The Woman Who Cried on the Morning Train
An entire compartment pretended not to see, and one aunty didn't.
There is a rule on the Mumbai local that nobody teaches you and everybody knows: if a woman is crying by the window, you have not seen her.
I learned the rule the way you learn all city rules, by watching it enforced. It was the 8:47 Borivali slow, ladies compartment, a Wednesday in July with the rain doing its usual production number on the roof. I was twenty-six, eleven months into the city, commuting to a job in Lower Parel that paid me in money and took payment in everything else. I had my spot by then, second compartment, left side, and I knew the regulars the way you know characters in a serial you keep meaning to stop watching.
The woman in the green kurta was not a regular.
She sat by the window and she was crying, and she was not doing any of the things we do to make crying acceptable in public. She was not hiding behind sunglasses. She was not pretending it was the wind. She was not on the phone, which at least gives tears a plot. She just sat there while the water ran down her face in the exact rhythm of the rain on the glass, as if the weather were happening on both sides of the window, and she let it.
The compartment performed its blindness beautifully. I want to be fair: it is not cruelty, or not only. It is what the city calls manners. Forty women suddenly found their phones fascinating. Two friends lowered their voices out of a kind of respect. The fisherwomen near the door went on talking, but angled away, giving her the only privacy anyone can give on a train, which is the pretense of it.
I did what I did best that year. I watched, and I did nothing... and I filed it away in the place where I kept everything I was too tired to feel.
Then the aunty in the purple flowered saree opened her bag.
I knew this aunty by sight. Boarded at Andheri, forearms like a woman who had carried her share and several other people's, a tiffin that smelled of methi at eight in the morning, which should be illegal or mandatory, I have never decided. She rummaged, produced a handkerchief, ironed, folded into a triangle, and held it out to the crying woman without a single introductory word.
The woman looked at it like she had been handed a passport to a country she thought had deported her.
“Le,” the aunty said. Take it.
She took it.
And then the aunty did the thing I have now been carrying for years. She reached back into the bag, took out an orange, peeled it in one long unhurried spiral like there was no train and no city and no clock, split it, and handed the woman half.
“Ro, beta. Rone ka.” Cry, child. Crying is allowed. “Par khaali pet nahi.” But not on an empty stomach.
The woman made a sound I have never forgotten, half sob and half laugh, the sound of a person being caught mid-fall by someone they have never met. She ate the orange in pieces, crying, while the aunty sat beside her and talked about nothing at all: the rain, the price of mangoes ending, a nephew's wedding. Not one question. Not one “what happened.” She built a little shed of ordinary words and let the woman weep inside it, dry.
Nobody clapped. This is not that kind of story, and Mumbai is not that kind of city. The train just kept doing its work, and at Dadar the aunty stood, patted the woman's shoulder once, and gathered her bags. On her way out she passed me, and she must have seen everything I thought I had hidden, the watching, the filing away, because she looked directly at me and said two words.
“Seekh le.” Learn it.
Then the platform swallowed her, the way platforms do.
The city teaches you not to see. Some women unlearn it, one orange at a time.
I would love to tell you I transformed on the spot... I did not.
I got off at Lower Parel, attended four meetings, and told the story at lunch as a charming thing I had witnessed, already smoothing it into an anecdote, which is what we do to moments that are actually instructions.
Eight months later, the phone call came while I was boarding the 8:47.
My father... A biopsy. My mother's voice doing the terrible bright thing, the “nothing to worry, they just want to check” voice, the voice that is a white sheet thrown over furniture.
The doors closed. The train moved.
And I stood there with the phone still in my hand and discovered that the crying had started without any decision from me, the exact way it had rained on that Wednesday, weather happening on both sides of some window.
I got the seat by the glass... Of course I did. The compartment saw me and unsaw me in one smooth practiced motion, forty phones blooming, voices lowering, the choreography I knew so well from the audience side.
I understood it now from the stage. It is not hatred, that blindness. It is a wall, and the wall is even lonelier than it looks from the outside, and I had helped build it every single morning for two years.
Then a college girl in a canvas tote sat down next to me.
She could not have been more than nineteen. She did not ask what happened. She rummaged in the tote, and I swear some part of me knew before her hand came out, because there are lineages in this world that have nothing to do with blood. She handed me a paper napkin from some canteen, and one of those flat sweets, an eclair, half melted, the kind that lives at the bottom of every Indian bag since the beginning of bags.
“Aunty rule,” she said, like it explained everything. Maybe it did... Maybe somewhere on some other train, some other purple saree had looked at her one morning and said, learn it.
I cried the whole way to Lower Parel with a toffee in my cheek, and it was the least alone I had felt in two years.
My father, since you are wondering, was lucky. The word benign is the most beautiful word in any language and I will hear no arguments. But something in me stayed changed even after the fear passed, the way a riverbank stays shaped after the flood goes home. I started writing that year, badly, at night, about the aunty and the orange peel coming off in one spiral, about the specific loneliness of being unseen in a crowd, and later, when I could, about what healing actually looks like, which in my experience is not sunrise over mountains. It is citrus and a train and a stranger's ironed handkerchief. I even entered the orange poem into a monthly poetry contest, hands shaking over the button, and whatever happened to it afterward mattered less than this: writing it forced me to see her clearly, and seeing, it turns out, was the whole lesson.
These days I board the 8:47 with two handkerchiefs, both ironed. One is mine.
The other is for whoever the window chooses next. Because I have learned the real rule now, the one under the rule they teach you. The city says: you have not seen her.
See her anyway.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.