I Found Our Old Chats and Read Every One
Scrolling up is the cheapest and cruelest form of time travel.
It started because I needed a plumber's number. That is the truth, and I want it on record, because everything that happened after midnight that Tuesday makes more sense if you know I was only looking for a man named Santosh who fixes geysers.
I typed "Santosh" into the search bar of my messages. My phone, helpful as a knife, returned a chat from four years ago: me telling Aman that Santosh had finally fixed the geyser, and Aman replying, "a hero in our time. tell him I said namaste," and just like that there it was, the whole thread. Three years of us, 2019 to 2022, sitting in my phone the entire time like water behind a wall.
I had never deleted it. I had told myself, and two therapists, and one very patient best friend, that I had moved on so completely that deleting it would have been giving it importance. The chat sat there for four years the way a sealed room sits in a house. You do not go in. You also, notably, do not brick it shut.
It was 12:40 a.m. I had work in the morning.
I scrolled to the top.
The first message in the thread is from me. "hey :) got your number from Priyanka, you left your charger at her party." His reply came four minutes later. "keep it. now you owe me a coffee and i know where to find you." I remember reading that on a bus in 2019 and smiling so widely a stranger smiled back.
For the first hour it was exactly the warm drowning I expected. The inside jokes rose off the screen like steam. The running bit about the pigeon on my balcony that he named Mr. Chaturvedi. The photo of two coffee cups on his tiny table the first morning I stayed over, captioned "yours is the chipped one, know your place." The message where he misspelled "love" as "loev" the first time he said it, panicked, and sent seventeen corrections until I replied "i loev you too."
I had forgotten none of it, is the thing... I had just kept it in a room I did not enter.
Around 2 a.m., somewhere in late 2021, the archive stopped agreeing with me.
The story I had told for four years, at parties, to therapists, to myself in the shower where all the best prosecutions happen, was simple: Aman went cold. Aman got distant, stopped trying, faded until I had no choice. I was the one who fought for us.
I had grieved as the abandoned one, and grief with a villain in it is so much easier to carry. It is grief with handles.
But the transcript.
The transcript did not know the story it was supposed to support.
There he was in November 2021, asking, "you okay? you've been one word answers all week." And there I was: "fine." There he was in January: "i feel like i keep reaching and you keep being busy. tell me how to reach you and i'll do it. genuinely. instructions welcome." I had replied, eleven hours later, "lol you're being dramatic."
I read a message where he asked me to dinner for his promotion and I said I was exhausted, and I sat there at 2 a.m., four years too late, with a sick feeling, because I remembered that exhaustion. Some of it was my job falling apart, which he knew about. Some of it was a bitterness I had decided he deserved for reasons the chat did not contain because they had never existed outside my head.
Scroll after scroll, the pattern held. He apologised first after every fight, including two that the timestamps clearly show I started. He remembered my mother's surgery date. I forgot his father's retirement.
In the last months his messages got shorter, yes, exactly the way I always described. What I never mentioned, because I had genuinely stopped seeing it, was the year of long messages before that, each one a hand held out, each one meeting "fine" and "lol" and "k."
Cold... I had called him cold to anyone who would listen.
I was reading the chat of a man swimming toward a person who kept moving the shore.
Memory is a novelist. The archive is a witness.
The last message in the thread is his. I knew it was there. It was the one thing in that sealed room I had never once been able to pretend away. March 2022, 9:14 p.m. "I hope someday you read all this back, top to bottom. Not for me. I just think you'll be kinder to both of us after."
I never replied.
Ten days later he collected his books, and Mr. Chaturvedi the pigeon outlived our entire relationship.
I sat in the dark with the phone on two percent battery, and I did the thing you do at 3 a.m.: I opened a reply box that had been closed for four years and started typing. "I read them. You were right."
My thumb hovered...
He is married now. She seems kind in the photographs. There is a message you owe someone and there is a peace you owe them, and at some point the first becomes the enemy of the second. I deleted it letter by letter... slowly, like walking backward out of a room.
But something had to be done with what I was holding, because grief you have carried wrongly does not just sit back down when corrected. It stands there... It wants a new job.
So I gave it one. Over the next weeks I wrote, badly at first, then less badly. There was a prompt that started it all: write about a message you never answered. What came out was not about Aman, not really. It was about memory, how it edits for survival, how it hands you a story you can live with and quietly shreds the footage. And underneath that poem, another one, harder to write, about forgiveness, the unglamorous kind, the kind you have to extend to yourself with clenched teeth because there is no one left to absolve you and the person you wronged has a new last name.
I will not pretend some final message from him would have been better than the poems. It would have been. But the poems were what was available, and they were honest, which the story I told at parties never was. I stopped telling that story, by the way. Someone asked me last month why we broke up and I heard myself say, "I stopped answering and he stopped asking," and the sentence cost me something, and it was correct, and both of those facts felt clean.
The phone died at 3:40 a.m. that first night, screen going dark in my hands like a window at the end of a street. I did not screenshot anything. I did not delete the thread either. It is still there, sealed room and witness stand both, the full unedited transcript of a love I finally read in its own words instead of mine.
Santosh came on Thursday and fixed the geyser in twenty minutes. Some things, it turns out, can simply be repaired. You just have to call while there is still someone on the other end.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.