The Uncle Nobody Talks About
His photo faces the wall, and his story faces silence.
In my grandmother's house, one photograph faces the wall.
It hangs in the corridor between the kitchen and the prayer room, in a black frame like all the others. The others show faces: my grandfather with his pocket watch, a great-aunt who died of typhoid at nineteen, wedding portraits the colour of weak tea. This one shows brown paper backing and a rusted wire. As a child I decided it was a mirror that had grown shy.
I was eight when I finally asked. My grandmother was rolling cotton wicks for the evening lamp, and her fingers stopped... only the fingers, the rest of her stayed perfectly still. "Some pictures are resting," she said. Then she sent me to fetch the matchbox, and I understood, the way children understand things through their skin, that I had touched a live wire.
His name was Prakash. I learned that at a cousin's wedding, whispered to me behind a plate of laddoos the way you would pass contraband. He was my grandmother's second son, born between my father and my aunt Meena. He left the house in 1989, and after that nobody said his name.
Not at Diwali. Not at funerals. Not even in anger, which is the loudest silence there is.
The story reached me in pieces over twenty years, and every piece contradicted the last. One cousin said he stole grandfather's gold and lost it on horses. Another said he drank. A third swore he had raised his hand against his own father, and she lowered her voice while saying it, as if the corridor could hear.
The truth, when I finally got it from Meena aunty on the night of her retirement party, was smaller and worse. He fell in love with a woman named Salma who worked at the telephone exchange. He asked permission to marry her. My grandfather said that if he did, the family would perform his rites as though he had died. Prakash asked twice more, properly, with folded hands. Then he packed one suitcase, married her at a registrar's office with two witnesses borrowed from the queue, and my grandfather turned the photograph around that same evening, himself, and told the house that his second son was gone.
We never erased him. We turned him to face the wall, and then we walked past the back of his head every day and called it peace.
I want to be honest about my part in this. For most of my life I did not think about him at all. You can live comfortably alongside a mystery if it hangs quietly enough. He was not a person to me. He was a hook, a frame, brown paper... a square of corridor nobody dusted.
Then my grandmother died.
She went in February, in her sleep, ninety-one years old, her spectacles folded on the windowsill like she was only stepping out. And because I was the grandchild with no job to rush back to that month, it fell to me to empty her steel trunk. Six saris. A tin of safety pins. Ration cards from three decades. The smell of camphor and old talcum, which I now believe is what the past actually smells like.
At the bottom, under her wedding sari, I found a bundle of envelopes tied with red string. Thirty-one of them. One for every year since 1989. All in the same slanting hand. All addressed to her.
All opened.
I read them on the floor of her room with my back against the trunk.
They were not dramatic letters... That is what undid me. He wrote about mango prices in Pune. About his daughter Ayesha standing second in her class, then first, then getting a job in a bank. He asked, in almost every letter, whether her knee still troubled her in the rains. He never once asked to come back. He signed every letter the same way: Your son.
The last one, dated 2019, gave a new address and a single line I have not been able to put down since: "The door here does not lock from the inside, in case you ever come."
Under the letters lay half a reply in my grandmother's careful schoolgirl Hindi. "Beta, the mangoes here are not what they were," it began, and stopped mid-sentence, and was never sent, and was never thrown away either.
She had read every letter for thirty-one years, retied the string, and said nothing.
She kept her son at exactly reading distance. I sat there a long time doing arithmetic I did not want to do: she was fifty-nine when he left, ninety-one when she died, and she spent every one of those years pretending, at dinner, that she had one son fewer than she did.
I did what people like me do with unbearable things. I wrote. Badly at first, all noble suffering and rain, and then one night honestly, about the whole knotted grammar of family, about how a name can become a banned substance in a house. I posted it on a community wall for poets, mostly to stop myself from deleting it. A stranger left four words underneath: "Go. While there's a door."
So I went to Pune. I did not tell my father. I took the photograph off its hook, wrapped it in newspaper, and put it in my backpack, and the empty square it left behind was two shades brighter than the wall around it, the exact shape of what we had refused to look at.
The address was a third-floor flat above a tailoring shop. Marigolds grew on the windowsill in a cut plastic bottle. The man who opened the door was seventy-two years old and had my father's face, but kinder around the mouth, the way a rough draft is sometimes kinder than the final version.
"I am Ramesh's son," I said.
He held the doorframe with both hands. Behind him a woman's voice asked who it was, and he tried to answer twice before any sound came out.
We did not talk about anything large. That surprised me. We talked about cricket, about Ayesha's daughters, about his knees, which troubled him in the rains, and neither of us pointed at the inheritance sitting inside that sentence. Salma aunty made tea and put four biscuits on a plate, and then, when she thought I wasn't looking, added a fifth.
Then I unwrapped the photograph.
He looked at his own young face for the first time in thirty-one years, a boy of twenty-six with oiled hair and a terrified smile, and he asked me only one thing. Not who had sent me. Not whether anyone was sorry.
"Did she read them?"
"All of them," I said. "Every year. The string was retied thirty-one times."
He nodded and looked out of the window for a long while. The tailoring shop rattled on below us. When he spoke again his voice was matter-of-fact, which is how the deepest things get said in my family.
"I was angry for ten years," he said. "After that, I just kept writing so the address would stay warm."
Before I left, he stood the photograph on his bookshelf, facing the room, angled toward the door. The first thing anyone would see walking in. Salma aunty wiped the glass with the end of her dupatta the way you wipe a child's face.
Back home, I did not hang anything on the empty hook. I am still learning what to do with the rest of it, with a grandfather I loved who did this, with the discovery that forgiveness in my family was never absent, only folded under a wedding sari where nobody would have to witness it. An estranged family member, I have learned, is rarely estranged from everyone. Someone is always reading the letters.
But here is the ending I did not expect. A month after Pune, I told my father everything and handed him the 2019 letter. He read it standing up, twice... and said nothing at all. The next morning, without meeting my eyes, he asked whether I still had the address.
He took the train on a Tuesday.
He carried mangoes.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.