I Forgave Her for My Own Sake
The apology never came, so I stopped waiting at that particular door.
For thirty years I kept a speech in my chest the way some people keep a will in a drawer. It was for my mother, and it began with the words... do you have any idea what you did.
I revised it constantly. In the shower. In traffic. In the middle of other people's weddings. It had a structure, an arc, devastating evidence. Exhibit A: the fifth grade recital she missed because a bottle of gin needed her more, me on stage in a costume she never saw, scanning the third row... until the lights went down. Exhibit B: the thing she said when I was thirteen, four words I will not print, delivered casually while frying eggs, that took three therapists and two decades to pull out of me like shrapnel. Exhibit C: the morning she left for Arizona with a man named Chuck who sold above ground pools, two weeks before my fifteenth birthday, and the card that arrived in April signed, with love, Mom, as if love were a stamp she had licked on the way out.
The speech ended, always, with her crying. That part was important. In every version, she cried, and she said, I am so sorry, I see it now, I see all of it.
And then, in the fantasy, something in my ribs would come loose and I would finally get to set the whole cargo down.
I carried that speech through college, a marriage, two kids of my own. I carried it through eleven Christmases of not speaking to her and through the stiff, weatherproof phone calls that came after. Twice a year, birthdays and New Year's, both of us performing a truce over a landline. She never mentioned the past. She spoke about her tomatoes and her neighbor's dog as if I had been issued a childhood in decent working order and simply misplaced it.
My therapist, a patient woman named Dr. Okafor who deserves a statue, once asked me a question I hated so much I nearly left.
“What is your plan if the apology never comes?”
I did not have one... Waiting was the plan. Waiting had always been the plan. I had built my whole interior around a door, and I stood guard at it like a soldier of some fallen empire, decades after the war, still saluting.
Then, three years ago, my aunt Carol called and said, “Your mother put the kettle in the refrigerator again. You should come.”
I flew to Arizona with the speech rehearsed and ready. I am not proud of that. My mother was losing her mind by the fistful and I sat on that plane doing final revisions, because some part of me believed this was the deadline, the last window in which she could hear the charges read.
She opened the door of the little stucco house, and her whole face lit up, and she said, “Bonnie! You came all this way!”
Bonnie is her sister. Bonnie died in 1989.
I stood on the doorstep of that house with my beautiful terrible speech in my chest, and I looked at a small confused woman in a cardigan buttoned wrong, and I understood that the person I had been prosecuting for thirty years had left the building.
Not died. Left.
The woman who missed the recital, the woman at the stove with her four cruel words, the woman in Chuck's car with the window down, none of them lived there anymore.
There was nobody left to confess.
I drank tea with her. She told me a story about a school dance in 1962, twice, both times delighted. She patted my hand and called me Bonnie and asked if I remembered the yellow dress, and I heard my own voice say, “Of course I do,” and she laughed like a girl.
In the rental car outside, I sat for an hour and did not turn the key.
Grief has a shape when someone dies. There are casseroles, rituals, words on cards. There is nothing for this: mourning an apology that has become extinct while its owner is still alive. I could not get the words I was owed. There was no longer anyone qualified to say them.
Which meant, and this took me months to accept... the debt could not be collected. It could only be forgiven or carried. Those were the whole options. There was no third drawer.
Forgiveness was not a gift I handed my mother. It was a door I finally stopped standing guard at.
I want to be careful here, because I hate the greeting card version of this. Forgiving her did not mean deciding it was fine. It was not fine. It will never be fine.
Forgiving her did not mean forgetting, or trusting, or pretending the recital seat was not empty. What it meant was this... I resigned. I quit the job of waiting.
I stopped keeping the ledger current, stopped revising the speech, stopped standing at attention outside a door that no one was ever going to open from the other side.
The strange part is what the work actually looked like. It was not one lightning moment. It was letters I wrote and never sent, eleven of them, each one angrier and then somehow shorter than the last, until the final one was a single line. It was Dr. Okafor's office and a lot of ugly crying about family, the kind of crying that ruins your face for a day. It was, of all things, poems. I started writing them at 51 like a fool, in a notebook I hid from my husband as if it were an affair. Nearly all of them circled forgiveness, prodding it, testing whether it was load bearing. One of them I finally read out loud to my daughter at her kitchen table, and she cried, and then I did, and it did more work in four minutes than the speech had done in thirty years. The speech was for my mother. The poem, it turned out, was for me. That was the whole difference, and I found others writing their way along the same road toward healing, which helped on the nights I doubted the road existed.
My mother died in January, on a Tuesday, holding Carol's hand. At the funeral, people said kind, smoothed over things about her, and I let them. A woman is allowed more than her worst decade. I have needed that clause myself.
In the spring, driving through my old city for a conference, I did something I had avoided for years. I drove to the house. The one from before Arizona, before Chuck, before the eggs.
The new owners have painted the front door yellow. There is a bike dropped sideways on the lawn, a kid's bike, pink tassels on the handlebars, abandoned mid adventure the way bikes are only abandoned in front of safe houses. I stood at the gate for a minute... I did not go in. I did not need to. Whatever I had left standing guard there had been relieved of duty a while ago.
The door I waited at my whole life never opened.
So I stopped knocking, and turned around, and found the entire sky at my back.
By Team Writory, for Writory.
Enter a Writory poetry contest
Enter the September contest and have your own poem read and scored. That first entry makes you a Writorian.