I Stopped Going to Church and Nobody Asked Why
The pew filled in behind me, and that hurt more than any sermon.
For eleven years I sat in the third pew from the front, left side, aisle end, and then one Sunday in October I simply did not show up.
There was no scandal. Nobody hurt me. The pastor did not run off with the building fund. I want to say that first, because when people picture someone leaving a church quietly, they picture a wound with a name on it. Mine had no name. Mine was a tide going out so slowly that you only notice when the boats are sitting in the mud.
It started with the hymns. I would stand with the hymnal open, the organ swelling under Blessed Assurance, and my mouth would make the words while some other part of me stood off to the side watching, arms crossed, unconvinced. The words felt like mail addressed to a previous tenant. I kept opening it anyway, out of habit, out of the hope that one envelope would still have my name on it.
Then the words got heavier than the music. Then the silence between them got louder than both. I do not know how to explain doubt to someone who has not had it, except to say it is not dramatic. It is not a lightning bolt in reverse. It is a slow leak in a back tire, and one morning you are simply sitting lower than you used to.
The mechanics of leaving are almost embarrassing. You do not resign from a pew. There is no form to sign. You just wake up on a Sunday and make pancakes instead, and the whole time the butter is browning you are listening for something... a knock, a phone, a feeling. That first Sunday I ate at the kitchen table at 10:15, exactly when the call to worship would have started, and I felt like a kid skipping school whose parents had not noticed he was home.
The second Sunday was easier. The third was easier than that.
Ease, it turns out, is its own kind of grief.
Nobody called.
I need you to sit with that the way I had to.
Eleven years.
I taught Vacation Bible School twice. I helped repaint the fellowship hall a color the committee called Harvest Wheat and the rest of us called beige. I knew whose casserole to avoid at potlucks and whose to get to early. And for six weeks, the only contact I had from that building was a group text from Denise asking if I could still do the funeral luncheon rota, sent to nineteen people, my name somewhere in the middle like a bead on a string.
I typed, "I might be stepping back for a while." I deleted it. I typed, "Sure." I sent that instead.
Casseroles are easier than confessions.
Sundays reorganized themselves around my absence with insulting speed. I walked by the river. I learned that the diner on Fourth has a 9 a.m. crowd of exactly the same regulars every week, nodding to each other over eggs, a congregation with better coffee. I sat among them and thought, so this is where the other lapsed people go, and nobody here asks what I believe either, and somehow from them it feels like courtesy instead of neglect.
Around week nine I did the thing I always do when I cannot say something out loud. I wrote it down. Badly at first, then less badly. I wrote about the specific loneliness of being unmissed, which is different from being alone the way a cavity is different from a missing tooth. One night I got brave, or lonely enough that it looked like brave, and I posted one of those poems on a community wall for poets. A stranger in another time zone commented, "I left in March. Nobody asked me either." We have never spoken again.
I think about her every week.
At Christmas I went back. Not out of faith... Out of the same instinct that makes you drive past a house you used to live in.
I came in late, on purpose, and stood at the back near the coat racks that still smelled like wet wool and peppermint. And there it was... my pew, third from the front, left side. A young family sat in it. Two kids in matching red sweaters, a diaper bag where my Bible used to go, a father whispering something that made the mother put her hand over her laugh.
The pew had filled in behind me like water.
The church had healed over the hole I left the way skin heals, completely, without a scar, without a single mark to prove I was ever there.
Nobody asked why I left, and after a while I understood that this was the answer to the question I had been too afraid to ask while I was still in the building.
I always thought community meant being held. Maybe it just means being scheduled. The choreography goes on with whoever shows up; the dance was never about the dancer. I do not say that with bitterness anymore, though it took a long time to say it without any. An institution can love you in aggregate and not notice you in particular, and both of those things are true at once, and neither one is a lie.
In February I ran into Ray at the hardware store. Ray was the greeter, eighty-one, hands like tree bark, the man who had shaken my hand roughly five hundred and seventy times. He was holding a bag of birdseed and he looked at me the way you look at a word you know you know.
"We lost you," he said. Not where have you been. Not we miss you at church. We lost you, the way you say it about a glove.
"I lost me too, Ray," I said, and we both laughed like it was a joke, because in a hardware store in February, with the salt melting off our boots, it almost was.
He did not ask why... But he put his hand on my shoulder, birdseed and all, and he held it there one second longer than politeness required. That second is the closest thing to a benediction I have received in two years, and I have decided to count it.
I am not going back. I know that now the way you know your own address. But I have not stopped listening for whatever I used to listen for in that room. Some Sundays I still write toward it, poems that are half argument and half a stubborn kind of hope, prayers with the address scratched out. I even sent one to a monthly poetry contest once, my hands hovering over the keyboard like it was an offering plate.
Most evenings I drive past the church on my way home from work. In December they leave the sanctuary lights on, and the stained glass throws blue and red onto the snow, and it is honestly beautiful, the way a thing can be beautiful when it is no longer yours.
There is a peppermint in my coat pocket from the jar Mrs. Aldous kept by the door. It has been there for two years. I do not eat it... and I do not throw it away.
Some doors you do not walk through anymore. You just keep the candy from beside them, and you drive past slow.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.