The Business That Failed Beautifully
We lost the shop but kept every friendship and most of the lessons.
On our last day of business, we sold more than we had in any month of being open, because everything was free.
The shop was called Second Chapter, a used bookshop and coffee counter in an old converted house with a blue door that stuck in humid weather, which in our town meant it stuck from May to September. Three of us owned it: me, Tara, and Wallace, three friends who had spent a decade saying "someday we should" over drinks until one January we ran out of excuses at the same time, which is a beautiful and financially catastrophic thing to have happen simultaneously to three people.
We did everything right, according to us.
We did almost nothing right, according to arithmetic.
The house had crooked floors that made the bookshelves lean like conspirators. The coffee machine was secondhand and had opinions. We hosted open mic nights on Thursdays where the same eleven people came every week, and a book club that once argued about a novel's ending so intensely that a woman named Carol did not speak to her sister for a month, both of them still attending, sitting at opposite ends of the room like a divorced couple at a wedding. We knew our regulars' orders and their dogs' names and, eventually, their sorrows, because a bookshop with a coffee counter is a confessional with better lighting.
What we did not know was our numbers. Or rather, we knew them the way you know a distant relative is unwell: vaguely, sadly, from a distance... hoping someone else is handling it.
The Meeting Above the Shop
The end announced itself in October, in the little room upstairs where we did the accounts, or where the accounts did us. Wallace, who among the three of us was the closest thing to responsible, laid out the spreadsheet and said, "We have four months. Five if the boiler doesn't do anything dramatic."
The boiler, hearing this, did something dramatic in November.
Here is what I expected to happen next, because I had read about failing businesses: the blame. The autopsy where everyone holds a different knife. Tara had insisted on the expensive espresso machine. I had ordered too much literary fiction and not enough of what people bought. Wallace had priced the coffee like we owed the beans an apology. There was plenty of blame to distribute, a whole warehouse of it, fully stocked, unlike our bestseller shelf.
Instead, Tara looked at the spreadsheet for a long time... and said, "Okay. Then we have four months to close it properly. Let's not let it die like a shop. Let's let it finish like a book."
Let's not let it die like a shop. Let's let it finish like a book.
I think about that sentence more than I think about the entire rest of the business.
So that is what we did. We stopped trying to save it, which freed up an astonishing amount of energy, the way a patient sometimes gets vivid and funny once the fight is over. We announced a closing date in a letter we taped to the blue door. We spent the last months doing every impractical thing we had postponed for being impractical. Poetry night went weekly. Tara printed writing prompts on the coffee sleeves, one line each, and customers started leaving their responses tucked between books for strangers to find, and some of those strangers wrote back, and for a few months our shelves ran a postal service for people who had never met.
Carol read a poem at the second-to-last open mic about her sister.
Her sister was in the room.
That is all I am going to tell you about that... except that the espresso machine chose that exact silence to hiss, and everyone laughed, and the laugh let the crying start. Someone later posted the poem, with Carol's blessing, on a community wall for poets, where people who had never stood in our shop read it and understood everything anyway.
The Last Day
On the final Saturday we gave away the stock. Every book free, limit ten, a limit we enforced with no seriousness whatsoever. The line went down the street and around the corner past the pharmacy. People we had never seen came, and people we had seen every week came and stood in line anyway, holding books they had definitely already read, because the line itself was the point.
An old man took a water-damaged atlas and told me he had proposed to his wife in a bookshop like ours in 1971, in the geography section, "because she loved maps and I loved certainty." I gave him the atlas and had to go stand in the stockroom for a minute.
We failed, let me be clear. This is not a story where a mysterious investor appears in the final act. We lost our savings, differing amounts, all of them the amount that hurts. For a while I flinched whenever anyone said the word "entrepreneur." The blue door got painted gray by the accounting firm that took over the lease, which felt like a small violence, and I took a photo of it the day before, the blue one, stuck in its frame, faithful to the end.
But here is the inventory nobody asked us to file. Three friendships went into that business and three came out, scuffed but load-bearing, which if you know anything about money and friends is the rarest outcome on the books.
Wallace does the accounts now for four small shops in town and is gentle with their owners in the upstairs-room meetings, because he knows what the spreadsheet feels like from the other side of the table. Tara runs the open mic at the library, first Thursday of the month, same eleven people, plus about forty more. Carol and her sister sit together.
And I write.
That was the strangest salvage of all. I had spent two years selling other people's words and never once making my own, and it took losing the shop to start. The first thing I wrote that mattered was about the last day, the line around the corner, the atlas man, and when I finished it I understood I had been circling hope the whole time, which embarrassed me, because I had set out to write about ruin. Later I wrote about the gray door and found I was writing about new beginnings instead, which embarrassed me again. Apparently I cannot write a proper tragedy. I have made my peace with this defect.
People ask if I would do it again, and they ask it carefully, the way you ask someone about an ex. The answer is yes... and not in the wise, laundered way, not "yes, for the lessons." Yes because for three years there was a house with a blue door where the shelves leaned like conspirators and the machine hissed and eleven people read poems on Thursdays, and it existed because three friends ran out of excuses at the same time.
The atlas man still sends a card every Christmas. He addresses it to "The Bookshop," no street... no number.
It arrives.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.