I Wrote Sermons for a Preacher Who Lost His Voice
His faith, my grammar, together we kept the pulpit alive.
Pastor Eli Grange once preached a funeral so tender that the dead man's atheist brother stood up and hugged him in the middle of it, and by the time I met him he could not order a cup of coffee out loud.
Throat cancer.
Two surgeries, thirty rounds of radiation, and what the doctors called a good outcome, which meant he lived, and a bad one, which meant the voice that had filled First Baptist of Harlow Creek for twenty six years now topped out at a whisper he could hold for about eight minutes a day. After eight minutes it shredded into a hiss, like a radio losing its station on a night drive.
I was the town's only freelance editor. I fixed grant applications for the volunteer fire department and wedding toasts for terrified best men. One Tuesday in October his wife Ruthann knocked on my porch door holding a casserole dish in one hand and a manila folder in the other. The casserole was a bribe. The folder was a sermon.
“He writes them long,” she said. “He always wrote long, because he trimmed as he preached. He could feel the room. Now he can't feel anything until Sunday, and Sunday costs him.”
The draft inside was nine pages. Eight minutes of whisper is maybe nine hundred words. The math was brutal, and the math was now mine.
Here is the part I should confess up front: I had not believed in God since I was nineteen, when my mother died on a Wednesday and the church casseroles stopped arriving by the following Friday. I took the job because it was October, because freelance editing in a town of four thousand people is mostly waiting, and because I wanted to see if I could do it. Cutting a stranger's faith down to nine hundred words sounded like a technical problem.
I like technical problems... they don't ask anything of you.
That first week I cut his favorite story, three full pages about his father's tractor stalling in a flooded field in 1974. I typed a note in the margin: This is beautiful and it is not the sermon. I braced for a fight. What came back, hand delivered by Ruthann, was a legal pad page with two words in block capitals: CORRECT. PROCEED.
I went that Sunday, out of guilt or curiosity, and sat in the last pew like a health inspector. The church smelled like radiator dust and lemon polish. Eli stood at the pulpit with a small microphone almost touching his lips, and when he began, the whole congregation did something I have never seen an audience do for a loud man. They leaned.
Two hundred people tilted forward at once... like a field of wheat when the wind changes.
A whisper, it turns out, is a kind of gravity.
We worked by legal pad after that. He wrote his drafts in a looping hand that got angrier as it got holier, and his editorial notes came in block capitals like telegrams. MORE MUSTARD meant the verbs were weak. TOO MANY STAIRS meant I had made him climb through three clauses to reach the point. Once, when I cut a long passage where he admitted he had spent the whole spring doubting whether prayer did anything at all, the pad came back with the capitals pressed so hard they embossed the next three pages.
PUT MY DOUBT BACK. THE DOUBT IS THE SERMON.
I put the doubt back.
Attendance went up.
By the second winter I knew his mind the way you know a house you clean: which drawers stick, where the light switches hide, what he kept in the room he thought nobody entered. I knew he would spend three paragraphs being kind before he said the difficult thing, and that my whole job was to move the difficult thing to the front while leaving enough kindness for it to land. Nine hundred words. Fifty two Sundays a year. It was the strangest and steadiest work I have ever done.
In February I finally told him. I don't know why that day, except that we were sitting in his study going over an Easter draft, and the afternoon was going dark early, and Ruthann had lit a candle on the desk because the overhead bulb had died and neither of us had mentioned it for an hour. I said, “Eli, you should know who's holding the scalpel. I don't believe any of it... I haven't for twenty years.”
He didn't reach for the pad right away. He looked at me for a long moment, then wrote in small letters, not capitals, which from him was practically a whisper inside a whisper.
I KNOW. KNEW BEFORE I HIRED YOU.
I asked him why on earth, then. He wrote for a while, tore off the page, and slid it across the desk like a verdict.
A BELIEVER WOULD HAVE KEPT MY BAD SENTENCES OUT OF REVERENCE. YOU ANSWER ONLY TO THE SENTENCE. THAT IS ITS OWN KIND OF FAITH.
I kept that page. It is in the drawer where I keep my mother's recipe cards, which is the closest thing I have to a reliquary.
Faith is not volume. Faith is what you keep saying after the volume is gone.
He wrote that line himself, for a sermon the third November, and I remember holding my pen over it for a full minute looking for something to fix. There was nothing to fix. Some weeks the work is knowing when you are not needed.
The strange side effect nobody warned me about: spending two years inside another person's belief loosened something in my own locked room. On nights I couldn't sleep I started writing small things of my own, poems about healing that I never showed him, and then, eventually, poems about the grief I had been editing around since I was nineteen. Much later I read an essay about why safe poems lose, and I laughed out loud in my kitchen, because Eli had been teaching me that on legal pads the whole time. The doubt is the sermon. The wound is the poem. Put it back.
The cancer returned in his fourth autumn, and this time the doctors did not use the word outcome. His last sermon was the Christmas Eve candlelight service. The draft arrived at my house three weeks early, which he had never once done, and it was three hundred words, which meant he had already cut it himself. I read it at my kitchen table and could not find a single stair to remove. It ended with a line addressed, I am fairly sure, to exactly one person in the last pew.
You have been my voice. Now go be somebody's.
That night the church was lit entirely by candles, small ones passed hand to hand down the rows, and when he leaned into the microphone the flames all over the room were trembling from the drafts and the breathing. Three hundred words takes a healthy man two minutes. It took Eli almost nine... and nobody in that building exhaled carelessly the entire time.
He died in March, with Ruthann on one side of the bed and a legal pad on the other. She told me the last thing he wrote was a grocery list, which I believe, and which I think he would want included, because he hated when funerals sanded a man smooth.
I still don't know what I believe... but some nights I turn off the overhead light on purpose, light the stub of a candle at my desk, and read old drafts in that small moving glow. Nine hundred words, over and over, in a voice that was half his and half mine and entirely quiet. And I lean in. That much, at least, I learned to do. The flame steadies. The room listens. Somewhere a sentence still needs me, and I answer it.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.