The 4 A.M. Pages That Kept Me Sober
When the craving knocked, I answered with a pen instead.
Cravings keep terrible hours.
Mine always clocked in at four in the morning, punctual as a paper route. Not at parties, where I was braced for them. Not at weddings, with an open bar humming twenty feet away. Four a.m., alone, in a rented duplex with a humming refrigerator... that was when the knock came.
And in those first months of sobriety I would lie there listening to it, doing the math on which gas stations were open.
My sponsor's name was Ray. Sixty something, retired pipefitter, drank his coffee like it owed him money. Ray said what all sponsors say: "Call me. Any hour. I mean it." And I believe he meant it.
But I am the son of a woman who apologized to furniture when she bumped it, and I could not make myself wake a sixty seven year old man because my own head was being loud. That is its own defect, Ray would say. He is probably right. But it is the defect I had, so I needed a tool that worked at four in the morning without waking anybody.
The tool turned out to cost eighty nine cents. A blue spiral notebook from the dollar store, seventy sheets, wide ruled. I bought five of them and a bag of stick pens, and I made myself one rule, and the rule saved my life, so I will give it to you exactly as I wrote it on the inside cover:
"You can drink after you fill three pages. Longhand. No skipping lines."
That is it. That is the whole system. I never said I would not drink. Telling a craving "never" is like telling a toddler "never," it just changes the pitch of the screaming. I said: fine, maybe... but first, three pages. The craving, which is a gifted negotiator but fundamentally lazy, always took the deal.
So the ritual assembled itself. Knock comes at four. I get up, I do not turn on the big light, because the big light makes it a crisis. I light the candle on the kitchen table, a fat vanilla one left behind by the previous tenant, and the room shrinks to a small warm circle: table, notebook, pen, one man in a T-shirt he should have retired years ago. And I write.
What did I write? Anything. That was rule two, there are no other rules. Grocery lists. Complaints about the refrigerator's hum, which is in B flat, I checked. Letters I would never send. Arguments I lost in 2009, rewritten so I won them. Prayers from a man who is not sure anyone is picking up. Descriptions of the candle flame, four in the morning is a slow news hour. Some nights the first page was just "I want a drink I want a drink I want a drink" until the words went strange and lost their teeth, the way any word does if you say it forty times.
And here is the thing I did not understand at the beginning but banked on anyway: not once, in four years, have I reached the bottom of the third page still wanting it the way I wanted it at the top of the first.
Not once.
The pages are not magic. They are minutes. A craving is a wave, and everybody tells you that, surf the urge, it crests and passes, but nobody tells you what to hold on to while it crests. Three pages longhand takes me about forty minutes. The wave takes about twenty five. The notebook is just a rope with lines on it.
The pen never kept me sober. It kept me company until morning, and morning kept me sober.
Somewhere around notebook four, the pages stopped being only a tourniquet and started being, embarrassingly, writing. Ray was the one who nudged that along. When I finally admitted my system to him, expecting to be told it was avoidance, he grunted and gave me an assignment instead, one of those prompts that looks harmless and is not: "Write the letter you'd never send. You know who to." I assumed he meant my ex-wife.
I sat down at the table that night, candle lit... and found out he meant whiskey.
So I wrote whiskey a breakup letter. I am aware of how that sounds. I wrote it anyway, dear you, it's not me, it's you, and about a page in it stopped being a joke. Because you cannot write a breakup letter without accounting for the good years, that is what makes it a breakup letter and not a police report.
I wrote about being nineteen on Kowalski's porch, the first time the noise in my head went quiet, and how I spent twenty years trying to get that one porch back. I wrote: you were the only thing that ever made the noise stop, and then you became the noise. When I finished it was five forty in the morning, the candle had guttered, and the letter had line breaks in it.
It had become, without my permission, a poem.
I want to be honest about the night the system failed, because a ritual you only praise is a ritual you are lying about. Two years in, my father died. Complicated man, complicated grief, and after the funeral I found myself in a motel outside Dayton with a bottle I had bought without any memory of buying it. I got out the notebook. I wrote one page. Halfway down the second, the pen died, and I sat there in that beige room... genuinely deciding, and I want to tell you I chose well because of character, but what actually happened is that I dumped my bag looking for a pen and found a green crayon my daughter had left in the side pocket some previous visit. And I finished the second page, and the third, in green crayon, in letters that got bigger and shakier until the last half page was just two words over and over.
Still here. Still here. Still here.
I poured the bottle into the motel sink at six ten a.m. and called Ray from the parking lot. Woke him right up. Turns out I could do it after all, my defect had an exemption built in for emergencies, and Ray listened to the whole thing and then said the sentence I have repeated to every sponsee since: "Good. Grief you write down is grief that has an address. The other kind just wanders around your house all night." I did not fully understand him until months later, when I finally started writing about my father directly, at the table, at four, page after page of grief with somewhere to live.
Last spring, four years sober, I did something Ray had been needling me about. I typed up the whiskey letter, the poem it turned into, and entered it into a monthly poetry contest. Fifty three years old, first thing I ever submitted anywhere. It took an honorable mention, which Ray celebrated like a pennant win, and a stranger wrote to me afterward to say she had read it at her kitchen table at, and I am quoting her, "my own version of 4 a.m." That message is taped inside notebook eleven. So is the green crayon, notebook nine, wrapped in a bit of masking tape like a relic, which I suppose it is.
The notebooks live in a row on the shelf now, eleven blue spines, my whole second life in wide rule. The knock still comes sometimes. Rarely now, and quieter... more of a tap, an old landlord checking if I still live here. I do not lie awake doing gas station math anymore. I get up, light the candle, and answer the door the same way every time.
Pen in hand. Three pages. Still here.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.