one years of a man who narrated everything: parking, weather, the news, her cooking, his cooking, other people's dogs. When he died, the silence in her house had a physical weight, like snowfall on a roof, and she had gone looking for the loudest, warmest room she could find where nobody would ask her to say anything. A room where the loneliness could sit in a chair like a person and be handed a program.
"I didn't come here to read," she told Devi. "I came to listen until I meant something again. The poem is just what the listening turned into."
I think about that more than I think about most scripture.
I had spent a year being wrong about her in the most self-flattering way possible. I assumed she wanted to be me, up there under the dented mic, and lacked the nerve.
It never occurred to me that she was doing the braver thing. Anyone can talk into a microphone. I do it constantly; ask anyone at the Blue Door; they will sigh. Sitting still inside your own silence for fifty weeks, letting other people's words rebuild you from the studs, and saying nothing until you have one true thing to say: that is the courage nobody claps for, because it looks exactly like an old woman drinking cold tea.
She kept coming, after. She read maybe one Tuesday in six, always short, always by heart. Devi eventually talked her into sending the open mic poem to a monthly poetry contest, and when it placed, Margaret shrugged the way you shrug about weather that suits you. Somebody, and I am not saying it was me, typed it up and posted it on a community wall for poets so the regulars who moved away could still find it. It is there now. The comment underneath that says "I was the voicemail kid" still takes the air out of me.
Margaret died two springs ago, in her sleep, which the talker in me keeps wanting to decorate, and will not.
Devi keeps the third row aisle chair empty on the first Tuesday of every month. The regulars know. Newcomers ask, and we tell them a shorter version of this, and they look at the chair, and then, I have noticed, they look at the whole room differently. They look at it the way she did.
Last month a new woman took the chair by accident, and nobody corrected her, because Margaret would have hated that. The new woman has come back three times since. She sits. She listens... She has not signed the sheet.
I have stopped counting her weeks.
I have started watching what she watches instead: the small fire on the stool, holding the dark room the way a keyhole holds a house.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.