The Therapist Who Made Me Write Letters I'd Never Send
Forty pages to people who will never read them, and it worked.
The first letter took me three weeks, and it opened with “Dear Dad, the Yankees are terrible this year,” because apparently, even in a letter no one on earth would ever read, I could not manage one true sentence. My therapist thought this was extremely interesting. Therapists always think the worst things about you are extremely interesting.
Her name is Marianne. Her office has a lamp the color of honey and a clock positioned so that only she can see it, which I have decided is the entire profession in one piece of furniture. Four months into our Tuesdays, after I had circled the same story enough times to wear a groove in it, she put down her pen and gave me the assignment.
“Write him a letter,” she said. “You won't send it.”
I laughed. I actually laughed. “Postal therapy,” I said. “Do I get a stamp for my feelings?”
“You have arguments with him in the shower,” she said, not unkindly. “You told me so. I'm suggesting you have one on paper. Paper is better than the shower. On paper, you get to finish.”
Some background, quickly, because the details are ordinary and the wound is not. My father and I had not spoken in nine years. The fight was technically about a car, a 1998 pickup he promised me and then sold, but the car was just the door the fight walked through. It was really about the drinking, and the Thanksgiving he showed up two hours late and one bottle deep, and the thing he called me in the driveway while my mother stood on the porch with her hand over her mouth like she was holding her own voice in.
Nine years... I told people we had drifted. Drifted, like it was weather. Like nobody had steered.
So: the letter. Three weeks, four drafts, and every draft was small talk with a ghost. Baseball. The weather. A paragraph about my job so boring it could have been read at his retirement party. I brought the fourth draft to Marianne like a cat presenting a dead bird, and she did something I did not expect. She refused to read it.
“They're not for me either,” she said. “That's the point. No audience. Not him, not me, not the version of you that performs being fine. Write the one you'd write if no one, living or dead, could ever hold it against you.”
The real first letter arrived at 2 a.m. on a Sunday, the way real things do.
I filled six pages in forty minutes. My handwriting deteriorated from cursive to carving; on page four I pressed so hard the pen went through the paper, and I want to tell you I stopped and composed myself, but I did not, I kept writing straight through the tear. Everything went in. The driveway. The word. The sound of gravel under his tires when he left, which I realized, writing it, I had been hearing for nine years the way you hear a ringing after a concert.
I did not feel better afterward... This is not that kind of story yet. I felt like I had moved a piano alone: something enormous was in a different place now, and everything hurt.
But the shower arguments stopped. That was the first thing I noticed. For nine years I had been drafting comebacks into the steam every single morning, and suddenly the courtroom in my head was adjourned, because the testimony existed somewhere outside my skull. Marianne nodded when I told her, like a mechanic hearing an engine finally turn over.
So I kept going. A letter to my mother, who did her best inside a marriage that behaved like a weather system. A letter to my grandmother, who died holding recipes I never asked for. A letter to a friend I lost to an argument so stupid neither of us could survive the embarrassment of apologizing. A letter to myself at fifteen, which was the only one that made me cry from the first line, because the first line was “It isn't your fault,” and my hand knew it before I did.
Forty pages by spring, kept in a shoebox that used to hold winter boots. Somewhere in those pages I finally wrote about the grief directly, instead of orbiting it, and I learned the shoebox rule of my own heart: everything I refused to say was running my life, and everything I wrote down resigned from the job.
Then, one Tuesday in March, my aunt called, and the letters stopped being practice.
A stroke. He was alive, she said, but the left side... and the speech. The speech was gone, maybe for months... maybe for good. I stood in my kitchen holding the phone and understood the joke the universe had built for me personally: nine years of silence between us, and now silence was mandatory.
The hospital corridor smelled like antiseptic and canned peaches. He was smaller than the man in the driveway, smaller than the man in the letters, white stubble, a blanket the color of oatmeal, one hand curled on his chest like a bird that had flown into a window. His eyes found me and went very wide, and then very wet, and he could not say one word... and neither, it turned out, could I.
So the second Tuesday, I brought the shoebox.
I did not read him the six angry pages. Those were mine, and Marianne was right, they had already done their work in a locked room. I read him the last letter instead, the fortieth one, one page, written after midnight the night before. It had the sawdust in it, the smell of his workshop when I was seven. It had him teaching me to sand with the grain, be patient, let the wood tell you. It had one sentence I had to stop after: “I kept the level you gave me. It still tells the truth.”
His good hand found my wrist and stayed there, and I sat in a vinyl chair reading out loud to a man who could not answer, and understood that I had spent a year in training for exactly this. Letters to someone who can't reply.
It turned out to be rehearsal.
Forgiveness turned out to be a letter I addressed to him and wrote, the whole time, to myself.
He got some words back by summer. Not all of them. We talk on Sundays now, short calls, both of us careful, like two people carrying a pane of glass across a room. I will not pretend it is a movie ending. He has never mentioned the driveway, and I have stopped needing him to, which Marianne says is not giving up, it is forgiveness wearing work clothes. It does not swing open like a door in a film. It is just a door, the bolt quietly drawn back, that both of you know about.
People ask if the letters fixed things, and the honest answer is that they fixed me enough to show up, which is the only part healing was ever going to be responsible for. The shoebox stays on the closet shelf. Thirty-nine letters that will never be read, one that was read aloud in a hospital room, all of them sent, in the only way that matters, to the person who wrote them.
I still write one a month. Marianne no longer assigns it; some prescriptions you just keep refilling yourself. The newest one is upstairs, started last night, and it opens “Dear Dad, the Yankees are terrible this year.”
Only now it's not an evasion.
Now it's just Tuesday, and true, and something I get to tell him on Sunday.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.