The Metaphor That Confused My Whole Office
I said the project was 'a ship of theseus'; HR scheduled a meeting.
The calendar invite said “Quick sync re: Tuesday's comment,” and it arrived with no agenda, no context, and a smiley face from someone in Human Resources named Priya. I have written poems about death that scared me less.
To understand Tuesday's comment, you need to understand Project Falcon. Falcon is a piece of software my company has been building for six years, and in that time it has replaced its database, its design, its entire original engineering team, its target customer, and its name. It used to be called Eagle. Before that, briefly and for reasons nobody can reconstruct, it was called Sandwich.
I am a project coordinator, which means I schedule meetings about meetings and maintain a spreadsheet that three people fear and nobody reads. I am also, privately, a writer. Every office has a few of us, writers in corporate jobs, hiding in plain sight behind status reports. I keep my poems in my phone under a folder labeled TAX DOCUMENTS 2019, because that is the one folder on earth no curious human will ever open.
On Tuesday, in the third hour of a planning session, a developer named Marcus asked the question that broke me. “Are we even building the same product anymore?” He asked it the way you ask a ceiling at 3 a.m. And I felt something ancient and literary rise in my chest.
“Honestly,” I said, “at this point, Falcon is a ship of Theseus.”
Silence. Not thoughtful silence... Buffering silence.
The silence of fourteen people deciding whether you have just had a small stroke.
Craig from procurement unmuted first. “Sorry, who's Theseus? Is he with the new vendor?”
“No, it's a thought experiment,” I said. “From Plutarch. If you replace every plank of a ship, one plank at a time, is it still the same ship?” I could hear myself getting louder, the way you do when you realize the bridge you are standing on is built entirely out of your own confidence.
Somebody typed. Somebody coughed. Deb, my manager, said, “Are you telling us the ship is sinking?” and wrote something down, and a product manager asked if Plutarch was a plugin, and the meeting moved on without me while I sat there radiating the specific heat of a person who has just been visibly strange at work.
I thought that was the end of it...
It was not the end of it.
By Wednesday afternoon the story had mutated the way office stories do, passed from Slack channel to Slack channel like a virus in a business casual outfit. One version said I had called the project fake. Another said I had compared leadership to old planks. A woman in marketing asked me, with real and touching concern, whether Theseus was the consultant who had been let go in the spring.
By Thursday, Deb messaged me “don't worry about it :)” which is how I knew, with total certainty, to worry about it.
Friday. Priya's office had one small brave plant and two chairs angled at the exact degree that HR manuals must recommend for difficult news. She offered me water. I declined, then immediately wished I had accepted, because my hands needed a prop.
“So,” she said. “Tuesday.”
Here is what had actually happened, and it was worse than any of the rumors. Craig had filed a soft complaint. Not because Greek philosophy offended him, but because, in his words, the comment felt designed to make everyone else in the room feel small.
And when Priya read that sentence out loud, I could not argue with it. Because a part of me, a petty, starving, unpublished part of me, had wanted exactly that. I had wanted, for once, in that beige building, to be the person who knew something beautiful. I had six years of poems hidden inside a fake tax folder, and I had smuggled one sentence of that entire secret life into a status meeting, and I had done it not to give anyone anything.
I had done it to be seen.
I said some version of this to Priya. Not smoothly... Somewhere in the middle my voice did an embarrassing thing, and she slid the water across the desk anyway, like she had been keeping it warm for this moment.
She was quiet for a second... Then she closed her notebook and said, “Off the record? What's the answer?”
“The answer to what?”
“The ship,” she said. “If they replace everything. Is it the same ship or not?”
So I told her what I actually believe, sitting in an HR office on a Friday afternoon, which has to be the least mythological setting Plutarch's ship has ever sailed into.
You can replace every plank in a thing and it will still be the same ship, as long as somebody on board remembers where it was going.
Priya looked at me for a long moment. Then she said, “I have a notebook at home with about thirty unfinished poems in it,” in the tone of a woman confessing to a hit and run. It turns out the person whose job is scheduling meetings about feelings spends her Sundays failing to finish a poem about her grandmother's hands. We talked twenty minutes past the meeting slot. I believe I am the only employee in company history to leave an HR intervention happier than they arrived.
I took Craig to lunch on Monday. I apologized for the tone, not the metaphor, and he accepted both, and then he asked me to explain the whole thing properly, slowly, which I did on a napkin with a drawing of a boat so bad it looked like a hat. He studied it for a while... “So it's like my dad's hammer,” he said. “Two new heads, three new handles. He still calls it his father's hammer.” Craig from procurement, ladies and gentlemen, casually out-philosophizing Plutarch over a chicken wrap.
That night I went home and wrote the whole week as a poem: the meeting, the buffering silence, the hammer. And for once I did not file it under fake taxes. I entered it into a monthly poetry contest instead, on the theory that humiliation had already done its worst by Wednesday. Then I read an essay on why safe poems lose and felt personally attacked in a useful way, because every poem I had hidden for six years was safe, and the hiding itself was the safest move of all.
A few weeks later I posted the hammer poem on a community wall for poets, where strangers said kind, specific things about it, which is more than my spreadsheet has received in its entire life. Priya found it there. She sent me exactly one line: “Finished a poem last night. First one ever. Blaming you.”
The real ending came three months later, in a budget meeting. The numbers had been reworked so many times that the original plan was unrecognizable, and there was a long, heavy pause, and then Craig leaned back in his chair and said, “Well. This spreadsheet is a ship of Theseus,” with the serene confidence of a man who had been waiting weeks to deploy it. He used it slightly wrong. Nobody questioned him. Deb wrote it down.
And I sat there feeling the thing I took this job and hid those poems trying to feel. Not smart. Not even seen, exactly.
Just on board. Same ship. Still going.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.