I Failed the Exam Everyone Expected Me to Top
The topper's fall is a public event; the recovery is private.
The results came out at ten in the morning, and by ten fifteen three neighbours had already called my mother. Not to console her. Consolation was the costume. They called the way people slow down near an accident, and my mother stood in the kitchen saying 'yes, yes, we will see, yes' in a voice ironed completely flat, while I sat in my room refreshing a government website that had already told me the truth twice.
Mathematics: 34. Passing marks: 35.
One mark.
In the subject I had topped for four straight years. In the subject whose Olympiad certificates were laminated and hung in the hall, because in our house we laminated things we were proud of, and I was the most laminated child in the colony.
You have to understand what I was in that school.
Not a student, a prediction.
Teachers said my name to other students the way you cite a law. The coaching centre had already asked my father for a photograph, in advance, for the banner they printed every year with the toppers' faces floating over a sunrise. I had seen eleven years of those banners. I knew exactly which corner my face would occupy.
What happened in that exam hall is both simple and impossible to explain. I opened the paper and the first question was easy... and something in my chest disagreed.
My heartbeat became a thing I could hear. The numbers stayed numbers, they refused to become anything else, and forty minutes went by in what felt like four, and the invigilator's sandals went slap, slap, slap down the aisle like a clock that had learned to walk. I wrote whatever surfaced. I remember the last half hour mostly as the taste of the pencil I had chewed straight through the paint.
Years later a doctor would give that morning a name... and the name would help. That day, nobody in my town had a word for it except the one they used: shame.
The school marked its response quickly. My photograph came down from the 'Our Achievers' board. Nobody announced it... I just went to collect a certificate in June and there was a rectangle of brighter paint where I used to be. The coaching centre's banner went up in July with a different boy over the sunrise. His father distributed sweets to our building.
My father accepted his box with both hands and said congratulations like a gentleman, and I watched him do it from the balcony and wished the ground would file the necessary paperwork and take me.
That whole monsoon I did not leave the house except after dark. It rained the way it only rains when you are seventeen and disgraced, in long grey sheets against the window, and I sat with my forehead on the glass feeling the thunder in the pane. My mother brought tea without commentary, which is the highest form of love available in an Indian household. The compartment exam, the one where you retake a single failed subject, was scheduled for September. The word compartment itself felt like a verdict. Trains have compartments. So, apparently, do reputations.
Here is where the story turns, and it did not turn the way I expected.
One night in August my father knocked on my door, which he never did, the door was usually just opened, and he came in holding a brown envelope so old it had gone soft at the corners like cloth. He put it on my desk and sat on the edge of my bed and said nothing... while I opened it.
Inside was a marksheet from 1987. His name. His board exams.
English: failed.
A red circle around it, made by some clerk four decades ago, still red... red does not fade in a closed envelope.
My father, the man who checked my report cards with a ruler under each line. The man whose handwriting I had believed was incapable of error.
'I sat again in September,' he said. 'Passed with fifty-eight. Nobody in this family has ever seen this paper. Your grandfather burned my banner in his head long before anyone printed one.' He tapped the red circle once. 'The mark is not the injury. The hiding is the injury. I hid for thirty-five years. You will not.'
A topper's fall is a public event, with an audience and a banner and sweets for the building. Nobody sells tickets to the recovery. You get up in an empty theatre, alone, and that is the performance that makes you.
I studied that September for a different examiner. Not the board, not the neighbours, not the rectangle of bright paint. I studied to be able to sit in a hall with my own heartbeat and stay. My mother taught me a trick her mother used before temple crowds: name five things you can see, four you can hear, three you can touch. It is an old trick and it worked in a plastic chair in a strange school where nobody knew my prediction, so nobody was disappointed, and the numbers turned back into shapes and doors the way they used to.
Sixty-one out of a hundred.
The lowest marks of my life, and the only ones I have ever been proud of.
The rest is quieter than anyone's version of it. I did not get the college from the banner sunrise. I got a lesser college, where nobody had heard of me, which turned out to be the greatest gift of that entire year: the freedom of being nobody's prediction. I studied what I liked instead of what I led. I found out I liked words nearly as much as numbers, on the nights the old shame came back and I needed somewhere to put it. I filled notebooks. Much later I found pages online meant for exactly this, poems gathered under healing, and read strangers describing my exam hall in their own languages, the heartbeat, the sandals, the taste of pencil. One midnight I wrote thirty lines about the rectangle of brighter paint and sent it to a monthly poetry contest before I could stop myself. It did not win... Submitting it was the win, if you want the honest accounting, because it was the first time I had raised my hand in public since the sweets went around my building. Later I even worked through lessons on writing properly, and discovered that revision is just the compartment exam of poetry, and I have already made my peace with compartment exams.
My father died three years ago. Going through his steel cupboard, I found the soft brown envelope again, and inside it, folded together with his 1987 marksheet, was mine. Mathematics: 34. He had kept the failure, not the laminated certificates. Both papers, father and son, pressed flat against each other in the dark for years, keeping each other company.
I have them framed now, side by side, one red circle and one near miss, hanging where the achievers' photographs used to hang in my head. When it rains hard I still sometimes sit with my forehead against the window glass, out of old habit, feeling the thunder arrive in the pane. But these days it feels less like hiding.
It feels like the sound an empty theatre makes, just before the person on stage gets up.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.