He Read the Phone Book at Open Mic and Killed
Names and numbers, perfect deadpan, the crowd demanded an encore.
The sign-up sheet said his piece was called "Residential Listings, K through M," and I assumed it was a metaphor. Poets love a metaphor. We will title a poem "Instructions for Drowning" and it will be about our mothers, so a phone book seemed like a reasonable disguise for something devastating.
It was not a disguise. It was a phone book.
The open mic at The Kettle happens every second Tuesday, in the back room where half the track lighting died in March. Priya, who owns the place, refused to fix it and started putting tea candles on the tables instead. "It's ambience now," she said, and she was right. Everything sounds more important in a dark room with a small flame in front of it. Even, as it turns out, the 1994 residential white pages of Marion County.
I was there because I read there every month. Two years ago a friend dared me to enter a monthly poetry contest, I placed exactly nowhere, and out of pure spite I became a person who performs. That particular Tuesday I read a poem about my breakup that I believed was raw and true. It received the kind of polite applause you give a child's recorder concert. I sat back down with my cold chai and hated everyone gently.
Then Gerald went up.
I knew him only as the older man who always sat by the radiator with a decaf and never, ever read. Gray cardigan, one hearing aid, the upright posture of a retired geometry teacher. He had been coming for over a year without once signing up. That night his name was on the sheet in handwriting like a cardiogram.
He carried an actual phone book to the mic. Not a prop, not a printout. A real one, thick as a brick, the cover gone soft with age, WHITE PAGES 1994 in letters that used to be red and were now the color of weak tea.
He adjusted the mic down two inches. He licked his thumb. He opened to a page he had marked with a rubber band, looked out at us with a face of total seriousness, and began.
"Kaminski, Albert and Ruth. 4417 Dorset Avenue. 555-0132."
Pause.
"Kaminski, D. 4419 Dorset Avenue. 555-0176."
A longer pause... He looked up over his glasses, as if to let the implications of D. Kaminski settle over the room.
Somebody snorted. He did not acknowledge it. "Kane, Bernard, DDS," he continued, and gave the dental credentials a moment of respectful silence.
I want to explain how the laughter built, and I know I will fail... because the whole thing should not have worked. Names. Numbers. Street addresses. But his timing was surgical. He read maybe thirty listings in all. He gave "Kellerman, Fitz" three full seconds of unbroken eye contact with a woman in the front row. He read one phone number twice, the second time softly, like a refrain, and she made a sound like a kettle reaching boil.
Halfway through the L section a man behind me was wheezing into his sleeve. By "Lampert, Cecilia, and family" the room was simply gone. He read the way real comedians and real poets both do the impossible thing: with total commitment and zero apology.
When he closed the book, we stood up. Fourteen people at an open mic gave a standing ovation to the phone book. Someone yelled "Encore," and Gerald, without smiling, opened the book one more time and read a single listing into the dark.
"Meachem, Rosa. 88 Old Quarry Road."
Then he sat down by the radiator and picked up his decaf like nothing had happened.
I could not let it go. Comedy that clean is never an accident, the same way a poem that lands is never a lucky swing. After the mic wrapped, I bought him a fresh decaf and carried it over like tribute and asked him where the bit came from.
"It's not a bit," he said.
The phone book was from Halden, the town where he grew up, three hours north of us. In 1996 the state finished the dam, and the reservoir took the whole valley. Houses bought out one by one. The church deconsecrated. The cemetery "relocated," a word he pronounced with air quotes and a look that could strip paint.
The 1994 white pages were the last ones the county ever printed for Halden. There is no Dorset Avenue anymore... There is water, and under the water, foundations, and under the foundations, whatever a town keeps to itself.
"Albert Kaminski taught me to fish," he said. "Ruth made a lemon cake you would fight a dog for. Bernie Kane pulled my wisdom teeth, and thirty years later he pulled my son's." He tapped the soft cover with two fingers. "Every name in this book answered once. You dialed the number, and somewhere in a bright kitchen a person stopped what they were doing and said hello."
Every name in that book answered once. You called, and somewhere in a bright kitchen, somebody stopped what they were doing and said hello.
I asked the obvious question, the one that had been sitting in my chest all night. Why read it funny? Why let a room full of strangers laugh at the drowned?
He stirred his decaf, which did not need stirring. "Because if I read it sad, you'd have felt sorry for me, and by Thursday you'd have forgotten every word," he said. "You laughed. Now you'll remember Rosa Meachem for the rest of your life."
He was right. I have. I will.
I asked who she was, Rosa of the encore, Rosa of Old Quarry Road. He wound the rubber band back around the book with the care of a man closing a hymnal.
"My mother's best friend. Last one out of the valley... She waited until the water was in her garden."
I went home that night and could not sleep.
I kept thinking about my breakup poem, how carefully I had sanded off everything specific, everything risky, until it was smooth enough to bore fourteen kind people. Later that week I read an essay about why safe poems lose, and I felt personally arrested. Gerald had stood up with a phone book and out-written every one of us, because he brought the actual names. Not "loss." Not "the past." Albert and Ruth at 4417 Dorset. The dentist. The lemon cake.
I posted the whole story on a community wall for poets, half expecting nobody to care, and strangers started replying with their own drowned towns. A woman whose grandmother's village is under a lake in Himachal. A man from Missouri whose family farm is a boat launch now. It turns out half the world is walking around with a phone book nobody prints anymore.
And a month later, I finally wrote about memory instead of writing around it. Real names, real street, the actual song that was playing when things ended, which, for the record, was "Dreams" by The Cranberries, because the universe is not subtle. The poem is not smooth. People remember it.
Gerald still comes to The Kettle. Most months he just drinks his decaf by the radiator, but every so often his cardiogram handwriting shows up on the sheet, and the regulars elbow the newcomers and whisper, wait for this. Last month he did "N through P." A college kid laughed so hard she had to leave the room, and Gerald paused, thumb on the page, until she came back... He would not go on without her. Everyone deserves to hear the names.
When he finished, he closed the book the way you close something holy, and the candle on the front table guttered, and for a second I could see it: a valley three hours north where it is always 1994, where every porch light is on, where the lemon cake is cooling on the sill, and all the phones are ringing, and everyone, everyone is home to answer.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.