The Diary Someone Left on the Train
I read one page to find the owner and stopped, ashamed and hooked.
The diary was on the seat where the woman with the silver tiffin usually sits, and for one stupid second I looked around the compartment as if someone might claim it, at 7:42 in the morning, on a train where nobody has ever claimed anything, not even their own exhaustion. It was brown, hardbound, the elastic band snapped and retied in a knot. Heavy for its size, the way used notebooks are and new ones never are.
I did the responsible thing... I want that on the record before everything else. I opened it looking for a name, a phone number, one of those THIS BOOK BELONGS TO pages we all filled out as children and abandon as adults, as if we stop belonging anywhere.
There was no name.
There was, on the first page, in small blue handwriting that leaned forward like someone walking into wind, this sentence: "The man who sells combs outside platform two has started nodding at me, and I have decided this counts."
I read the whole page standing between Dadar and Matunga Road. I am not going to pretend a train delay made me do it.
The page was about loneliness the way rain is about water. It never used the word. It counted things instead: the comb seller's nod, the exact number of times the writer's phone had rung that month for reasons other than banks, the neighbour's television heard through the wall and what the writer had learned about the neighbour's taste in serials, which was terrible, and how the bad serials had become something to look forward to anyway, secondhand, through the plaster.
I closed the diary at Matunga Road, ashamed of myself.
I opened it again before Mahim.
The Ledger
Here is my defence, thin as it is: I kept telling myself I was looking for the owner. Every page might have a name, an address, a workplace. Detectives read everything. And so I detected my way through fourteen months of a stranger's private arithmetic, standing in a crowded ladies compartment with my ears going hot, hooked in a way no published book has hooked me in years, because published books are performed and this one was lived.
The writer measured everything. That was the style, if you can call honesty a style. Not feelings, almost never feelings, only quantities: how many words spoken aloud per day, tallied like an expense. Which streetlights on the walk home flickered, and which had died, and a small argument with the municipality conducted entirely within the diary and lost. How long a plant on the window grille had survived, with a burial notice for the plant, four lines, more tender than most things said at human funerals.
Some pages made me laugh out loud into my dupatta. An entry rating the compartment's daily fights like a critic, five stars for one about a stolen window seat that involved three stations' worth of retaliatory elbows. Some pages I had to close for a while. One said only: "Amma called. We spoke for six minutes. I performed a person who is fine for four of them, and for two of them I was not performing, which is progress."
Nowhere, in fourteen months, a name.
The diary's owner had done what the loneliest people always do... She had written everyone else down and left herself out.
I say she. The handwriting could have been anyone's, but the compartment was the ladies coach at 7:42, and some knowledge arrives without needing proof.
We are all a page in some stranger's notebook, and we will never get to read ourselves.
I believed that line completely when I thought of it, somewhere past Bandra. I did not yet know how literally the morning meant it.
Page After Page
It was the entry from the previous monsoon that ended me. The writer described the 7:42 regulars, one by one, with the same measuring tenderness she gave streetlights and plants. The woman with the silver tiffin who guards the window seat like a border. The two college girls who study for different exams from one shared phone. The elderly lady who distributes unsolicited marriage advice with her mints.
And then: "The girl in the green dupatta near the door, who always gives up her seat too easily and then looks angry at herself for three stations. She reads paperbacks with broken spines. She looks like someone who used to write and tells people she stopped."
I was wearing the green dupatta.
I was holding a paperback with a broken spine inside my bag... under her diary.
I had never noticed anyone noticing me. That is the vanity of the lonely, I think, and I can say this because I had been one for two years by then, since the flat emptied out: we believe our invisibility is total. We ride pressed shoulder to shoulder against eighty women and privately insist nobody sees us.
Meanwhile someone with a brown notebook had been keeping me like an account, patiently, monsoon after monsoon, and had read me more accurately than people who have known my full name for a decade.
Used to write. Tells people she stopped.
I got off two stations past my own and stood on the platform doing sums. Whoever she was, she sat where the woman with the tiffin sat, or near it. She had missed the train today, or changed compartments, or left the diary on purpose... though nobody leaves fourteen months of themselves on purpose. She would be back at 7:42. Almost everything about her life was in my bag and the one thing that wasn't was her face.
I did not sleep much that night... I wrote, though. First time in two years. Do not let anyone tell you shame is useless.
Platform Two
She was there the next morning, and I knew her instantly, and the knowing had nothing to do with detection. She was scanning the seat, the floor, the rack, with the face of a person who has lost the only copy of herself. Mid forties maybe. A working bag, sensible shoes, entirely unremarkable, which was the point of her whole notebook: nobody unremarkable exists, we are just under described.
I put the diary in her hands. I had rehearsed a lie about not opening it. It dissolved on contact.
"I read it," I said. "I was looking for your name. There was no name. I am sorry. I kept reading. I am the green dupatta."
The train did its violent shuffle around us. She looked at me for a long moment, and then she laughed, a short shocked sound, like a cough set free, and said, "You gave up your seat again yesterday, I suppose," and that is how I met Prabha, who measures the world.
We have tea on Saturdays now, near platform two, where the comb seller nods at both of us, and it counts. I told her that her fourteen months read better than most published memoirs, and she waved it off, and I pushed, because I had recently learned what pushing is for. There are places that exist for exactly this, for writers nobody has heard yet, and her pages about the buried window plant belong somewhere pages like that go. She is thinking about it. Thinking, with her, is a real activity with a ledger.
As for me, I write about loneliness now, openly, the way she taught me without knowing she was teaching: by counting instead of complaining. I even put a poem where strangers could read it, on a community wall for poets, with my name on it. First page in years that has one.
Because that was her only editorial note, the day I confessed to reading her.
"Next time," Prabha said, tapping the brown cover, "write your own."
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.