I Married My Best Friend's Ex
Love arrived wearing the one face I was forbidden to want.
There is a photograph from my wedding where my husband is laughing at something his brother said, and I am looking past the camera at a door. I know exactly what I was doing in that moment. I was watching for a woman who had told me, four words, no punctuation, that she might come.
Her name is Priya. She has been my best friend since we were nine years old and she bit a boy who stole my geometry box. For twenty years we shared everything: clothes, exam notes, chickenpox, a hostel room with one working fan, the specific griefs of our specific mothers. And for three of those years, in college, she shared her life with a boy named Aman.
The boy I married.
I want to tell this correctly, because the internet version of this story has villains in it, and the lived version mostly has people.
Priya and Aman broke up the year we turned twenty-two. It was not dramatic. He wanted Bangalore and ambition; she wanted Delhi and her mother's kitchen and a PhD. They ended it in a parking lot, hugged, and did not speak again, the way you don't speak to a city you moved away from. Priya cried for one weekend, ate an entire box of soan papdi, and moved on with a thoroughness I have envied all my life. When she talked about him afterward, which was rarely, it was with the mild fondness you'd have for an old textbook.
I did not think about Aman for seven years. I want that on the record too.
Then, at twenty-nine, I stood behind a tall man in the condolence line at Professor Kulkarni's funeral, and the man turned around, and it was him. Grief makes strange introductions. We drank bad canteen chai afterward and talked about the professor, who had once failed us both with great affection, and at some point I laughed for real, at a funeral, and felt the exact click of a key finding its lock. I remember walking to the auto stand thinking, in these words... no. Absolutely not. Anyone but this one.
The heart does not check the guest list before it chooses a face.
The Year of the Locked Drawer
We told ourselves it was coffee... Then it was coffee twice a month.
Then he drove me to the airport at five in the morning when my father had his bypass, and sat with me in the cardiac waiting room that smelled of phenyl and fear, and by the time my father was stable I was holding Aman's hand like it was a railing on a ship.
And I hid it.
That is the part I would do differently, the only part. Not the love. The locking.
For eleven months I ran a small secret government. I saved his number under a colleague's name. In my own diary, my private diary that no one on earth would read, I wrote him as A, as if even the page might call Priya.
When she and I met, and we met constantly, because nothing had changed for her, I would sit across from my best friend of two decades and feel the secret sitting between us like a third chair. She'd say, you seem happy lately, what is it, and I would say work... and she would look at me a half second too long.
I told myself I was protecting her. Protection is the flag guilt flies when it wants to feel like a country.
When I finally told her, in her kitchen, both of us standing because some sentences cannot be said sitting down, I had rehearsed for weeks. I got out maybe eight words. Priya put down the knife she was using on the ginger, very carefully, and said:
"I know. I've known since Diwali."
Eight months.
She had seen us at the flower market in November, my hand in his jacket pocket, and had gone home and waited for me to tell her. Through her birthday. Through her father's retirement dinner. Through a hundred phone calls where she asked what was new and I said... nothing much.
"I don't care that it's Aman," she said, and her voice did the thing it does before she cries, which I have known since we were nine. "I ended that story myself. I'd have teased you about it for a year, and then I'd have danced at your wedding. What I care about is that you looked at me for eight months and decided I was too small to survive your happiness."
Falling for him was never the betrayal. The betrayal was the year I let her love a version of me that no longer existed.
She asked me to leave. Not forever, she said. Just now. In twenty years we had never once needed the word forever, and hearing her have to specify it was the single worst moment of this entire story, worse than any part involving him.
The Empty Chair
We were engaged by the next winter. I sent Priya the invitation myself, no envelope, hand to hand, on her doorstep, the way we used to deliver each other's love letters in school. She looked at the card for a long time.
"I might come," she said.
She did not come.
The photograph proves it: me in red, looking at a door. My mother says no one noticed. Mothers lie beautifully. I danced at my own wedding, and loved my husband, and grieved my friend, and learned that a heart does all three at once without asking permission, the way lungs breathe during a funeral.
Here is the turn I did not see coming, the one I am still not fully over.
Eleven days after the wedding, a parcel arrived. Inside was a small silver anklet, scratched, the clasp mended with wire, and I sat down on the floor of my new house because I knew it instantly.
We had bought a pair of them, one each, at a fair in 1999, with pooled pocket money, and sworn some solemn nine-year-old oath. I had lost mine within the year. She had kept hers for two decades without ever mentioning it.
The note said: "For the marriage, long life and happiness. For you, I need more time. Wear this so some part of me was there."
Not forgiveness. A receipt for it, postdated.
It has been three years. We speak now, carefully, the way you walk on a leg that was broken: it works, it carries weight, it aches before rain. She has met my husband as my husband exactly four times, and the fourth time she argued with him about cricket for an hour, and I stood in the kitchen listening to the two of them shout statistics, crying quietly into a bowl of ginger, happier than I was at my own reception.
I wrote about all of it eventually, because I could not afford the therapy hours this actually required. It started with a prompt that started it all: write about something you stole. I meant to write about him. Every draft came out about her. I finally understood I had not stolen a man, no one owns a man, but I had stolen months of truth from a person who had earned it in a currency of decades, and the poems only worked when I wrote toward forgiveness as something you ask for, not something you deserve. The best one, the one I can still not read aloud, sits with the others about love, filed where it belongs.
People ask me, when they hear the outline of this story, whether it was worth it. They mean the marriage. I always answer yes, and it is true.
But some nights I look at my left hand, at the wedding ring, and then at my right ankle, at a scratched silver anklet mended with wire, and I know which one took more mending.
Both were worth it. Only one was owed.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.